Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutStaff Report BOCC 10.18.10 CR 306t- " cfl o ,L v l/*'t'r' Exhibits to Public Hearing on 70/1,8/10 (BOCC) Exhibits A Proof of Mailing B Garfield County Unified land Use Resolution of 2008, as amended C Garfield County Comprehensive Plan of 2000, as amended D Staff Report dated 10/18/10 E Draft Resolution with Exhibits Attached F Email from County Attorney to Jenna Keller dated 7OlO5/10 G Email from ienna Keller to County Attorney dated 10/05/10 ? L /'/ + ,il'h"Cr//]r/ / r'1 /tu,L /'6,4' AI,t /w,/71 %on' Lrl /h;lt" 'f .' tt 3 4o? ) r om 'n' /2"*/ / Q"ry Road 306 RoW Vacation BOCC October 18, 2010 PROJECT INFORMATION AND STAFF COMMENTS Request to Vacate a portion of CR 306 Spring Creek Road) and Accept a new P Hyrup Properties, LLLP, Connie A. Murra!ffiill Dutton, Dutton, Muriel Life Estate, David S. Dutton, Linda Marie Dixon, and the Dutton Family Limited Liability Partnership DTD Approximately 4 miles Southwest of Parachute Rural Approval /" Pl. , 'o4*"'z') GENERAL PROJECT LOCATION II. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND PURPOSE The vicinity map above points out the general location of CR 306 which is approximately 4 miles southwest of Parachute, CO. The landowners and the BOCC intend to vacate an old portion of County Road 306 known as Wallace / Spring Creek Road which exists as an old right-of-way (not improved as a road today) that loops through several properties listed on the cover of this memo which was deeded to the County years ago. lt is currently difficult to make out if you walk the right-of-way. The currently travelled public road will remain the same corridor travelled by the public today but will officially be deeded (50 ft. ROW) to eh County. The map below shows (as well as Exhibits A and B to the resolution in your packet) the areas to be vacated denoted by FJ EXHIBITtDREQUEST PROPERTY OWNERS LOCATION EXISTING ZONING RECOMMENDATION Q",, Road 306 RoW Vacation the hashed lines. The dark line will still be the which will be deeded to Garfield County. BOCC October 18, 2010 FJ County Road 306 as currently travelled today III. REFERRAL AGENCIES Pursuant to specific direction to Staff by the Board of County Commissioner BOCC) on Monday, October 4, 2010, the BOCC decided to waive all of the referral requirements codified in the Unified Land Use Resolution of 2008, as amended (ULUR). lV. REVIEW CRITERIA & STANDARDS in Section 4-110(C) of the ULUR RELATED TO ROAD VACATIONS Section 4-110(CX7) Planning Commission Review. lf appropriate, the Garfield County Planning Commission shall review all applications or petitions to vacate public roads or right-of- way pursuant to the provisions of 530-28-110(1) (d), C.R.S., as amended. The Planning Commission procedures are as follows: j *s^ilffi- /i=:\y',",",'r\ l-rlE ,, It_,t\;,/ rcmrri4ffiM. l2- W iffi..fi r.x.MilS M &U*IUX q} l1 llraiui H tr; eD m^rksrcErc{oac@(rqrumps a\ F.Buctrr fitilnm=--l\\V lpsu:<rr.rrro.qsl '\i-- i.fficft^v&.ds I'- :: - - -.*- l*r*r@tIlf:::J\-ir\'-- QO:ttuilrEr'/ -____-::::=_:__ --l_ *'- iwvals$@!lw i #[ rB. fftre s$ - BOCC October 18, 2010 FJ The Planning Commission shall conduct its review of the petition or application to vacate a county or public road right-of-way as a public hearing without required notification other than inclusion in a posted agenda. The date establish for initial review by the Planning Commission shall be considered the date of submission pursuant to $30-28-1 10, C. R.S., as amended. The Planning Commission may continue consideration of the petition or request to vacate county or public road rights-of-way to the next regularly scheduled Planning Commission meeting. Under all circumstances, it shall conclude its review and render its decision and recommendation to the BOCC within sixty (60) days of submission. The decision of the Planning Commission, rendered pursuant to its review set forth herein, shall be considered a recommendation. Under no circumstances shall the Planning Commission action be considered a vacation of a road or right-of-way or final action on such request. The Board of County Commissioners has the discretion to vacate a road, however certain vacations are prohibited per the following code section in 4-110. E. Prohibited Vacations. The Board of County Commissioners shall not approve any petition or request to vacate a county or pubic road right-of-way when the following information has been submitted to the BOCC. 1. The subject county road or public road right-of-way provides any access to public lands (for the purpose of this subsection public land shall mean any property owned by the federal government or the State of Colorado). Z. The subject county road or public road righ[of-way abuts or is connected to any property, including any easement owned by the federal government. State of Colorado, municipality, county, or special district, where such property or easement constitutes a public park, recreational area or trail. 