Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout4.0 BOCC Staff Report 08.05.1996PROJECT INFORMATION AND STAFF COMMENTS REQUEST: APPLICANT: LOCATION: SITE DATA: WATER: SEWER: ACCESS: EXISTING ZONING: ADJACENT ZONING: BOCC 12/4/95 8/5/96 An exemption from the definition of subdivision. William & Nancy Flood A tract of land located in Section 3, T7S, R89W of the 6th P.M.; approximately 4.5 miles south of Glenwood Springs on CR 117 (Four Mile Road). 6.07 Acres Well Individual sewage disposal system Direct access to CR 117 along a shared driveway. A/R/RD O/S - West A/R/RD - North, South, East RELATIONSHIP TO THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN The property is located in District - lb Subdivisions/Moderate Environmental Constraints as designated by Garfield County Comprehensive Plan's Management Districts Map. (The original application was made prior to the adoption of the new Comprehensive Plan for Study Areal.) H. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSAL A. Site Description: The property is located south of Chelyn Acres subdivision, immediately west of CR 117, approximately 4.5 miles south of Glenwood Springs. An existing single family dwelling, accessory dwelling unit and garage are located on the eastern portion of the tract. The topography rises from Four Mile Creek (elevation Aik 6360 feet), which flows through the eastern portion of the property, up to approximately 6800 feet, an average slope of 43%. From the creek to the existing structures, slope has been calculated to be 19%, above the house slope has been calculated to be 48%. The vegetation of the lower portions of the property consists of shrubs, grasses and deciduous trees, whereas the upper portions of the propert are primarily vegetated by shrubs, grasses and sage. See vicinity map on page B. Adjacent Land Uses: Single family dwellings predominate in this area, as Chelyn Acres is located to the north, Lazy Diamond A Subdivision is located to the east and a number of smaller residential tracts are located throughout. Bureau of Land Management owns lanhich abuts the western portion of the applicant's land. See sketch map, page C. Project Description: The proposal specifies the division of the 6.07 acre tract into two (2) parcels of four (4) and two (2) acres in size. The application indicates the petitioners intend to sell the larger lot which would consist of the existing structures and retain the smaller lot for the location of a new, single family dwelling. III. MAJOR ISSUES AND CONCERNS A. Subdivision Regulations: Section 8:52 of the Garfield County Subdivision Regulations states that "No more than a total of four (4) lots, parcels, interests or dwelling units will be created from any parcel, as that parcel was described in the records of the Garfield County Clerk and Recorder's Office on January 1, 1973, and is not a part of a recorded subdivision; however, any parcel to be divided by exemption that is split by a public right-of-way (State or Federal highway, County road or railroad) or natural feature, preventing joint use of the proposed tracts, and the division occurs along the public right-of-way or natural feature, such parcels thereby created may, in the discretion of the Board, not be considered to have been created by exemption with regard to the four (4) lot, parcel, interest or dwelling unit limitation otherwise applicable; " The subject property existed as a larger tract of 11.7 acres in March, 1972, which was later subdivided, by exemption, in Oc ober, 1972, creating two (2) parcels. See Petition and Resolution on pages / - ap • licants acquired the northern parcel in February, 1977. See deed on pages • Therefore, it appears this request is consistent with Section 8:52 (A) of the Subdivision Regulations. B. Zoning: The property exists within the A/R/RD zone district which mandates a minimum lot size of two (2) acres. Both proposed lots are in excess of two (2) acres. Originally, staff was concerned that the proposed lot configuration would result in a violation of Section 5.04.03 of the Zoning Resolution. However, the submittal of a preliminary exemption plat indicates that each proposed lot would consist of at least one (1) contiguous acre of less than 40% slope. C. Lot Design/Development: The design of the smaller parcel includes a narrow strip of land which runs the length of the northern border of the property. If this is necessary to create a parcel that is a minimum of two (2) acres, required by the A/R/RD zone district, then it is questionable whether this is a viable split. Staff has calculated the square footage of the eastern portion of the property, exclusive of the narrow strip of land, and found it to be 1.63 acres in size. It has been represented to staff that this strip could be utilized as an electrical utility line easement to bring power from the main line, located west of the existing structures, to the proposed, two (2) acre lot. This possibility would assist in validating the irregular lot configuration and staff suggests the Board consider making the use of the easement, for the specified purpose, a condition of approval. D. Water: The existing structures are served by an existing well, pursuant to Water Court application No. W-3570, which granted a water ri ht m eting the criteria of an exempt, domestic well. See case No. W-3570, pages . The water supply for the proposed lot is the subject of a West Divide Water Conservancy District water allotment contract and recently approved augmentation plan in Water Court Judgement and Decree, No. 94CW344. See Decree, pages'/ • �Z . Apparently, the Decree validates the West Divide contract and therefore, would enable the petitioner to apply for, at a minimum, a household -use only well permit for the proposed lot, as this Decree sets in place the augmentation plan. Staff recommends that, as a condition of approval, the petitioner receive all necessary permits, complete the new well, provide the well completion report along with the results of a four (4) hour pump test, and a statement from the well -driller that the well is capable of supplying the intended uses. This shall be done prior to final approval. E. Sewer: The method of water treatment for this proposal is specified to be the use of an ISD system. According to the Soil Conservation Service, soils on-site where the system would logically be placed, are identified as being within the Cochetopa and Fluvaquent classifications. Both soils have severe limitations regarding the placement of ISD systems and carry the severe designation for building site development. Staff would recommend a plat note be included to address these limitations. State regulations concerning ISDS require that placement of ISDS be on slopes no greater than 30%. Apparently, the double garage and accessory dwelling unit (ADU) were built after the original ISD system was installed; however, the ADU was also plumbed to the existing septic tank. According to research by staff, the tank size is unknown and the leachfield was incre d to between 600 square feet and 840 square feet. The diagram on page indicates that the new leachfield may be located on a portion of the proposed lot and it is difficult to state exactly where the existing septic tank is located, as the diagram is not drawn to scale. This is an issue because new state regulations do not allow a combined flow rate in excess of 2000 gallons per day from two systems placed on one (1) lot, no matter the size of the lot. It is conceivable that if the existing tank is located on the proposed lot, then the combined flow rate would be in excess of 2000 gpd. As a condition of approval, staff recommends the petitioner demonstrate compliance with the note 'te ' nd that all setbacks can be met. See additional ISDS information, pages Additionally, it would be required to designate easements for any and all components of the existing septic system that would be located on the proposed lot. F. Fire Protection: Two letters by the Glenwood Springs Department of Emergency Services have been received indicating that the tract to be subdivided by exemption ma create roblems in the event of an emergency. See letters attached on pages y� � Staff recommends a plat note concerning wildfire mitigation be included. G. Legal Access: Access to CR 117, for the parcel to be created, would be along a driveway which currently serves the existing residences and a neighboring parcel, which crosses over an adjoining piece of property. An easement for access to the existing residence would be necessary as the driveway would cross the larger parcel and the adjoining parcel. This easement shall further demonstrate that the easement has been expanded to include the new lot. H. Easements: All easements regarding access, utilities, drainage, water supply and any additional easements would be required to be shown on an exemption plat. I. School Impact Fees: The applicant would be required to pay the $200 school impact fee for any new lot that is created, prior to signing of an exemption plat. IV. SUGGESTED FINDINGS 1. That proper posting and public notice was provided as required for the meeting before the Board of County Commissioners. 