3. The subject county road or public road right-of-way is currently used or will be used in the foreseeable future for any county or public road purpose. The term "county or public road purpose" includes, but is not limited to, motor vehicle use, pedestrian use, equestrian use, bicycle traffic, stock drive, or placement of utilities. The term "foreseeable use" shall include a use projected or planned to occur within the next twenty years as such has been include in any adopted state, county, federal, municipal or special district facilities plan, comprehensive plan, zoning plan, recreation plan, street plan, or similar document for development objectives for that entity. This provision shall apply only if documentation of the current or foreseeable use is presented at the time of public consideration of the proposal vacating resolution. 1 2. 3. 4 Q",, Road 306 RoW Vacation BOCC October L8, 2010 FJ 4. The Provisions of thls section shall not be deemed to preclude the BOCC's denial of a petition or application to vacated a county or public road right-of-way for other reasons. Staff Response: Staff finds the subject vacation is not in conflict with these criteria. V. REVIEW CRITERIA & STANDARDS FOR LOCATION AND EXTENT As you are aware, the BOCC recently adopted the "Location & Extent" regulations form the state statutes in to the ULUR. ln that regulation, the Planning Commission is required to determine whether the project (the road vacation in this case) conforms to the Comprehensive Plan. Staff Response: The existing Comprehensive Plan of 2000, as amended (the Comp Plan) does not specifically address Road Vacations. However, there are a few areas that support this action: A) Public Participation: The act to vacate a public righGof-way will be done in a publically noticed hearing before the BOCC ensuring that the public has a right to due process. B) Transportation: One goal is to specifically "ensure that the County transportation system (its roads) are safe, functional, and designed to handle existing and future levels of traffic..." This vacation cleans up an 18-year old discrepancy ensuring that the proper County road (the existing one) is the County road of preference and is located in a properly described / deeded ROW to Garfield County. Further, this vacation does not conflict with providing access to public lands as it does not currently do so. C) Agriculture: By formally establishing the current existing CR 306 as the public ROW and vacating the old ROW, it reduces that potential impact of an additional road way through open grazing lands by allowing that old right-of-way to return to a more natural state. Ultimately, Staff finds this vacation to be in the spirit of the applicable goals, objectives, and policies of the Comprehensive Plan. VI. PLANNING GOMMISSION REGOMMENDATION ON October 13, 2010, the Planning Commission forwarded a recommendation of approval to the Board of County Commissioners regarding the request to vacate a portion of the deeded right-of-way for County Road 306 with the following findings. 1. That the public hearing before the Board of County Commissioners was extensive or complete, that all pertinent facts, matters and issues were submitted and that all interested parties were heard at that meeting. 4 3. 4. Qrry Road 306 RoW Vacation BOCC October 18, 2010 FJ That the above stated and other reasons, the proposed vacation and acceptance of CR 306 right-of-way has been determined to be in the best interest of the health, safety, morals, convenience, order, prosperity and welfare of the citizens of Garfield County. That all representations made by the Applicant in the application, and at the public hearing before the BOCC shall be conditions of approval, unless specifically altered by the BOCC. The subject county road or public road right-of-way does not provide any access to public lands (for the purpose of this subsection public land shall mean any property owned by the federal government or the State of Colorado). The subject county road or public road right-of-way does not abut or is not connected to any property, including any easement owned by the federal government. State of Colorado, municipality, county, or special district, where such property or easement constitutes a public park, recreational area or trail. The subject county road or public road right-of-way is not currently used or will not be used in the foreseeable future for any county or public road purpose. The term "county or public road purpose" includes, but is not limited to, motor vehicle use, pedestrian use, equestrian use, bicycle traffic, stock drive, or placement of utilities. The term "foreseeable use" shall include a use projected or planned to occur within the next twenty years as such has been include in any adopted state, county, federal, municipal or special district facilities plan, comprehensive plan, zoning plan, recreation plan, street plan, or similar document for development objectives for that entity. This provision shall apply only if documentation of the current or foreseeable use is presented at the time of public consideration of the proposal vacating resolution. 5 6 EXHIBIT *€ir, STATEOFCOLORADO ) )ss. COUNTY OF GARFIELD ) At a regular meeting of the Board of County Commissioners for Garfield County, Colorado, held at the County Administration Building in Glenwood Springs on Monday, the - day of ----, 2010, there were present: Tr6si Houpt , Commissioner Mike Samson , Commissioner John Marlin , Commissioner Chairman Don K. DeFord , CountY AttorneY Ed Green , County Manager Jean 4&CuSe-, Clerk to the Board when the following proceedings, among others were had and done, to-wit: RESOLUTION NO. 10- A RESOLUTION CONCERNED WITH VACATING A PORTION OF PUBLIC ROAD RIGHT-OF.WAY OTHERWISE KNOWN AS A PORTION OF COLiNTY ROAD 306, ACCEPTING NEW PUBLIC ROAD RIGHT-OF-WAY AND RESERVING A PRIVATE ACCESS EASEMENT. WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Garfield County, State of Colorado ("BOCC") through resolution 2OO3-07, adopted a procedure for vacating public roads and rights- of-way; and WHEREAS, Resolution 2003-07 is mandatory for requests to vacate or abandon the entire width of a public road or County road; and WHEREAS, the BOCC have determined that for the requested vacation of portions of County Road 306, as set forth herein, certain provisions of Resolution 2003-07 shall not apply; and WHEREAS, the BOCC desires to vacate a portion of a dedicated public road right-of- way, as such lies within the property of the affected party as set forth below; and WHEREAS, the public road right-of-way as set forth below is no longer needed as a public road dght-of-way; and WHEREAS, the BOCC is entitled to vacate a public road right-of-way by resolution pursuant to the provisions of Section 43-2-303(1Xb), C.R.S. (2010); and WHEREAS, to the extent necessary a duly noticed public meeting was conducted by the BOCC concerning the need and appropriateness of vacating said public road right-of-way under the provisions of Section 43-2-303(2Xb), C.R'S. (2010); and WHEREAS, the purpose of this proceeding is to vacate that portion of the road right-of- way for County Road 306 which is no longer required; and WHEREAS, the Garfield County Planning Commission has conducted an appropriate location and extent review pursuant to the provisions of Section 30-28-110, C.R.S. (2010) and Article IV of the Garfield County Unified Land Use Resolution. WHEREAS, the BOCC is entitled to accept right-of-ways, properly dedicated to the public, for use by the public, and on behalf of the public, pursuant to the provisions of Section 43-2-20r(1)(a), C.R.S. (201 0). NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Board of County Commissioners of Garfield County, State of Colorado, as follows: 1. That the public meeting leading to vacation of this roadway was the subject of necessary notice to landowners adjacent to the roadway, to the extent such notice was required by the provisions of Section 43-2-303(2Xb), C.R.S. (2010) and Article IV of the Garfield County Unified Land Use Resolution. 2. That a public meeting was conducted at which testimony and evidence was presented concerning the vacation of portions of the subject road. No testimony or evidence was presented objecting to said vacation. Exhibits were presented supporting the finding of proper notice, if needed, and all interested parties were given an opportunity to attend, testify and present evidence. 3. That the vacation of the roadway was conducted in accordance with Garfield County Resolution 2OO3-07, or the BOCC waived compliance with those provisions, and Section 43 -2-303, C.R.S. (20 1 0). 4. That portion of the public road right-of-way of County Road 306, described in Exhibit A and B, ittached hereto, and all other right-of-ways in SW%SE% Section 1 and NWTTNE% Section 12 all in T8S, R96W, 6th P.M., should be and hereby are vacated except the new public road right-of-way set forth in Exhibits D, 1 and 2 attached hereto. 5. That pursuant to the foregoing vacation, title to such property including all oil, gas, and other minerals shall vest in the property owners of the abutting lands to the right-of- ways. 6. That pursuant to Section 43-2-302(1X0, C.R.S. (2010), the vesting of title to the vacated right-of-ways is subject to the private-access easement as set forth in Exhibit C attached hereto. 7. The foregoing vacation does not leave any property adjoining said public road right-o1--way without an established public road connecting said land with another established public road. 8. The vacated right-of-ways do not provide access to public lands, and therefore, this vacation does not leave any public land without access to a public road' 9. That this vacation is in the best interest and for the health, safety and welfare of the general public. 