2. That the meeting before the Board of County Commissioners was extensive and complete, that all pertinent facts, matters and issues were submitted and that all interested parties were heard at that meeting. 3 That for the above stated and other reasons, the proposed exemption is in the best interest of the health, safety, morals, convenience, order, prosperity and welfare of the citizens of Garfield County. V. RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends approval of the petition, pursuant to the following conditions: 1. That all representations of the applicant, either within the application or stated at the meeting before the Board of County Commissioners, shall be considered conditions of approval. 2. A Final Exemption Plat shall be submitted, indicating the legal description of the property, dimension and area of the proposed lot, access to a public right-of-way, and any proposed easements for setbacks, drainage, irrigation, access or utilities. 3. That the applicant shall have 120 days to present a plat to the Commissioners for signature from the date of approval of the exemption. The Board may grant extensions of up to one (1) year from the date of conditional approval, if requested by the petitioner within the original 120 day period. 4. That the applicant shall submit $200.00 in School Impact Fees for the creation of the exemption parcel. 5. That the following plat notes shall appear on the Final Exemption Plat: "The legal water supply for this exemption is subject to curtailment if the contracts supporting the substitute water supply plan are not renewed." "The augmentation plan supporting the legal water supply for Parcel B, set forth in Case No. 94CW344, is subject to reconsideration on the question of vested water rights, after a period of five (5) years, commencing on the date specified in the Order of Adjudication of Case No. 94CW344." "Soil conditions on the site may require engineered septic systems and building foundations. Site specific percolation tests at the time of building permit submittal shall determine specific ISDS and building needs on the site." "The minimum defensible space distance shall be 30 feet on level terrain, plus appropriate modification to recognize the increased rate of fire spread at sloped sites. The methodology described in "Determining Safety Zone Dimensions, Wildfire Safety Guidelines for Rural Homeowners," (Colorado State Forest Service) shall be used to determine defensible space requirements for the required defensible space within building envelopes in areas exceeding five (5) percent grade." 6. Final approval will be contingent on receiving a letter of approval from the Glenwood Springs Department of Emergency Services, prior to the signing of an exemption plat. Furthermore, the applicant will be required to adhere to all recommendations made by said department. 7. Control of noxious weeds will be the responsibility of the property owner. 8. That, prior to the authorization of an exemption plat, the petitioner shall provide to the Planning Department a copy of the fully -executed (signed by all parties) Judgement and Decree in Case No. 94CW344, a copy of a valid well permit for the proposed lot (2 acre lot), a copy of a well completion report for the well proposed for this lot, the results of a four (4) hour pump test, and a statement by the individual conducting the pump test that this well is capable of serving the proposed use. 9. The exemption plat shall clearly demonstrate the location of the existing individual sewage disposal system (ISDS) and the configuration of both lots will be done in such manner as to comply with all required setbacks. This shall be accomplished by the designation of a building envelope, on Parcel B (the 2 acre lot). The plat shall also be required to show the actual location of the well on Parcel B and demonstrate that all required setbacks are met. 10. That the electrical utility be brought onto the two (2) acre lot via the 25 foot wide strip of land located along the northern portion of the larger, four (4) acre lot. OIMMIND 6, rr i) vw 1 ;x65/6, 1 1 6<00 lid 10,l 217 1 5940, •;} n , 1 • 8030 jj • t;Gla )II 7930 7055 6844%. ._ l J/ 783 6489 �1 JX 1 )! 7855) XA \ \ 9 6600 684/ 0 m '7056 o 00 0 7364 o I 0f .1• • i 7073 "p 7464 BEFORE THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF GARFIELD COUNTY, COLORADO PETITION FOR EXEMPTIONS Pursuant to C.R.S. 106-2-33(3) (d) (1963), as amended, the undersigned, Terry C. Wallin and Lynda B. Wallin petition the Board of County Commissioners of Garfield County, Colorado, to exempt by Resolution a parcel of land adjacent to land owned by them, all as more fully set forth and described herein, and for the reasons set forth herein: 1. On or about March 24 , 1972 Petitioners entered into a Contract of Sale and Purchase with Patrick M. Fitzgerald and Marilyn A. Fitzgerald to purchase approximately 11.70 acres located in the SWkSWk of Section 3, Township 7 South, Range 89 West of the 6th Principal Meridian, Garfield County, Colorado as described in Exhibit A attached hereto and outlined in red. 2. On June 30, 1972 the Petitiorers obtained a deed for saicproperty and executed a note and deed of trust in favor of the Sellers. 3. Your Petitioners desire to divide the subject parcel into two parcels, each will be 5.00 acres or more, and each of which will have direct: access to Four Mile Road. The survey has not yet been completed but the approximate location of the proposed boundary line is indicated in a dotted line on Exhibit A. 4. Your Petitioners desire to construct a single family residence on the Northerly side of the proposed division line and for that purpose a water well was drilled on August 29, 1972, which well has been measured to produce 25 gallons per minute. 5. Petitioners have obtained a permit from the County Sanitarian of Garfield County, Colorado for the location of an acceptable septic system on each of the above- described parcels. 6. The existing well of Petitioners, a well drilled by the Fitzgeralds, prior to and within one-quarter of a mile of the Petitioners well, together with the general availability of underground water in this area causes Petitioners to assert that adequate, potable water should be available to the subject tract. WHEREFORE Petitioners request that the Board of County Commissioners of Garfield County, Colorado grant them an exemption to sell the above-described Southerly parcel. Which parcel shall contain not less than 5.00 acres nor more than 6.7 acres. Dated at Glenwood Springs, Colorado this 2nd day of October , 1972. Vit Terry C. Wallin hti r;�,� `Ii0(G '/7I1. Lynda B. Wallin OEN- -2- 7) i RESOLUTION WHEREAS, Terry C. Wallin and Lynda B. Wallin have petitioned the Board of County Commissioners of Garfield County, Colorado, for an exemption for a five -acre tract of land under C.R.S. 106-2-33 (3) (d) (1963 as amended); and WHEREAS, the petitioners have shown to the satisfaction of the Board of County Commissioners that they desire said exemption for said five acres for purposes of resale, said five acres presently being a part of a larger tract of land owned by petitioners, and whereas petitioners have demonstrated to the satisfaction of the Board that there is a reasonable probability of locating a water well on said five -acre tract, that there is adequate ingress and egress to said tract, and that location of septic tanks will be permitted by the Colorado Department of Health, and that the separation from Petitioners' land of said five -acre tract is not reasonably within the purposes of the Subdivision laws of the State of Colorado or the County of Garfield and therefore said tract should be exempt from the definition of the terms "subdivision" and "subdivided land" as set forth in C.R.S. 1-6-2-33 (3) (d) (1963 as amended). NOW, THEREFORE, upon motion of — / �/ seconded by ?4±2 /Pa V/ and unanimously carried, said five -acre tract of land, being described as follows: (description of Southerly parcel to be supplied) is hereby exempted from such definition and transfer of said tract may be made by Terry C. Wallin and Lynda B. Wallin. A copy of the instrument or instruments of conveyance when recorded shall be filed with this Resolution. FEB 2 3 1977 Recorded at o'clock Reception No. 2 69G9 _ -.! f •! -., , Wiretarl/y (ley/ KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS THAT TERRY r_ WALLIN and _LYNDA B. WALLIN First Party • 61 t... sband and w:re i.a Rnya l Apartments. Highway_ 31 ❑ Ur.gte person P.O. Box or Street Address 0 a Colorado Corporattsn Petoskey. Michigan 49770 p a Partnenhlp City State Zipp i_m o a �.. I�.w o«•....tic for and In consideration of ten dollars and other valuable considerat ion. in hand paid, hereby sells and contreys to z d; .,;r44S)3 WE/19 order RECORDER Sint i s '' WILLIAM L. FLOOD and NANCY C. FLOOD Second Party 4339 Road 117 P.O. Box or Street Address t 1 t n innd Springs . Cnlorado 81601 City . ,`, State Zip the following described property in the County of Rarfimld •D Individually IN joint tenancy o tenancy In Common p a Colorado Corporation o a Partnership 0 a Limited Partnership and State of Colorado: PARCEL A A parcel of land situated in the SW1/4SW1/4 of Section 3, Township 7 South, Range 89 West of the Sixth P.M., lying Westerly of the Westerly i.right-of-way line of the Four Milra Creek County Road as constructed ,and in place and Easterly of the Westerly line of said Section 3, ,said parcel of land is described as follows: Beginning at a point on the Westerly line of said Section 3 whence the Section Corner common to Sections 3, 4, 9 and 10 in said township and range bears: S. 01°01'32" E. 970.20 feet; thence N. 01°01'32" W. 220.43 feet along the Westerly line of said Section 3; thence S. 89°30'00 E. 792.95rfeet; thence S. 52°56'57" E.• with all its appurtenances and warr5a�f?t til � to he same, except and subject to general property taxes for the current year, U.S. patent reservations and exceptions, any and all easements and rights of way of a public or private nature and planning, zoning aril other governmental rules and regulations, prior mineral -reservations, protective covenants and a Deed of Trust to secure a note in the principa sum of $50,000.00 payable to United Mortgage Company dated April 1, 1975 recorded in Book 472 at Page 497 o° the Garfield County records, which the second party assumes and a rear to v. Firat party warrants that the current balance due is $49,243.84. SIGNED this !Q 'day of V. hritary A D 19 ZZ_ STATE OF 4?-i‘.7/Yl k -1 - COUNTY 1 - 1 ss. COUNTY OF • Tera ` ll�i �ttusband Lynd4/B. Wallin - wife The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this (' day of Prshrilarir 19 77 by Terry C. Wallin and Lynda B. Wallin, husband and wife. Witness my hand and official seal. My commission expires: • NOTE: = ' • Mark abpUabl. aqua,. with.. — 8lneular d,aI,rneluda plural .t cont.fP requires. ) Jr'zL1.L-- • Notary Public K. i.. RA 'IA Notary Publ,c, ri^mrl C- ., Mich. MV Comnncs in r.p'^c .1u{ 1. 1^79 6s1 onict Ikdress, Yelossey, Mi,h. 491/0 PETRE. ZIMMERMAN ti SHELTON P.C. — Form 1 -w 1 • t oavuoioa JO 31VJs -1 O BUUK493 PACE720 318.94 feet to a point on the Westerly right-of-way line of said road; thence S. 12°58'10" W. 190.69 feet along,the Westerly right-of-way line of said road;' 'thence N. 73°33'45" W. 350.42 feet; thence N. 84°23'00" W. 667.83 feet to a point on the Westerly line of said Section 3, the point of beginning. PARCEL B A 20 foot road easement said road easement being 10 feet on each side of the followinj described centerline: Beginning at a point on the Southerly line of Parcel A whence the Section Corner common. to Sections 3, 4, 9 and 10 in said township and range bears: S. 38°39'00" W. 1135.10 feet; thence along said centerline S. 15°00'00" E. 181.58 feet; thence S. 84°00'00" E. 150.00 feet; thence S. 17°00'00" W. 107.00 feet; thence S. 28°00'00" W.. 122.00 feet; thence N. 65°00')0" E. 58.35 feet to a point on the westerly right-of-way line of the Four Mile Creek County Road. l3 Asir SEO-ITP LTJ 5 TEL:303-945-5005 Nov 29 95 14:18 No.005 P07 IN THE DISTRICT COURT IN AND FOR WATER DIVISION NO. 5 STATE OF COLORADO Application No. W--3570 IN THE MATTER OF TUE APPLICATION FOR WATER RIGHTS OF WILLIAM L. FLOOD IN THE ROARING FORK RIVER O1; ITS TRTBUTARII:S TRIBUTARY INVOLVED: FOURNILE CREED) IN GARFIELD COUNTY ) FILED IN «'ATL:; COURT Division N,,. 5 9.7V'E OF FOLOPADO wATetl CI.Cr.' RULING OF REFEREE nt isK"trrY The above entitled application was filed on December 2, 1977, and was referred to the undersigned as Water Referee for Water Division No. 5, State of Colorado, by the Water Judge of said Court on the 13th day of January,_ 1978, in accordance with Article 92 of Chapter 37, Colorado Revised Statutes 1973, known as The Water Rights Determination and Administration Act. of 1969. And thn undersigned Referee having made such investigations as are ne- cessary to determine whether or not the statements in the application are true and having become fully advised with respect to the subject wetter, of the application docs hereby make the the Referee in this matter, to -wit: 1. The statements in the application are true. 2. The name of the structure is Flood Water Wel,I. 3, The name of the claimant and address is William L. Flood; 4339 Court, Road 117; Glenwood Sprints, Colorado. 4. The source of the water is a well having a depth of 115 feet, and being tributary to Four Mile Creek, tributary to the Roaring Fork River. 5. The well is .located in the SU SWt of Section 3, 1'.7S. R.89W. of the 6th P.M. at a point 1120 feet North of the South line and 680 feet East of the West line of said Section 3. 6. The water is claimed for domestic purposes; however, permit No. 63726 was issued by the Office of the State Engineer on August 28, 1972, subject to the following "conditions of approval"; This tac.11 shall be used in such a way as to not cause material injury to e:cist.in, water rights, The issuance of this permit does not assure the applicant that no injury will occur to another vested nrF,Ler right or pre- clude another owner of a vested water, right from seeking relief in E, civil court action. following determination and ruling as Approved for household use only, for one (1) single Emily dwelling and not to be used for irrigation. The return flow from the use of this well must be returned Lo the same stream system in which the well is located, 7. The date of initiation of appropriation is June 2.9, 1972. 8. The tnnount of water claimed is 0.033 cubic foot of water per second time, absolut,.r. 9. The wetter was f-irat applied to bene `a.ciel u ;c on September 21, 1972. The Referee does therefore conclude that the above entitled application should be granted in part and that 0.033 cubic foot of water per second of SE0-WTF. DIV 5 TEL:303-945-5665 Nov 29 95 14:43 No.006 P.08 time •l.: hereby awarded to the Flood Water Well, for household use only for one singIe family dwelling, with appropriation data of the 29th day of June, 172, absolutely and uno.ondiLlon&lly. The above described underground water right meets the criteria Cor F111 exempt domestic well pursuant to C.R.S. 1973, 37-92-604 4=4, so long as it is used for the purposes set forth herein, and by statute. It is accordingly ORDERED that this ruling shall be filed with the -iter Clerk and shall become effective upon such filing, subject to Judicial review pursuant to Section 37.92-304 CRS 1973. It is futther ORDERED that a copy of this ruling shall he filed with the appropriate Division Engineer and the State Engineer. Done at the City of Glenwood Springs, Colorado, this 5/ 4 7- day of 44f9'/ , 19 7e5) . ?to protuot was Mad to tbia Art. tr xne torogoing ruling ?6 cora icopei citid i ?roved, an to insAle th• xviagriven4i. Dna Daazoo of thio ohn:et . A1/6 -/V Dnts+u Plater Judge BY TUE REFEREE: : ,lateeferoe f?at a>'Division No. 5 Stele of Colorado DISTRICT COURT, WATER DIVISION 5, COLORADO Case No. 94CW344 JUDGMENT AND DECREE OF WATER COURT CONCERNING THE APPLICATION FOR WATER RIGHTS OF WEST DIVIDE WATER CONSERVANCY DISTRICT AND WILLIAM ZILM IN GARFIELD, PITKIN, AND EAGLE COUNTIES The Applicants, West Divide Water Conservancy District (the "District") and William Zilm, have applied for a surface water right for the Zilm Transfer Ditch, a change of water right for the Atkinson Ditch, and approval of a plan for augmentation and exchange. The Water Judge referred the Application to the Water Referee for Water Division No. 5, State of Colorado, in accordance with Article 92 of Chapter 37, Colorado Revised Statutes, 1973, known as the Water Rights Determination and Administration Act of 1969. The Referee ordered re-referral of the Application to the Water Judge on March 15, 1995. I. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. Applicants filed their Application in Case No. 94CW344 in District Court, Water Division No. 5, on December 28, 1994. Applicants filed an Amended Application on November 29, 1995. 2. All notices required by law have been made. 3. Statements of Opposition were filed by Ray D. Walker, James P. Mahan, Jr., Edmund Prehm, Lazy Diamond A Homeowners Association Ltd., the State and Division Engineers, Richard Hilleary, John M. Traul, Sr., Russell William Coletti, Jr., May S. Duncan, John H. Quinn, Jr., Faye B. Faas, Betty Byers -Coates, Brenda P. Zegarski, and Alan Wolf. Springridge Place Homeowners' Association was substituted as a party for Traul, Coletti, Zegarski, and Wolf. Duncan, Quinn, Hilleary, and Faas have withdrawn their Statements of Opposition. The Water Court summarily dismissed the Statement of Opposition filed by Walker and Mahan. Prehm, Springridge Place Homeowners' Association, Lazy Diamond A Homeowners' Association, and the State and Division Engineers have stipulated to entry of this Decree. Case No. 94CW344 West Divide water Conservancy District et al. Judgment and Decree of water Court Page -2- CLAIM FOR SURFACE WATER RIGHT 4. The Applicants claim a surface water right for the Zilm Transfer Ditch, more particularly described as follows: a. Legal description: The Zilm Transfer Ditch diverts from the left bank of Zilm Draw at a point whence the SE corner of Section 3, T. 7 S., R. 89 W. at the 6th P.M. bears S. 41° East a distance of 4100 feet. b. Source: Zil'm Gulch and return flow from diversions from Fourmile Creek, tributary to the Roaring Fork River c. (1) Date of initiation of appropriation: 6/1/1969 (2) How appropriation was initiated: construction of ditch and application of water to beneficial use d. Amount claimed: 2.0 cfs, absolute e. Use: Augmentation CLAIM FOR CHANGE OF WATER RIGHTS 5. Name of structure: Atkinson Ditch See paragraphs 8 and 9. 6. Proposed change: The District requests the right to use its interest in the Atkinson Ditch for augmentation purposes in addition to the currently decreed irrigation use. CLAIM FOR APPROVAL OF PLAN FOR AUGMENTATION AND EXCHANGE 7. Structures to be augmented (hereinafter "the augmented rights"): WDWCD.F32 July 17, 1996 1 '1 E Y my e C 0 , 0 u MAXIMUM EQR TO HE AUGMENTED UNDER EXISTING CONTRArTA ) 0 I O 0 O N pwi O O y f-. a;''- "'.u a d 4 < < Q Q < U U U G 0 i >v > H a+ _ 4 0. •' NUX 44 CO= t CS 4 de. in IN .n LC, N eo v) N ao )n N eP u) N OP ui N on . s .i. Js% f M < r a 0 1.m 2 L 1 08/03/1966 r so .4 m 0 so so a m O 0 06/29/1981 11/18/1980 In m - u'1 N v 0 N r o, v. O 0 0 1 06/30/1973 1 06/29/1972 06/01/95 0 0 N G t ' G G S 1 1 1 0 Z at 3 e e v1 3 3, U m m 3 3 :J Ui CD m ev 3 om )o � e `n 3 3, U CD CO O 40 O m O 3 *)*OU$x (Cr$) O O O 1) trt 0 O O O N N O m O O 4) -4 N C • • 0 CO Z a 4-440. In s.1 r I 0)-+ 41 C 7 0 C/1 Z Zilm Well No. N • 0 Z (1) 3 E -1 —4 0 Z 4-1 4) 3 E .•1 N 0 4) L) 44 0 0 -4 0 r-1 . 0 Cu 3 r g 0 0 CO 0 U • m + v a a 0. m •44 r-- -0 •O C '+ 0 0 to + 3 0 ON 4) Y 0.1 (r) C7 .-i O 40 .-1 CO • E 3.1 0 r 0 U N 17 m L rn E a a oci +i c -1 C •0 -4 7 O 40 0 30 3 • m a) 0 0 .1 Co C7 O 10 m O 0 O o .-1 L.• m a E r 0, U •--1 V) .•.1 .-1 r+O 0 a 0 3 3 0) 0 • m a) 04-1^•1 nr C7 wL7 t CV CV N CJ PO CO C1 4 4 4 m m O id id4 Fe O 0•- M X hi M M E4 Z kfl de ti N 0 ■ a 5 4 2 r 3 Lel U enrn 0 r 3 U a a U Cr, 0 U 0, rn 11 tal O u1 0 O O m O r -i O N O O O 3 6 F t0 T. m 0 4+ O o'Z c 0. -i r1 co 3 0 0 • L O .4 C O O c/ 3 0 0 x N .0 O O+ Z C .-1 7 4) In 3 0 0 L O' -•-i L U C -4 7 -•4 O • 0 Z m c Ca 0,10, m C. a 'O }J -4 '0 CO 5 O •a V 40'0 F 0 •7 1 0 d-1 0 3 c X v' C 7 O 41 y C1 U N \ O P. CO Ct E E C 0 a 4) 4 4 c w w 0 11 4) 11 c .0 4) 4) 3 4) 4 4) --/ w w 4.) 3 a 0 o . v 0 r9 4) 7� r 1, E C 'C •1 4 •.1 0 0 •.1 U a a w O C IC ° m 4) 4) U a 0 0 ...I .1 0 m - .-1 11 c o c c 4) -1 o 0 4) 11 ..1 -1 4 a1 4.1 u u •-1 0 0 4) a a1 0 ID 4) m m •o m -1 4) 4) c .0 4 7 11 4-1 4) •J 11 4 4 a1 o w w •O C 7 .. l'.1 O 4) 4) 0 a.0 , I •0 4) 4) C z 0 w w •.1 U ✓ U O m 4 0. u� 0 0 o a1 ✓ • „✓ 0 ON 4 0 c .,.1 e a Z •. i 4)0) N .. O D 4) 7'• o 0 O a L. 0 4) U a. Y 4) -i •.1 1-. c 0 0. 0. E Y 41 • C ..0 .0 47 a m-. 6. L 9 11 41 4) L' oc 11 11 .04 0 to a a T 0) 0 1.) 44 a +1t 4 L 6 CO •O -'9 C E E 4 4) _ 0 C1 4) 0 9 •-1 a a 11 4 4) c c 3 a . a 41 11 0 10 17 0 •a 4) 0 4) 4) 4) 4) a 4 .0 L 1.1 .-i = > 11 11 U a > 4) 0 w w •0 C O 0 0 0 u 4 4) • 0 41 A r.. 3 3 Ca 4 11 C • o1 O, 4) C • anO• CO CO 4 4) •.0U•• • of .0 U 0•0. U 11 m.0 CO' CO. to 7 4.+-1 4) a4 a -•1 0 4) a O 0 7 4 44 • 0 4) C Cr. 31) CO Z.0 4)4)44444) 41 1-1 4) 4) 4 -1 t` 1- N -1 4 .0 a .-1 4 EC9i1a4) 4) 4) 14 0 •O • F H 3 •O 0 4 .0 -1 - C 0 41 >v•.. E 7 [.. 11 • .1 -1 0 .. 0 .-1 4 m 3❑mIn.. .. -.4.0 >E �1 4) 1) 3 U C 0 N •4) -.-I0 0 T 0 0 m -m 0. 0 • 4) 7 .0 7 0 0 ON -.1 0 .... .0.-1 451, C 3 0 `- 11 .. 4, .. 4, O C O O a U U C •O a 4 4 L.4 0 4 C 4) C 1:11-4 C 4)04)0.4)0)00)0 C CO .0 .0 V 0-1 H -1 •.4 a 4) e• Q000). .11 .11 41 O.Ci 11 0 a O e 04) c .-1 0 U -1 11 11 -1 0 4) 0 ..1 4)111.10 m 0 011 0..un.•w 10.-1 4 •.i -1 -1 o a -1 W 3 c -1 4)004)0 44LZ•0tn•0 03 >-1Cc.4)0)444.4.m10 o44) P1>, 000e134)0EC.0me0) 4) m m 4 4)•-1 U T 4)y 11 •.0 4)0004)0 7E w 44 0)1.) 7Y.Oa°e70) Ot 00°0° Z - °,40 4).c44 0•-1•0Y CDdv s C •-• 1 4) m 4)-.1 4) � -4 -. -4 •-4 0. 0 41 3 4) 11-1 -1 O. T.•. •-1 ....1 4) 0 -4 > 0 3 014. 4 •O W 3 3 •1 AC m�CO C y0 w 4) m y.0 1.1 0 0 0> 0�04)0'0'4)-..44)-..1 T 4) 4 4) • -1 C L 11 .0 11 •0 •p 4) 4)04.-i-.-44)040 -4 0401001 TO 0.01000 T4 4 0 0 0 0 .i.-1 y y +1 4)+•1 -.C1 a W000'44)094440�043 4 >, 04.1 . -.4 4.)c0004)41411 4) a4) 11 11 11 4) 4) 01 .1)41.1.'M 10 .0 4) a a o.1 4 1144 a a 4.) U U O a 4 -1 4 4 0 4)U 4) 4) 4) 0 0 0 4) 7 .X a C 0.0 0.0 c w 4 a s 4 01 0 v1 W CO 4 11 4 11 E• -1 Case No. 94CW344 Nest Divide water Conservancy District et al. Judgment and Decree of Water Court Page -6- 8. Water rights to be used for augmentation: AoxczxxOI Atkinson Ditch" • ocxaf DA 05/11/1889 05/24/1882 C.A.132 4.0 cfs Fourmile Creek Green Mountain Reservoir) 10/12/1955 08/01/1935 2782, 5016, 5017 154,645 af :3lue River Ruedi Reservoir 06/20/1958 07/29/1957 C.A.4613, W-789-76 140,697.3 af 101,369 af Frying . Pan River Zilm Transfer Ditch 12/31/1994 06/01/1969 94CW344 2.0 cfs Zilm Gulch 1) Refer to paragraph 11bA for amount of Atkinson Ditch dedicated to plan for augmentation. 2) The District's contracts for Ruedi Reservoir and Green Mountain Reservoir releases are described in paragraph 11bC. 9. Legal description of point of diversion or place of storage of water rights to be used for augmentation. Atkinson Ditch: The headgate is located on the East Bank of Fourmile Creek about three miles from the mouth of said creek. Green Mountain Reservoir: The reservoir is located approximately 16 miles southeast of the town of Kremmling in Summit County, Colorado and more particularly in all or parts of Sections 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, and 24 of Township 2 South, Range 80 West in Sections 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 28, 29, and 34, Township 2 South, Range 79 West of the 6th P.M. Ruedi Reservoir: An on -channel reservoir located in the NW'/4 NE'/4 of Section 18, Township 8 South, Range 84 West of the 6th P.M. Zilm Transfer Ditch: Please refer to paragraph 4 above. 10. Uses: a. Atkinson Ditch — irrigation and augmentation WDWCD.F32 July 17, 1996 Case No. 94CW344 West Divide Water Conservancy District et al. Judgment and Decree of Water Court Page -7- b. Green Mountain Reservoir — in accordance with paragraph 5(a), (b), and (c) of the section entitled "Manner of Operation of Project Facilities and Auxiliary Facilities" in Senate Document 80 c. Ruedi Reservoir — generation of electric energy, domestic, municipal, industrial, irrigation, and stock watering d. Zilm Transfer Ditch — augmentation 11. Statement of plan for augmentation: a. Background The District intends to provide water to contract users within the Fourmile Creek basin for domestic, recreational, municipal, and commercial purposes. The District has consequently developed this augmentation plan to provide such a .