10. The BOCC hereby accepts as the new public road right-of-way the property deeded as forth in Exhibits D, 1 and 2 attached hereto. The acceptance by this Resolution is limited to the descriptions contained therein. DATED this - day of ,2010. ATTEST: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF GARFIELD COLINTY, STATE OF COLORADO By: Clerk to the Board Chairperson Upon motion duly made and seconded the foregoing Resolution was adopted by the following vote: Tr6si HouPt AYe Mike Samson AYe John Mar"tin AYe Commissioners STATE OF COLORADO ) ) ss. COUN]'Y OF GARFIELD ) t, Jean Alberico, County Clerk and ex-officio Clerk of the Board of County Commissioners in and for the Couttty and State aforesaid do hereby certify that the annexed and foregoing Resolution is truly copied from the Records of the Proceedings of the Board of iiounty Commissioners for said Garfield County, now in my office' IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the seal of said County, at Clenwood Springs, this - day of _-, A.D' 20-' County Clerk and ex-officio Clerk of the Board of County Commissioners T:\MyFiles\ROAD & BRIDGE\RESOLUTIONS\Vacating Portion of Public Road Right-of-Way- Portion of CR306 doc € a il irz (.) o j(8o.Em Ot .d^o.E 9os H? g EEq= =$#xc;g qEE eI eg IflE a 5?= Bit !,{.,l>tdlor T,YEr a {EBI H "dE 153*f;r:!E sEr.9!383{ "f,iE"i;-Htr .fi-'[:ESsa I3r EH;?3E EE: *BiiB5?ittH:*uu*'u!6: H t a-a' xHS r,;oBF=>;;;1 t!g;E i{g;ilfifrStg*ilil3 €fr5€S E?2?aaazad=vv3,! Ut:A iS *"i 8I3 3 3 3I3I n E*€!i ;ui+SeEEEEEEEE iH4s[ ?fi#; 5 !)/ To 1Jo 0) $>lJ)\o oolbo 0)Cdbo0.C -d'2d+J -'u ao.r{ }i _cEP EEE.Fl v b9t E cn,q x - fi.oYrEI3s33oAtEEOT€Eq(Y) ? I F"q u#ar€c L E e,Eq o; :;xE3#; h.$E s E+)(Volrlol-rzoa 93<O i FEO 3 s* q 9'lrboEr7 ^9'ia !r o.u<Ho cd C)6 op ffi#i:eEXHIBIT '6 5o6 I ol q a I E"-l ;EHl ;8 Hl 6Axl r''z Ell 6 t)9rEol e d'E I q coI E.9 :l!EZloa* F U - at il aA trz U ii e oL I c.l o cl I ?t:l? I ;Etil :P BHI ri€e Hl "iE F Hl =:5 ! l3;e :----: !:o I BiE 5.B .XE.$,ll E g ,U:8 t -a:^s. j ,,{ri;l I 3= fl(,'p: 'z\ "\H- \"{$r $N;IW i$ I Nlr iE I /#;' ' iELff/,/1gL#t,'oiEl /{// fj_l {r/ ; ,W *E/8/ fl Y tol I +r .E{o l7i tt 5 HEE i:l r E_HfE,8ll' frl B E eotVr'l oXtEfYi 8B;qH lEiBl{la - =='Ea o ---i ; 'oN Iaf,red I o oinoic -l <E;o"r^n I ! -o o ff3jJor- 6...u,'-ie5:"- /// Er-**- t a \, /[ H*B {,*r% Eq a EEEE qAP ffi =EEEIEEfl/ry"( &i"\X w_ H,{',ll a' ,zo8'. l'1 '4, ' e4l'@-+ tes\lEr g|3Et lEj ilF" I ,1fil- t /PJ;-ft-Qqoo* // t \ 'n* l' I t) I /'' I Ir al I lf ,: I ;t lttx I =l l?i=l t N lEEel ININEII Larzbl P 611l!ilz f'-li co.fi =B=l ci rna a- 7 \f rna{- rda Y ooX o.ct co,looco3i.9 c O .ts -o.9;HEioooxEOAJ, o- do OF tr.: = .= aa9 b'i tr O g*5'i ci r o hoL, h ;= C cdXEoq)d<: *o.9 ii'<8+{,' co d.qc6X! H VJ '93"qE8f&dY(dd oE cgrr)O- F d-l; c^, a",-aXi-'- o rt3 H ps' .- .=^ ?st.;GEO O oO oZDqc.)0( zI0-00-I I I-ztlz 'oN IarrEd f slflr(qd 'du.(g g/3 4111 sargrado:4 dn:.611 'JI Iicdl(d otr I ^ do IE E-'E IE< Ya I)I:< o-ou /\ d tn-cdCf-lf-ci6> -U.\rH --r-qv i9!.lcD- omr; 0.) C6,; boUI04viz qdo>U!p*'t Bu'J0)e'a!- d O6r-E m 'r.rO ? s:br;9 32e negdi"-tl cd -\:' 6t H i\ Om u !P- e o. EE E A 5.(tu 9+joQotB(6- o orh J.EiBI Hs#;ss *n5:KE;[ Er?e:s fr ? 6oF bcrN _ q + F.io <- g? { d oLOr.-#rNFU)CIa.Yd) H s,hilUir.Hf.- ,.O E tO O q)Za EZ com i9 I fi. , H H H q E3E H;Ef- iI $ E e' ;6F E'XEE: o k o a BE? EeI8n 3 E 3 ;'id< q9tc8 o 'i E P ^- EI.E{$xE# ;-[+ta:EE iEsEi:5.r #e€H€rf:'P <d r:..0 i".A EB!;E ee E; flI Te.Io .Hs# ,HH SrEhE $$ $r $: tr; tfi;= Elra ialai gH g; q; gB fi!f,s E!;f, EiEri i*t E? Ea Eg HigE EEiE *EiEa ifi Efl Efi E# trEg EEHS Ei*Ei iS E* Et E: EEEI ttBr I*EEE lnfinEfii[$illiH$il 5 r?u esH tftEt ilililtilil;EEigIIgiEtp. H-ii rhi6x FFFNFSEHpqHFEEFEEoi ;rE 2d&,&4,,E fE€ EgF?Hflf;*BHBEsEHH!EEgEH!il iEE 5#55ESioi c'i+'d6r- cd". := r: ABEXHIBIT H Fz U oa'= L I c'lI d H fr t.I €r|.:al oO';tEal dg tl E:trll {E3l .d,E 6l c--- I g Ezt!:4lj B€lqao Fz U !{F (J l< o^ EEH*o=02:0<asxotrlu>il'i<rqx &3=laoz:=z*fr3zilooD<o.O Joo, n( =c)P> oz ci3z<Do fa. A o E z z D.] zI m nz (J H $ f'l -ae S rrl *= (/l rna ,.b oLoctr)LN E r,: @:^xliE+ ON 0\Oi- tDna u 3l 5l el \( ,l =l l=l.N !2o z > 9roo @aa I N oz l cxJ z z ri s sI ! o P @ rN €ooN ao N c1 @ ( t!. o o nf, 5 v oq oo oc ocooN oqr ! zoI aI N aeaN o\ o N Ia C P )o O O (-) I o. p,'o.E, 6)* *J id .--.ilJoE .;; ot{ ur (-) oS EBEX E9 bfr] H; F> b!\,0 c HtsOfo<sr(Y) ; is9!rnE H d;Gl<nto x'oFdil3.8 hE Fts+J?[>E3fiEi t* ^A/ o^, oO cru0 €:5<0. a '.5 q)a frr qO 5dall ,v a dvI flt It co =l I \oo(/) o o M Fz LJ z Fa X hl #,.-,*jR J F Hz J oz a rdo t!rI C( tra rda !?oo ra FNIoD o @a It €c-r o 6 $6o otrz I! E 9o tr U. Foz(n :: + o\ D N\oo d tr(@q No @N + Z J I S oJ oI \lrn -r at :1 I ^-rc).*rrjg* Qr+\o O Fr\ J^- :v.;i>.-tizz> JU 01 o Lrl <t-4z<rnlOO f,, cV-/t r //, & b) v/ // /// (to-oo-ll t- Lttu'oN l33red I stndqd 'dru.{g 9/3 61,11 sauado:6 dn-r,{g H trzp O 0o'= al I e H E ? I c" P I ;*,i Ll €(J EEI iq iHI EgL/ Hl .iE E Hl ,:'," 3 l;E= o^ 2"tt % I I EASEMENT DEED Nathan N. Dutton of 4000 C,R. 306, Parachute, CO 81635, for the consideration of ten dollars and other valuable consideration, receipt and adequacy of which are acknowledged, grants and conveys to David S. Dutton and Muriel S. Dutton, whose address is 4852 County Road 306, Paraohute, CO 81635, and their heirs and successors, a non-exclusive perpetual easement ('oEasement') for ingress and egxess for agricultural and residential purposes to and from real property in Garfield County, Colorado, legally described as the NE'/NE% Section 12, T8S, R96W, 6th P.M., County of Garfield, State of Colorado such Easement to be appurtenant to such property. The Easement shall be across real property in Garfield County, Colorado, legally described as the NW%NE% Section 12, T8S, R96W, 6th P,M., County of GarIield, State of Colorado such Easement being further described on the attached Exhibit A and depicted on the attached Exhibit B. DArED tni, /s! auv oLhhfu-,2010. NATHAN N. DUTTON STATE OF COLORADO COIINTY OF GARFIELD ) ) ss: ) . . The-foregoing insffument was acknowledged before me this / aay of ULtbla^r/ 2010, by Nathan N. Dutton. Witness my hand and official. se4l. My Commission expire.t ,1X lfUV EXHIBIT ) Nota.y Public H Fzp oU i.;Ia ? I c" X-l =E>al c€ iHI EgL, r-rl .;^ :ir '-: =il El -- cd,Ei-6lE-'F l-aJ u l5;:i ldsE a e.lI o 6 o BEiBflEI*$Its v'E ^,< a n'ri 4aEB3 ETsHy EEo=o tr---:.i v4 EsA ESifiE EE :r* HEEils :IEHE MTYa; Eil EllB :l:?E Efi-3':ir ;;rI5 f;E { *at ttgH, E*#rEE H;?Ei s{g;'dE dfa"ErEfElEt E,aEe {+EEE#fin'i.-EHn. ;?; ;I;iilIHEfr+$ H Cg :U33 EFFFF F E!'T€.e8 3^K::tr9355H E; ;;€ ffi#EgE?8il;*s.9e H oo) >.F,aF-tr-\o\c}co-(oE9; ESEE{raaaa?zi;E 5#558'oi c'j+'; :\<lzo. d 6 (') d d! 'H qi OO+, o5.H5q)3 ;;B.Fl * "',n od P)'rJ X'UF{#o)"'dxhH9"5H 6.! ETo E', 1E O rri i Es({) E ! ITrEHgSOE=stO /^' X iFil=il ESL{ h 5- >, q E 8E+r+i ? ^>tr H 5.Et ).213 O - e.EOo €q6aE-r-*\< Lrlz >s Bz a) d F {8Wrsrffi r5i < qr te,,i F ffi# o :)Q HE o >ac60Q& o^ lrl f-l HPHqo=d: xfi5;iai<r!^ 93=7o.oaE= ESESziioo)<o.(J z m o-n( a.) -E> AZ, <2 ^QZ< olL I fi' le \\ EI4 c-r iHtla ,96'V96 S,,I9,Zt.O0 N:rauroC axg ot aiJ--T\ - \ as- a.._F q"l /t / :z tu 4 I\o (.) d -9.H (H qOu .+, cdU.Fa 5 {.)s #>opl - "' ,^ O,q ..aE 5Ex h E 9"E fEI Ei HE\oFii;Ot!Ite(o E i iisoYaaE Ji H o; cd Eo o# O A E =trMZT H3 >, q E €ts+r J.i ? ^>tr H 5.Ea;EieO' ' c.EOo ,!H6aF. -+-_\< f'lz:s Bz C)A*F 7 v \oo c') FO5< ?v,Eol-tizz?JLJilt)g> k<r!oo ;t:l E-. C, ''%:** Qr+ Ia' I tt it @ =l I @o(Y) o oN Fz Do z ta X rn ,r,*F3<#; J co a !nz Z @ Foze lnz tla !eo ora N\N rn o !")oo ra o\a @ r:l N !')ao o€a rn @ob a @tND N\ooN I EI $J zio-o0-I I l-z"z 'oN larredt sut,(qa 'dru.{g 9/3 6111 san:ado:6 du(g E & Fiz U q oL N ..lr o Ia I cl I o of,i9 €(.) l"c d.: dd ,E-v s Et H l- ZA YX\J frl r-\ o Fm Q t E ! E. E 5 3 E :^' o!iui,*i i$l:\] i\3 jo;,i ,/ 7 7/ ,l I I I I I I 0. O z z J aJ m az3o fr. z o. F\o B\o a @F oi or'la I I I I // When reeorded, mail to: This Space Reserved For Recording Information SPECIAL WARRANTY DEED Muriel Dution and Linda M. biion of and P.O. Box 58, New Castle, CO 81647, and as owners of a life estate and remainder interest respectively to certain lands in Garfield County described as the SW/+SE% Section 1, TBS, R96W, 6th P,M. ("Grantors"), County of Garfield, State of Colorado, for the consideration of ten dollars and other good and vaiuable consideration, the receipt and adequacy of which are hereby acknowledged, hereby sell and convey to the GARFIELD COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, with an address of 108 SrH Street, Suite 213, Glenwood Springs, CO 81601, a public road easement for travel by the public including associated subsurface road support located in Garfield County, Colorado, and described on Exhibit 1, attached hereto and incorporated by this reference, (the "Property"), reserving unto Grantors all oil, gas, and other minerals and all other subsurface uses including but not limited to public utilities, private utilities and similar uses. Garfield County may protect this public road easemenr from all other users, including the g1'antors, through issuance of permits that will control, condition, or prohibit the use of the easement. The provisions of the foregoing reservations, interests, dghts and easements shall be binding upon and run with the land. Grantor warrants title against all persons claiming under Grantor, excepting taxes and assessments for the years 2009 and thereafter, and easements, reservations, restrictions, covenants encumbrances, and other matters shown on Exhibit 2 hereto. Signed ,nifi&day of ,2010, MURIEL DUTTON EXHIBIT !oDo fro,ffiirDD(oN STATB OF COLORADO ) couNTY oF GAMIELD ) ss: A The foregoing instrument was acknowledged W2010, bY Muriel Dution. Witness my hand and official seal. STATE OF COLORADO ) ) ss: COUNTY OF GARFIELD ) 20i0, by Linda M. Dixon. Witness my hand and official seal. My Commission expires: before ^"*irtauy ot J,/- -w The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this 3) aay of My Cornmission expires: ,j" sxrnti-v,1. 'i5. : l.dlCi.iur_S : J SFiIRI,EY J. 1 ,i N|GHOLS : EXHIBIT 1 LEGAL DESCRIPTION EASEM.ENT DESCRIPTION A5o'ooFooTSTRIPoFLANDSITUATEDINTHESwI/4sE1/+ff9E9]tql,.Towt{SHIPSSoUTH.RANGE9S wEST oF THE 6TH pRlNctili"M"Edri,?ir,"Siio'iiniC'tir'tario t-vNc-zs.oo rtrr or't EAcH slDE oF IHE FOLLOWNG DESCRIBED CENTERLINET (BASIS oF BEARINGS FoR IHIS ExHlBlT lS A BEARING oF Ns7'.!'4:39-!