- water supply for up to 500 equivalent residential units (EQR) within the Fourmile Creek basin. For purposes of this plan for augmentation, one EQR is based on the assumptions that 3.5 people live in each residence and use 100 gallons per day per capita for in-house use, and that 3500 square feet of lawn and garden will be irrigated at each residence. Depletions -to the stream system vary depending upon the type of waste water disposal system used: approximately 5% to 25% of in-house diversions are consumed when the waste water is centrally collected and treated, and approximately 15% of in- house diversions are consumed when the waste water is collected and treated by individual waste water treatment systems (septic tank—leach field). Irrigation depletions are estimated to be 80% of diversions, with a unit consumptive -use value of 1.99 acre feet per acre at lower elevations in the Fourmile Creek basin. Diversions and depletions for a single EQR are tabulated below (values in acre feet): WDWCD.F32 July 17, 1996 Case No. 94CW344 Meet Divide water Conservancy District et al. Judgment and Decree of Water Court Page -S- TTPg or WASTZWATs1t TRSATIO<XT SYSTEM IRRIGATlow S=asar (vAWZS Is L 2Z Flamm DTV-*3Tors DIPL TZare Ix- souse I uctattrTgr TOTAL IA- Houma IARIQATTos TOTAL Central Wastewater Treatment (5%) 0.199 0.20 0.399 0.010 0.160 0.170 Central Wastewater Treatment (25%) 0.199 0.20 0.399 0.050 0.160 0.210 Septic Tank — Leach field or central wastewater treatment (15%) 0.199 0.20 0.399 0.030 0.160 0.190 No Return to Fourmile Creek (100%) 0.199 0.20 0.399 0.199 0.160 0.359 Nay- nuts aasIos Swor DTvgssZOWS DSPLETIasS 0.193 0.010 0.193 0.048 0.193 0.029 0.193 0.193 The irrigation season is typically April 15 - October 15 in the lower Fourm b. Operation of plan for augmentation When the augmented rights are out -of -priority, augmentation will be provided first through diversions at the Zilm Transfer Ditch. When said Ditch is out -of -priority, augmentation will occur through dry -up of lands historically irrigated by the Atkinson Ditch and associated bypasses or storage releases from Ruedi Reservoir and/or Green Mountain Reservoir. This preferred order of augmentation and the actual augmentation source (or any combination of sources) may vary, depending upon the location of the call and the time of year. Each year the Applicant will report to the Division Engineer the number of units augmented by this plan and the type of sewage treatment by unit. Using the depletion information described in paragraph 11.a. of this decree, the Applicant will propose a plan of operation by April 1 for the upcoming administrative year (April 1 through March 31). Applicant will provide a copy of the plan to the Objectors Lazy Diamond A Homeowners Association, Springridge Place Homeowners' Association and Edmund Prehm upon their request. The plan will include at least diversions at the Zilm Transfer Ditch, a quantity of bypass water at the headgate of the Atkinson Ditch and/or releases from storage facilities as necessary to meet projected calls and as necessary to conform with the preferred order of augmentation described above. If the Division Engineer accepts said plan of operation, including proposed diversions at the Zilm Transfer Ditch, bypass and WDWCD.F32 July 17, 1996 _Z3- Case No. 94CM344 West Divide Water Conservancy District et al. Judgment and Decree o1 Water Cot. Page -.- releases, then administration the following year shall be in accordance with such. however, the Division Engineer may adjust the said plan of operation as he deems appropriate in consideration of the actual calls and stream conditions, if the actual call is different from the projected call estimated by Applicant. A. IRRIGATION SEASON - AVERAGE YEAR Irrigation -season depletions will be augmented by the cessation of, use of Applicant's interest in the senior priority in the Atkinson Ditch. The portions of the Atkinson Ditch dedicated to this plan are as follows: 1.00 cfs owned by the Applicant, West Divide of the senior priority (priority no. 33) of the Atkinson Ditch, described more fully in paragraph 8 above; Dry up of 50 acres of lands historically irrigated by the senior priority of the Atkinson Ditch as depicted in the attached Exhibit A; and 99.5 acre feet of consumptive use associated with the said 1.00 cfs and dry up of 50 acres. See footnote 1, page 6. The monthly distribution of consumptive -use credits associated with the portion of the Atkinson Ditch dedicated to the plan for augmentation is as follows: MONTS UNIT OF CONSUMPTIVE—USE CREDIT (FEET), TOTAL CONSUMPTIVE—USE CREDIT (ACRE FEET) APR 0.06 3.0 MAY 0.38 19.0 JUN 0.48 24.0 JUL(1) 0.45 22.5 AUG 0.29 14.5 SEP 0.25 12.5 OCT 0.08 4.0 TOTAL 1.99 99.5 July, August, and September consumptive -use credits may not be expected to be available in dry years. However, even in dry years, one-half of Applicant's interest in the Atkinson Ditch is made more dependable for purposes of thin augmentation plan by virtue of the WDWCD.F32 July 17, 1996 Case No. 94CW344 West Divide Water Conservancy District et al. Judgment and Decree of Water Court Page -10- District's long term contract with the owner of a one-half interest in the senior Fourmile Ditch priority no. 19. See paragraph 11b11 below. B. IRRIGATION SEASON - DRY YEAR At times in the past, the Atkinson Ditch has been out of priority to the Four Mile Ditch, Priority No. 19, with an adjudication date of May 11, 1889, and an appropriation date of November 11, 1886., In order to minimize the repetition of this circumstance in the future, the West Divide Water Conservancy District has entered into a long-term (40 years) contract (Exhibit B hereto) with the owner of a one-half interest in that Fourmile Ditch priority. The said agreement allows the Applicants to divert 0.5 cfs of the Applicants' interest in the Atkinson Ditch, Priority No. 33, out of priority to the said Fourmile Ditch, thereby making one-half of Applicants' interest in the Atkinson Ditch more dependable for purposes of this decree. The Court hereby approves said agreement and agrees that Applicant's interest in the Atkinson Ditch is thereby made more secure. The Applicants understand that this contract is of limited duration and if such contract expires, fails to be renewed, is terminated, or alternative sufficient sources of replacement water are not included in a temporary substitute supply plan or in this decrby proper amendment prior to such expiration, curtailment of,alllout-of-priority diversions ����will occur . �,\ o }} oL. �`ar? ! ) / i� t G LL.. /_ / i-1 1/ - During the irrigation season when the physical supply at the Atkinson Ditch headgate is 1.0 cfs or less, the Fourmile Ditch call (up to 0.5 cfs) shall be deferred to the Atkinson Ditch for Applicants under this plan. When the augmented rights are out of priority, Applicants will whenever possible (as a preferred order of augmentation) provide water to the Fourmile Ditch by diversions into the Zilm Transfer Ditch and by releasing such diversions to Fourmile Creek above the headgate of the Fourmile Ditch. Applicants may obtain a credit for said releases that may be applied directly to benefit the augmented rights or to improve the reliability of the Applicants' interest in the Atkinson Ditch. SMART AND GREEN AND GRISTY DITCHES Two ditch headgates on Fourmile Creek below the Fourmile Ditch and above the confluence with the Roaring Fork River have WDWCD.F32 July 17, 1996 Case No. 94CW344 West Divide Water Conservancy District et al. Judgment and Decree of Water Court Page -11- historically received a supply of water from ground water accretions to Fourmile Creek below the headgate of the Fourmile Ditch. Historically the supply available to such ditches has varied depending on the overall water supply in any given water year. At times the full decreed allocation has not been available to the Smart and Green Ditch, which derives its source of supply both from Fourmile Creek and the same unnamed tributary upon which the Zilm Transfer Ditch is located. Because Applicants' plan contemplates the replacement of 100% of depletions either to Fourmile Creek or the unnamed tributary above the Smart and Green Ditch, no injury should accrue to either downstream headgate. However, Applicants' proposal for augmentation releases is a complex system that may vary from year to year and season and season. In the evaluation of Applicants' annual proposal of operation and in the administration of such plan, the Division Engineer may consider that adequate water is made available to the Smart and Green Ditch, for example, by making deliveries to the Smart and Green Ditch via the Atkinson Ditch and the Zilm Gulch. C. NON -IRRIGATION SEASON Some non -irrigation season calls affecting the augmented rights are expected to come from outside the Fourmile Creek basin. Thus, Green Mountain Reservoir and Ruedi Reservoir releases may be used pursuant to this plan for augmentation during the non -irrigation season to augment depletions to the �, Roaring Fork River and the Colorado River. 