-?gtrEN THE soUTH QUARTER CoRNER Or SECION 1, A BLM ALUMINUM CAP IN PLACE N'Tii T]JT iESi-SIiTECH]H CORNER OF SECNONS 'I AND 12; A ALH ALUUINUU CAP IIi PLACE,) (ALL SIJR\€Y INFORMATION SHOWN HETEON lS EASED ON INFORMATIoN PROVIDED 8Y THE GARFTELO COUNTY sURvEyOR AND OOES UOi iErtECr ANY FIELO lOcnnONS BY HIGH couNTY ENGINEERING' lNc') COMMENCING AT lHE SCUTH QUARTER CORNER OF SAID SECTION I' A BLU ALUM}NUM CAP IN PLACE; THENCE N0O.t9,r7,E A DISTANCE oF 1J76,il FEET TO a pOrNf Or niE NOIiTHERLY BOUNDARY OF IHE Sw1/4SE1/4 Or SAID SECnoN 1; IHENCE iaStZOr"E ALONG SAID NORTI'IERLY BOUNSARY A DISTANCE OF 25'00 FEET To A polNT oN THE CENTERLINE or-iaro Rtcllr-or-wni, -tur.eg.ulc QIrylilq THENCE LEAVTNG sAlD NoRTHERLv BOUNDARY ALoNc THE cENTERLINE Or'se6-iGili-or-ui rue rou-OwtHc FouRTEEN (14) COURSESI 1, SOO19'17,VY A DISTANCE OF 75J.J8 FEET; Z- ALON6 THE ARC OF A CURyE TO THE LEFf.HAyING A RADIUS OF 55-00 FEET' A CENTRAL ANGLE oF 57.10,21. eNo a orsiaidr dr i+.gfrEer (cHdRo BEARS s28'15'55'E A DISTANCE or 35.4g FEET)I 3. S5651'04"E A DISTANCE OF 135.47 FEET; 4. ALONG THE ARC OF A CURVE TO THE RIGHT HAVING A RADTUS OT 2OO'OO FEET' A CENTRAL ANGLE OF ot47,OZ- ANo A USIANCE Or 13.21 FEET (CHARD-BEARi Ss457'15'E A DISTANCE OF 15'21 FEEr); 5. S53O4,O2"E A DISTANCE OF 2J8.69 FEET; 6.ALoNGTHEARcoFACUR\EToTHELEFTHAVINGARAotuSoFITo.SoFEET,ACENTRALANGLEoF 60.18,1e. ANo A Dtsi;J;i or ua,gi irrr tii-i&i' iEens-sesrs'lr"E A DTSTANCE oF 170'78 FEET); 7. N6637'40"E A DISTANCE OF 106'24 FEET; 8. ALONG THE ARC OF A CUR\€ TO THE RIGHT HAVING A RADIUS OF 2OO'OO FEET' A CENIRAL ANGLE OF to'f,Cos'AND A D|STANCE oF 56.8e FEET (i;&;;Eans Hli's+'+4'E A DISTANCE oF 36'8a FEET)I 9. N77'II.49,E A DISTANCE OF 124,00 TEET; .lo'ALoNGTHEARcoFAcUR!€ToTHERIGHTHAVINGARADIUSoFSE'o0FEET,ACENTRALANGLEoT tse-tz,Jo' ANo A DlsiANci or ros.ss rEEr itij6ilo arAns szs'rr'56"E A DIsTANcE oF 74'7s FEET) 11. s56'24'19"W A DtsrANcE oF 96'4J FEET 12.AL0NGIHEARcoFACURVEToTHELEFTHAV1NGARAoIUSoF25o,ooFEET,ACENTRALANGLEoF ,srz,so, n*o a ors?ni[i'or'isis reEr tiniiiid b]rnilisie'o4'lr A DTsTANcE oF 25.62 FEET) 15. S5O'5I,49"TJ A OISTANCE OF 238'52 FEET 14.AL0NGTHEARcoFAcUR\€ToTHELEFTHAVINGARADIUSoF.ISo.ooFEET,ACENIRALANGLE oF 58,21,58. ANo A DlstNi;'oi iiz*z rrer tiiixio beans izr zr'oo tv A DISTAN0E oF 126'77 FEET) ro A potNT oN TltE sourx'soriNoenv o1 serO seiiion 1, THE P'INT oF' TEIIMINUS' (lrrENcE THE soUTH 6gARTER coRNER oF +fiil";"eliR's $i'1a;s6;il A'DIITANCE or 4ie'56 Frer): sAlD srRlP gSNTAINING 2.546 ACRES MORE OR LESS' I., 3. 4. E)GIIBTI 2 PERMITTED ENCUMBRANCES p,-rniG vo,r1a aisclose, and whic( dre noidbo*I by tirc pUblic recoras;PI€mlSSSli,OUlooIsclQse,SIquljllcllare.nolsDownDylnePuplrcfecoras. i - ;: . ..1 .'.. -t :.:: . .;.:1::'..:.: Any lien, :or riglrt to a lien, for services, labor or matcrial heretofore or hereafter furnisfrgd, imposcd by law rirrd not shov/n by the public . Rightsorclaimsofpartiesinpossessignnotshovmby0rePublicrecord". ,.1,. ' : '.. .... . .', . .,' ',, Eascmenls,orqlaimsofcascm'ents,notshoimbydrepublicrecords, ,, ,' .,'.'. , .. :..' ...::':. :: . , Disr.clanciel, ,1nfficts in bounda.V lincs, shortage in area 91c. roachm3nG, and an14 facts, n&ich a correct survey and inspcctiqn bf ihe : , : -.: : .: I ,,i ., :. l n"i."ts, ti"n., mcumbrances, adverse clairns or other matters, ifany, creatd first appearif,g in thc.publ.ic rccords or attaching subsequgnr to rlie effecrive dale hereofbut prior to thc date the proposed insured acquires ofrecord for yalqc *ic cstate or interes't or mo(gage therern covered by this cohmitment. ,'::,:j: 6: Anyandallunpaidtaxcs,assessmentsandunredccmcdtaxsales. . ..., ..''..,: .,-: : 7':Anylicnorchargebnaccbuntoftheinclusioflofsutjcctpropcrtyina4improvementdistricL 1', ;:. .',: ; I ',. .. !1.; . Anf "n{ qlf watgl ngits, c'laims, or tit}e to waler, \yhether or not thc.maberq gxccpiied.arg- stiown by rhe,pubtic reeord. , . , ' , .,:: 9.,Right;ffi!proprietorofavcinorlodctoextiactandrcmovehisoreiherefrom,shouldthesamebcfoundtopenctrateorintqrlectilie i ryemisgq hereby grTtjd and a right of wiy for ditches or crinals as condruotcd by thc authority olihe United itates, as r.served in U.niigd SlatcsPatentrrcordcdDeicmber3, 1923 inBook l12atPagc397. . . : 10. Rig}t of way Easernent Srantcd to Holy Cross Elcctric in instument recoided May 9, 1979 in'Bqok 528 at Page 9. .,,,It. RcscrvatiorrofaLife EshtobyMlrielDurtonininstrumortrecorddDecemlier:l7,2004inBook165l aPa1e2l. .. '. ,:.. 12. ,Conveyance of the mineral interests, inoluding but not limited to oi[, gas and pthqr nrincrals as described in insmrment recorded .Deccmbcr '.l2'2004ioBookI65Ial!age22,andenyaridallassigumentstheieofcjrintbies1Erhbrbiu.,: '...,. ] i , | .'.' :.,-..|,:i..,,: l3' jTerhsandcoitditiodsofoilaDdGasLeasebyandbetweenMurielDuuonby.LindaMari".pi*cn;adrnsyinfa4'ast;ssoraudApolo.r,. Enelgy- LLt, as Lesscc, rcco-rded Japlrary 8, 200f in Book 1425 at PagJ +40 aird any and al! interlgts,rhereirr or assi8ninin$.therenf, , . .. , . 