4-. /✓0r67V' Green Mountain Reservoir: The District currently has a�temporary, water -service contract with the United States Bureau of ----- — -- Reclamation for delivery of up to 100 acre feet. As necessary, releases may be made from Green Mountain Reservoir to augment depletions pursuant to this plan. Ruedi Reservoir: The District currently has a water -service contract with the United States Bureau of Reclamation for release of up to 200 acre feet per year. As necessary, releases may be made from Ruedi Reservoir to augment depletions pursuant to this plan. The Applicants understand that these water service contracts are of limited duration and if such contracts expire, fail to be renewed, are terminated, or alternative sufficient sources of WDWCD.F32 July 17, 1996 Case No. 94CW344 West Divide Nater Conservancy District et al. Judgment and Decree of Water Court Page -12- replacement water are not included in a temporary substitute supply plan or in this decree by proper amendment prior to such expiration, curtailment of all out -of -priority diversion will occur. The most probable source of non -irrigation season calls affecting the augmented rights from within the Fourmile Creek basin is the Zilm ,hydropower right. In order to prevent injury to this hydropower right, Applicant has entered into an agreement (Exhibit C hereto) with the owner of the Zilm hydropower water right. Under that agreement, Zilm has agreed to accept payment (as described in the agreement) in lieu of augmentation replacement releases. 12. Pursuant to C.R.S. § § 37-84-112 and 113, the Applicants shall install headgates and measuring devices, provide accounting, and supply calculations regarding the timing of depletions as may be required by the Division Engineer for the operation of this plan. The Applicants shall also file an annual report with the Division Engineer by November 15th of each year summarizing diversions, depletions, and replacements made under this plan. Applicant will provide a copy of the report to the Objector Lazy Diamond A Homeowners Association, Springridge Place Homeowners' Association upon their request. A proposed accounting form is attached hereto as Exhibit D. The accounting shall include an accounting of upstream out -of - priority depletions covered under this plan for augmentation, so that a corresponding amount of water, when required, will not be called at the Atkinson Ditch headgate under Priority No. 33. The proposed accounting form may be modified as required by the Division Engineer. 13. Upon its own initiation or at Springridge Place Homeowners' Association's and/or Lazy Diamond A Homeowners' Association's request, West Divide will be responsible for making improvements to the Atkinson Ditch to allow for accurate measuring of any necessary bypasses at the headgate of such ditch in accord with the plan for augmentation decreed herein. West Divide shall have two years from the time of such request (if any) by Springridge Place Homeowners' Association and/or Lazy Diamond A Homeowners Association, to respond with the said improvements. WDWCD.F32 July 17, 1996 Case No. 94CW344 West Divide Water Conservancy Dictrict et al. Judgment and Decree of Water Court Page -13- 14. Furthermore, to ensure that no injury occurs to others, the District shall observe the following conditions during the operation of its augmentation plan: a. Each year the Applicants will submit to the Division Engineer a statement in the format generally represented in Exhibit D which contains calculations of depletions which would be tributary to Fourmile Creek upstream of the headgate of the Atkinson Ditch. The annual statement will also include a calculation of the depletions that are expected tb occur between the headgate of the Atkinson Ditch and the headgate of the Fourmile Ditch. The Applicants will also annually submit calculations of projected depletions to be made to that unnamed tributary of Fourmile Creek which has been referred to as Zilm Gulch, on which the Zilm Transfer Ditch headgates. b. When the Atkinson Ditch is being used as the augmentation source, out -of -priority depletions will be charged to West Divide's proportionate share of the Atkinson Ditch. Under circumstances where those depletions do not fully consume West Divide's proportionate share, West Divide can call for and leave its unconsumed share in the ditch for use by the ditch co- owners. c. Out of priority depletions will be replaced to other users so that water users on Fourmile Creek, including other users of the Atkinson Ditch priorities, may receive, through actual diversions, the amounts of water they would have otherwise received if not for the out of priority depletions. d. This decree contemplates that West Divide will add to the augmentation service plan (as described in this decree) additional points of diversion and/or water rights and/or EQR (above those currently represented in paragraph 7, Section I). In the event such future points of diversion and/or water rights and/or additional EQR are added, and approval of a substitute supply is requested from the State Engineer, notice will be given by the Applicant to the Objectors Edmund Prehm, Springridge Place Homeowners' Association and Lazy Diamond A of said substitute supply plan, and an opportunity to object thereto. Future points of diversion and/or water rights and/or additional EQR would be added on a permanent basis to the augmentation plan herein decreed only after the filing of an application in Water Court, notice of which is published in the resume, and an opportunity WDWCD.F32 July 17, 1996 Case No. 94CW344 West Divide water Conservancy District et al. Judgment and Decree of Water Court Page -14- given to all, including Objectors Edmund Prehm, Springridge Place Homeowners' Association, and Lazy Diamond A, to object on the basis of injury to water rights or for such other basis as may be provided for by law. II. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW 1. The foregoing Findings of Fact are fully incorporated herein. 2. The Court has jurisdiction over the Amended. Application and over all who had standing to appear in this action, whether they actually appeared or not. 3. The surface water right, change of water right, and plan for augmentation described herein are such as are contemplated by the law. If implemented and administered in accordance with this decree and the stipulations set forth herein, the change of water right and plan for augmentation described herein will provide water to contract users within the Fourmile Creek drainage basin without adversely affecting the owners or users of vested water rights or decreedconditional water rights. The change of water right and plan for augmentation described herein may be lawfully decreed by this Court. III. JUDGMENT AND DECREE 1. The foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law are fully incorporated herein. 2. The Zilm Transfer Ditch described herein is decreed an absolute water right. The change of water right for the Atkinson Ditch and the plan for augmentation described herein are approved, subject to the terms and conditions set forth herein. 3. The State Engineer and Division Engineer may lawfully be required under the terms of this decree to: a. Administer the plan for augmentation in the manner set forth herein. WDWCD.F32 July 17, 1996 tq- Case No. 94CW314 west Divide Water Conservancy District et al. Judgment and Decree of Water Court Page -15- b. Refrain from curtailing out -of -priority diversions of the augmented rights when the depletions are offset by the operation of the plan for augmentation approved herein. c. In conformance with Colo. Rev. Stat. § 37-92- 305(8), curtail out -of -priority diversions by the augmented rights at any time when the consumptive use associated with Applicants' provision of water as approved herein exceeds the net amount of replacement water available under the plan for augmentation. 4. In consideration of the specific findings and conclusions made herein and in conformance with Colo. Rev. Stat. § 37-92-304(6) (1990), as amended, the approval of the change of water right and plan for augmentation decreed herein shall be subject to reconsideration by the Water Judge on the question of injury to the vested water rights of others for five years commencing upon completion of the structures identified in paragraph I.7. Applicants agree not to assert the defenses of res judicata or collateral estoppel with respect to any future claim made during the said 5 -years retained jurisdiction period by Springridge Place Homeowners' Association and/or Lazy Diamond A Homeowners Association that the agreement between Bershenyi and West Divide Water Conservancy District (Exhibit B to this Decree) fails to operate to prevent injury to Springridge Place Homeowners' Association and/or Lazy Diamond A Homeowners Association or their successors or assigns. IT IS ACCORDINGLY ORDERED that this Decree shall be filed with the Water Clerk subject to judicial review pursuant to Colo. Rev. Stat. § 37-92-304. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that a copy of the Decree shall be filed with the State Engineer and the Division Engineer for Water Division No. 5. Dated: WDWCD.?32 July 17, 1996 BY THE JUDGE: Water Judge -30- EXHIBIT A ATKINSON DITCH Sec. 3 & 10, T 7 S, R89W, 6th PM WATER AGREEMENT THIS AGREEMENT is glade this 4 day of , 1994 by and between JOHN W. BERSHENTI and ALICE BERSHENTI, hereinafter referred to as "Bershenyi," and the WEST DIVIDE WATER CONSERVANCY DISTRICT, a quasi -municipal entity formed pursuant to Colorado statute, hereinafter referred to as "West Divide." WITNESSETH Bershenyi is the owner of those certain water rights described on Exhibit A, which exhibit is attached hereto and incorporated herein as those fully set forth; and WITNESSETH Bershenyi has, in the past, been forced to participate in litigation in Water Court in order to protect the yield of water available to said water rights; and WHEREAS West Divide is desirous of furthering its water allocation program in the Four Mile Creek region whereby it allocates water pursuant to C.R.S. 37-45-101 et. seq. to water users in need thereof, primarily for domestic and lawn irrigation type uses; and WHEREAS West Divide wishes to implement its program in cooperation with Bershenyi and in a manner that does not cause Bershenyi injury as set forth in this Agreement, FOR AND IN CONSIDERATION of the payments and promises to be made hereunder, the parties agree as follows: 1. Bershenyi agrees that he will accept payment as hereinafter described in lieu of replacement releases that otherwise would be made to meet calls made pursuant to the priorities listed on Exhibit A to the extent of 0.5 c.f.s., which 0.5 c.f.s. may be included in an allocation and augmentation program by West Divide. 2. West Divide shall pay to Bershenyi in consideration for the foregoing agreement not to call, the minimum annual sum of Five Hundred Dollars ($500.00), together with an additional annual sum in the amount of Twenty Dollars ($20.00) per acre foot for each and every acre foot allocated by West Divide pursuant in whole or in part to the water rights leased hereunder under its Four Mile Creek allocation program. 3. The term of this Water Agreement shall begin on the first day of January, 1995, and extend to and include the 31st day of December, 2035. Water Agreement John W. Bershenyi and Alice Bershenyi and West Divide Water Conservancy District -3i- EXHIBIT B Page 1 of 3 4. Each anniversary during the term hereof, the minimum annual rental and the per -acre-foot annual rental described herein shall be subject to modification. The minimal annual rental and the per -acre-foot rental shall be modified on the 1st day of January of each year of the term of this Agreement by the percentage of the rent which is equal to the percentage that the cost of living for the preceding twelve -(12) month period increased or decreased. The cost of living shall be computed upon the basis of the Consumer Price Index, All Urban Consumers, U.S. City Average 1982-84=100, published by the United States Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics. The base index number shall be the latest month available prior to January 1, 1995. The current index number shall be the same month of each year thereafter. Commencing on the second year of this Agreement and each thereafter, the rental shall be adjusted by computing the increase or decrease in the cost of living for the preceding twelve (12) month period and adding or deducting the same from the rental. The increase or decrease between the base index number and the current index number (expressed as a percentage) shall be multiplied by the rental. Any resulting positive or negative product shall be added to or deducted from the rental and the total thereof shall be paid in equal, successive, monthly installments. If at any time the Consumer Price Index is no longer published, the parties shall use such other index as is generally recognized or accepted for the purpose of making similar determinations of purchasing power. 5. As additional consideration for the agreement herein, West Divide agrees to investigate means by which Bershenyi's Reynolds Ditch may be rehabilitated and placed to efficient beneficial use in accordance with its decrees. Bershenyi is the owner of irrigated land under said Reynolds Ditch that is in need of irrigation from the ditch. 6. West Divide acknowledges Bershenyi's title to the water rights described in Exhibit A and exclusive use thereof except for the term of and pursuant to the terms of this Agreement. Further, West Divide agrees that it will appear in Water Court, as necessary, in order to protect Bershenyi's and West Divide's rights under this Agreement. 7. Bershenyi's agreement not to exercise an administrative call shall be conditioned upon West Divide's ability to cause either a bypass at the headgate of the Adkinson Ditch on Four Mile Creek, an amount of 1.0 c.f.s., or West Divide's ability, through agreement with others, to cause return flaws from an unnamed gulch immediately east of Four Mile Creek proper to be Water Agreement John W. Bershenyi and Alice Bershenyi and West Divide Water Conservancy District 33 ' Page 2 of 3 returned to Four Mile Creek above the gate of the Four Mile Ditch in the amount of 1.0 c.f.s, or a combination of the bypass and return flow to Four Mile Creek to occur in a total amount of 1.0 c.f.s. 8. West Divide shall be solely responsible for the installation of any and all measuring devices, recording devices, and administrative requirements associated with this Agreement. 9. West Divide agrees to hold Bershenyi harmless for and on account of any damages that may occur to Bershenyi and/or third party users contractees of West Divide's allocation program resulting from water use derived under this Agreement. 10. West Divide shall be solely responsible for obtaining all local, state, and judicial approvals necessary to accomplish water use pursuant to this Agreement. 11. West Divide may terminate the within arrangement should West Divide no longer need to rely on this Agreement to implement the allocation plan. THIS AGREEMENT is done this ' day of _R_c.„A„_„..4e4, 1994, and shall be binding upon the heirs, successors, and assigns of the parties hereto. Secretary "HN W. BERSHENYI ALICE BER ac, WEST DIVIDE WATER CONSERVANCY DISTRICT By 'id -5 '22 Water Agreement John W. Bershenyi and Alice Bershenyi and West Divide Mater Conservancy District eft 3`I - Page 3 of 3 EXHIBIT A FOUR MI LLE D ITC H =1AM pitch priority No. Amt, A.PP.DATE ikDJ.DATZ Four Mile Four Mile 19 1.6 11/6/1881 5/11/89 WATER AGREEMENT This Agreement made this „7:2'7h day of ��t �,,_ ) , 1995, by and between JOHN W. BERSHENYI AND ALICE BERSHENYI, hereinafter referred to as Bershenyi, and the WEST DIVIDE WATER CONSERVANCY DISTRICT, a quasi -municipal entity performed pursuant to Colorado Statute, hereinafter referred to as "West Divide." WITNESSETH, Bershenyi and West Divide entered into a Water Agreement dated December 28, 1994; and WHEREAS, the parties have determined that one paragraph of said Agreement should be amended. FOR AND IN CONSIDERATION of the payment and promises to be made hereunder, the parties agree as follows: 1. The parties agree that paragraph 7 of the Agreement of December 28, 1994 should be amended so that it will provide as follows: 7. West Divide shall cause either a bypass at the headgate of the Atkinson Ditch on Four Mile Creek or West Divide shall cause return flows from an unnamed gulch immediately west of Four Mile Creek to be returned in the Zilm Transfer Ditch to Four Mile Creek above the headgate of the Four Mile Ditch. The obligation to provide bypasses at either point shall be limited in that the amount of cumulative bypass at both points shall be that quantity of water available for bypass in excess of 0.5 cfs. 2. In all other respects, the Agreement