14. Ieims,conditions,obligationsandallmaterssetforthinMemorandumofUnderstaudiqgiccoldedApril20,20lQ'asReceptionNo. ,...784920. . , . ,. ..; " When recorded, mail to: This Space Reseled For Recording Information SPECIAL WARRANTY DEED Nuhan N. Dutton of 4000 C.R. 306, Parachute, CO 81635, and as owner of certain lands in Garfield County described as the NWYaNET+ Section 12, T8S, R96W, 6th P.M. ("Grantor"), Counfy of Garfield, State of Colorado, for the consideration of ten dollars and other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and adequacy of which are hereby acknowledged, hereby sells and conveys to the GARFIELD COUNTY BOARD OF COLIIITY COMMISSIONERS, with an address of 108 8rH Street, Suite 2i3, Glenwood Springs, CO 81601, a public road easement for travel by the public including associated subsurface road support located in Garfield County, Colorado, and described on Exhibit 1, attached hereto and incorporated by this reference, (the "Property''), reserving unto Grantor all oil, gas, and other minerals and all other subsurface uses including but not limited to public utilities, private utilities and similar uses. Garfield County may protect this public road easement from all other users, including the grantor, through issuance of permits that will control, condition, or prohibit the use of the easement. The provisions of the foregoing reservations, interests, rights and easements shall be binding upon and run with the land. Grantor warrants title against all persons claiming under Grantor, excepting taxes and assessments for the years 2009 and thereafter, and easements, reservations, restrictions, covenants encumbrances, and other matters shown on Exhibit 2 hereto. Signed tnis fl /*aV ot duve-,2010. NATHAN N. DUTTON ,d ,={ I ft//STATE OF COLORADO COUNTY OF GARFIELD ++4++*e{'+n''<,*@+ Wifrress my hand and official seal. My Commission expires: - ' My Commission'Exoire;66i26t2a1 z ) ) ss: ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this4- day of 2010, by Nathan N. Dutton. JANET N. KIME NOTARY PUBLIC STATE OF COLORADO EXHIBITf;>e ;;;; ""',*^*.,:roo'*ii exHreil:s'1'eg$r1gon Nar:r+'5e'18-+'I5*^1l4,tgg"l';1["I^!i;lii: ir,<cnnnN,i? A,BLLl *u[liuTlt"# iN eLeEr.nuo rHe easr sx]EENTH coRlll ' :' EXHIBIT 1 LEGAL DESCRIPTION UiliEcn-b*.iC, ;A :sLM rlr-uutNu u, gAP,:tI If e-LM'niiJMrNuu.: cAP,,!r{ I FLAcEi) is,;rieb.oN;r*ionutriou,Ffr o*.oqg,=r-!:*I,c,.g1etl9orntw $iLfy#i\Y1f#XBY -EFIS'FiX?"XJ;"'Lt"t"r'8,ili'T;iilai:"d;ilii,:]:o::i::::^]? hiTu};;Jffi*dl#offi:if,rii 1?hi;R..1,ir;tgth,p,ap;,H;;'i?f.i5i:,lH.iU[ii"6l['{i,r]^oq(i;;prry}9q;ol.',^i+?iz,'i:. orsteNq1'.gf.,.ti?--ql ro,A ,T}IENCE:LEAVING sAlq ifiXli':bi','i;i-fi tffi uni,'#'-sAio-;rRrcEl:eF;,1tY,'-,ll..,.rli r.'noitxo.aRy nLoNG IHE,CENTEBUNE oF ll3li],"tJT,,'Slffi"i:ffi-ili'#fi HEI'liif i1ffi :.::^:'l::i::, iri*n *i :i**: ot,i: ***,.0-T}lE ,l *m':,i.?i tf ['ti1];Lt#1l'*l'iff)?tl. AL6NG 1116,mc or a cunw'ro T|E LEFT.HAY-ry-G A KALRUT UT rrv'w "'i*ie-5i iiSS reEr) :os'42'41'oND,o D'=To;Er ir,iiii'gi:;; tcHono BEARS:sl0''41:to:q A Dlsr , Ii : : :i '..1 :-.-t ..'. :. ::. . 3. ALoNG THE:ARC oF ^'cunw ro mr Rlq[fly]jc A:RADlus ioF lsq'oo FEr{' A CEIITRAL ANGLE oF :102.r5:3o, ^o o,o,rrl"i*.tl:zei?r,.rEir1c'ton"otiii-d isiiSi+;w * DtqTANcE or 233:sT EEET) +i,sea'+zisg'we'otSraNiE''oF: 290:57FEET: ' :' ::' :. : ', , ' , ," ;. ''il;;; ^-J';ilt.** ,1,11'3'il,';JlY!" o naoiusg!19+'o9'i*r A cBrmAt aNct-E'or ' rzzs,rol RNo ^ o,.rotfi.lo".tisii-,rsEi'lctoRol=8ioii;'t${i'+-i''w a otsreHcE or 65'45 FEEr) ro A poiHr oN lHE wESTERL' "ilI*'OkV'iiii *r-1g1+r1iZ;tO?'si6' ircnalt t2' rxE potNr oF nnutNu' (r{lJENcE rHE NoRrH Ouenft?tair'nren o1isl.c1E^ri'dEi*s:'riooii;loue :r otsre*cE:or zza'45 rEED; lrto stnp coNTAtNtNG o,zs?:eiiEJi;oHe o* Gss i i t, : : EX}ITRIT 2 PERMITTED ENCUMBRANCES l. .RightsorclaimsofparicsinposscssionnotEhowrbythiPublicrecords.. ; .'.. ,' : .2. Ealsments,orblaim!:ofcasemente,notshownbytheiublicrccbrde'. .. . ' ' . i. ' pir.i'p*i;." ;;;;; ;; dilrry-6;;;.h;,;;;ilairrl en.'0.'r,*cnts; Bnd ;ny tuiF, rlich a cerrcct gurvey and inss,irlion of ihe . ' preiniJeswoulddisclose,aridwhicharenotshownbythepublicrccords.'. . . .' , i , ,, ', '. '. ,':: .:: : 4..Anylieo,or.rilhitoalien,for$ervices,laboiorniaicri4ihcrctofoTeorhereaAerfinirishe(imposedbylawandnorghoivnbylhepublic 'iecords,., '. ': '', "' '' ":-'1:: ij .. .. s': iiJiJtr,ri*.,encumbrarces,adverseclainxorotherrnatters,ifany,created,first'appcaringinthepublicrccordsorafiaching'subxqueni to ihi effecfive datc hdeofbut prior to thc date thc proposcd insured acguires oftrirord fof.valUe thq estee qr intcrqst. or mo(gqge r}lieon Any !p4 or charge on accout of the inclusion of subject propcrry inaa imPl?iSryAl:lls.tilqt:. . . : Any end a1i watcr rights, clainrs, or title to water, rvhcther or not the matlgrs gxc:pted a1q shgwa byJhg pubtic tocord. ; : ,, .,....r:.:'::,.,,..:....: ,.: , .. : ., :.. r Rightof the proprietor of a vcia or lode to ort"act ard rernove his orc 6.refronr, t'itolrlq,*,9 tf49 U" founa 10 Pqlqtretc pr intencct thc . prerruses hqrcby granted and a right ofway for ditches or cailals as consbuctdd by tbc,aulhori-ry oflhg United Statas, as resaved in Unitcd :,StatcsPatcntrecordedNovember30, 1912iaBook71 atPage59i andFe-bquary27, l9l5'in.Boot92gtPage34l. , .' ' , .. : - -' : ...,. i'l: ,::: : ": ':' : " 'i: ' , :. :i Rightof way easeh-rcnt $qnted to Hoiy Ooss elecrric Associalion Inc; in io#qh*t r.*raed Sepiember t O, t 98a in Book 6j6 at Page : . 4l8andiniqstumentrecordedOctober30, 1984in'Book659atPage333,: .'.,. t,.'.',',, , :.. , ,, , . ,, 6: 7. 0 9- ,:-: 10. ...:,,.r:,1 '-:":jri:.'1. :.1,. .-1. ..,: :. . ':: ..:.r..,,..:,..i l i : .,.' . .:, ..".: :,'.... 12.:TermsofCoop.erativeAgiccrnentforPcrmanentDamagcPrevcniionFenCingitcorrledepril 23, l992inBook829atP8ge8?4.,,.....: . . j j i '-; 13..RiradwaycasemcntandrightofwaygraotedtoNoblcEnergy,lnc.asdescribedininsqumcnirecordcdApriL2S,20OBaiR.gc-c.ptr1qiiNo. .,,747410.' .:. .'i. .. , ,.i .,..,,-.:....t'..,,.'..:'l:-.t: .,.. '' i " i ' ' ''' '' ' ' :' t :' :" ''" "14.: . iipeiinc easement and.right ofuray gran;ed to Noblc Encrgn Ine. as described ininstrumcnt iecorded April 28; 2OOt ai.fCCepf;on No. .,'7ti74tt. : --' . .. .'.,...-: ::::'".'.:.;..:..'-:..:.:',.,r.. ,, ,, ,- :,,j,,.:,,, ,,, : : r s. .;C1 nveyan* of one-qu3rter (257o) of the o.il sas-,acrcl al 9tt 9r mm"ri ,igh; i;l*"rr1n*,UU recoraca Septcmbcr 24, zooZ aqneception Nq. 733698, and any ald all assignmeqts thcreqf or ioterests lberein. , : l6.,Righ!ofrvayforCouatyRoad306.:,':...;.'.:.,:,.''.].i i 7. Terms, condidons, obligations and all mattcrs set forth in Mcmorandum oiU;raqslatOing iecoaoa epl ZO, 2010 ai Reception No. : 784920. o be used, by any taxpayer for the o;"r" of avoiding penalties that may U"Qor.a on any Internal Revenue Service. From : Don DeFord [mailto : dkdeford@garfield-county. com] Sent: Tuesday, October 05,2010 10:11 AM To: Jenna H. Keller Cc: John Martin; Mike Samson; Tresi Houpt; Marvin Stephens; Jeff Nelson; Fred Jarman Subject: CR306 vacation and acceptance process Jenna, Yesterday the BOCC off,rcially approved "waiver" of its road vacating process in regard to the cr306 Dutton/Dixon project. Pursuant to that action, and unless your clients object, the County will proceed to vacate and accept relevant portions of the 306 right-of-way following only state law. Under that direction, the vacation and acceptance issues have been set for 6:30pm on Oct. l3'h for a location and extent review by the Planning Commission. Subsequently the BOCC will conduct a public hearing on Oct. 18th at 1 :15 to consider the Resolution you have reviewed. Please advise this Office as soon as possible conceming your clients position on the "waiver" and the schedule as their objection may substantially alter the course of events. It is also my understanding that your clients will schedule a "walk through" with County staff this week to confirm construction compliance with the MOU. Thank you for your attention to this matter. Don K. DeFord, Garfield County Attomey CONFIDENTIALITY STATEMENT: This message and any attachments are confidential and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to which it is addressed. The information contained herein may include protected or otherwise privileged information. Unauthorized review, forwarding, printing, copying, distributing, or other use of such information is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful. If you have received this message in error, please notify the sender by replying to this message and delete the email without further disclosure. r EXHiBIT C2Fred Jarman From: Sent: To: Subject: Attachments: Jenna H. Keller [keller@dwmk.com] Tuesday, October 05, 2010 '11:00 AM Don DeFord RE: CR306 vacation and acceptance process Vacation Resolution v4 RED.doc Don: At this time, my clients are planning on the vacation and acceptance issues for 6:30pm on Oct. 13ft by the Planning Commission and the public hearing on Oct. 18th at 1 :15 to consider the Resolution. The compliance with state process and waiver of the county process is acceptable. The form of the attached resolution (also sent to you on Friday) is acceptable. I plan to attend the Oct. 18ft hearing. Should our office be in attendance for the Oct. 13th meeting? I instructed Linda to contact Jeff Nelson to schedule a "walk through" with County staff this week to confirm construction compliance with the MOU. I also indicated to my clients that all issues of construction should be resolved by Oct. 15, 2010 in order to proceed with the vacation. I asked that they take this issue up directly with Jeff Nelson. If I hear anything.to the contrary or if there are any problems, I will let you know. Jenna H. Keller Dufford, Waldeck, Milburn & Krohn, L.L.P. T44Horizon Court, Suite 300 Grand Junction, CO 81506 Direct: 970-248-5857 Telephone: 97 0-241-5500 Facsimile: 970-243-7738 Montrose, CO Telephone: 97 0-249-4500 Moab, UT Telephone: 43 5 -259 -2225 I E DLrFFofitr vvALDECT{ t WJ H::11Y": KftoHr'J ii" CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE : This electronic mail transmission and any accompanying documents contain information belonging to the sender which may be confidential and legally privileged. This information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity to whom this electronic mail transmission was sent as indicated above. If you are not the intended recipient, any disclosure, copying, distribution, or action taken in reliance on the contents of the information contained in this transmission is strictly prohibited. If you have received this transmission in error, please call collect at970-241-5500 and delete this transmission. Thank you. IRS CIRCULAR 230 NOTICE: This electronic mail transmission and any attached documents may contain provisions concerning a federal tax issue or issues. Under recently issued IRS regulations, we must inform you this electronic mail transmission and any attached documents are not intended or written to be used, and cannot