between West Divide and Bershenyi shall remain in full force and effect. WEST DIVIDE WATER CONSERVANCY DISTRICT By A T:. l4 Secretary 'JOHN We, )ERSHENYI r ALICE `SERSHENYI -3 6 - WATER AGREEMENT THIS AGREEMENT is made thisaay ofd , 1994 by and between WILLIAM M. IILM and CHARLOTTE 5. $ILt, hereinafter referred to as "Zilm," and the WENT DIVIDE !CATER CONSERVANCY DISTRICT, a quasi -municipal entity formed pursuant to Colorado statute, hereinafter referred to as "west Divide." WITNESSETH Zilm is the owner of those certain water rights described on Exhibit A, which exhibit is attached hereto and incorporated herein as those fully set forth; and WITNESSETH Zila has, in the past, been forced to participate in litigation in Water Court in order to protect the yield of water available to said water rights; and WHEREAS West Divide is desirous of furthering its water allocation program in the Four Mile Creek region whereby it allocates water pursuant to C.R.S. 37-45-101 et. seq. to water users in need thereof, primarily for domestic and lawn irrigation type uses; and WHEREAS West Divide wishes to implement its program in cooperation with Zilm and in a manner that does not cause Zilm injury as set forth in this Agreement. FOR AND IN CONSIDERATION of the payments and promises to be made hereunder, the parties agree as follows: 1. Zilm agrees that he will accept payment as hereinafter described in lieu of replacement releases that otherwise would be made to meet calls made pursuant to the priorities listed on Exhibit A. This Agreement may be included in an allocation and augmentation prograa by West Divide. 2. West Divide shall pay to Zila in consideration for the foregoing agreement not to call, the minimum annual sum of Five Hundred Dollars ($500.00), together with an additional annual sum in the amount of Twenty Dollars ($20.00) per acre foot for each and every acre foot allocated by West Divide under its Four Mile Creek allocation program pursuant in whole or in part to the water rights leased hereunder. 3. The term of this Water Agreement shall begin on the first day of January, 1995, and extend to and include the 31st day of December, 2035. Vats: Agrsaaant Willlas� M. ills and Charlotte D. film and Wait Divide Mater Conservancy District EXHIBIT C Page 1 of 3 4. Each anniversary during the term hereof, the minimum annual rental and the per -acre-foot annual rental described herein shall be subject to modification. The minimal annual rental and the per -acre-foot rental shall be modified on the tut day of January of each year of the term of this Agreement by the percentage of the rent which is equal to the percentage that the cost of living for the preceding twelve -(12) month period increased or decreased. The cost of living shall be computed upon the basis of the Consumer Price Index, All Urban Consumers, U.S. City Average 1982-84.100, published by the United States Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics. The base index number shall be the latest month available prior to January 1, 1995. The current index number shall be the same month of each year thereafter. Commencing on the second year of this Agreement and each thereafter, the rental shall be adjusted by computing the increase or decrease in the cost of living for the preceding twelve (12) month period and adding or deducting the same from the rental. The increase or decrease between the base index number and the current index number (expressed as a percentage) shall be multiplied by the rental. Any resulting positive or negative product shall be added to or deducted from the rental and the total thereof shall be paid in equal, successive, monthly installments. If at any time the Consumer Price Index is no longer published, the parties shall use such other index as is generally recognized or accepted for the purpose of making similar determinations of purchasing power. 5. West Divide acknowledges Zilm's title to the water rights described in Exhibit A and exclusive use thereof except for the term of and pursuant to the terms of this Agreement. Further, West Divide agrees that it will appear in Water Court, as necessary, in order to protect Zilm's and West Divide's rights under this Agreement. 6. West Divide shall be solely responsible for the installation of any and all measuring devices, recording devices, and administrative requirements associated with this Agreement. 7. West Divide agrees to hold Zilm harmless for and on account of any damages that may occur to Zils and/or third party users contractees of West Divide's allocation program resulting from water use derived under this Agreement. - 8. West Divide shall be solely responsible for obtaining all local, state, and judicial approvals necessary to accomplish water use pursuant to this Agreement. Water Agreement William X. fill and Charlotte D. f is aid West Divide Mater Conservancy District 3$ Pagt 2 of 2 9. west Divide may terminate the within arrangement should West Divide no longer need to rely on this Agreement to implement the allocation plan. THIS AGREEMENT is done this Zday of i�ll� , 1994, and shall be binding upon the heirs, success•rs, and assigns of the parties hereto. st: Secretary WILLIAM M. ZILM /-7 CHARLOTTE B. ZILM WEST DIVIDE WATER CONSERVANCY DISTRICT By Water Agreement William X. fila aad Charlotte' D. film and Wsst Divide Mater Conservancy District -39- Fags 3 of 3 EXHIBIT A ATKINSON DITCH _ream Ditch priority No, Amt, roD,Date Adi,Date Four Mile Atkinson 2.0 9/29/1977 12/31/1979 Creek Ditch Four Mile Atkinson 2.0 03/24/1983 12/31/1985 Creek Ditch Four Mile Atkinson 2.0 03/24/1983 12/31/1985 Creek Ditch EXHIBIT D1 List of Water Contract Users for the Year O Z Depletion Location 4.a g I g jjI ii J 1 O dL C f=� 0 Location c i_ Y 1 .., ., Diversion Structure c Z 2 tract 15.O -1° o C3 2 W Con Name of Contractee I 1� N 2 O _2 O 2 2 O yi AIM t'N O O O A O co co .v co O O O co O Q Q to C) O O CD co o c.,) rn (D r O - Pi 1..- N- U" O CD t•-• CO N o O r- T I NcocD CV en Lin M O CD N O O O O ti o CO � O O O 1 h. O CO O Lo O O O f... 1-- 1 - CN CO G O O LO O O O I,- 1— ..— 0 0 o 0 0 r`1— 0 0 000 12 C .J' O I4 z v 11 4, c O t0 I— ,� LLl C) N C F W 0o JD p N m C g Y O QCo LU .;8 J o< 0E- 05 C> 7 O LL uVan lc%nulo.mii...1 e,..�.... LLl o< c ..........:sme yi AIM PLOT PLAN AND DESIGN FEATURES: Include by measured distance location of wells, springs, potable water supply lines, cisterns, buildings, property lines, subsoil drains, lake, water course, stream, dry gulch and show location of proposed system by direction and distance from dwelling or other fixed reference object, and additional submissions in support of this application such as data, plans, specifications, statements and commitments. `-i-k1 W IL a� o� �r d� � ger vim` �,. I/o'' ou��� 5'e�rJ. `�, d����� r O(e g' y�A`S Set �ci 4A �✓` 3g1 y�se r,,l \JorF no /le ex//f>7_i 5:y5/e, f I f>7 =fes �J Page 4 s _ - �L (5 ;, y �e a 4- / / di -e - exa t x ,> ° uJki ,. -pF 1s4• ir(+�; 4 GARFIELD COUNTY BUILDING AND SANITATION DEPARTMENT 109 8th Street Suite 303 Glenwood Springs, Colorado 81601 Phone (303) 945-8212 INDIVIDUAL SEWAGE DISPOSAL PERMIT N2 1723 Owner System Location Licensed Installer AAA' 5, AIM , .z"Z d 0 ZD d-? 3 7 ..0(/, // 7 6-44 p_,, ,/ This does not constitute I a building or use permit * Conditional Construction approval is hereby granted for a gallon - Septic Tank or Aerated treatment unit. Absorption area (or dispersal area) computed as follows: VL^.otl n, Perc rate of one inch in __ minutes requires a minimum of .2 -?2. L sq ft of absorption area per bedroom. Therefore the no. of bedrooms / x ¢1-; 2sq ft minimum requirement = a total of 3 21q ft of absorption area. 74/E" Off //VA L S `/ST E /1/i kV4 S /N sr,? L L <,D 5 May we suggest: c �� �/L 47/cAV S �,I/n y,h/Ek' is 0/�� T %' x E / S N U L 0 <../" % 7'//4 7-- 774/E E, -1-/.577A.16: ,92So.'T/O/J Date Inspector LF�Icz-T' ,4-1E4/) — ?¢'X2 5'x FINAL APPROVAL OF SYSTEM: i No system shall be deemed to be in compliance with the Sewage -Disposal Laws until the assembled system is approved prior to cover- ing any part. i Septic Tank access for inspection and cleaning within 12" of ground surface or aerated access ports above ground }' surface. " Proper materials and assembly. Trade name of septic tank or aerated treatment unit. i Adequate absorption (or dispel sal) area. '%, a; Adequate compliance with permit requirements. Adequate compliance with County and State regulations/requirements. Date Other` Inspector RETAIN WITH RECEIPT RECORDS AT—CONSTRUCTION SITE 'CONDITIONS: 1. All installation must comply with all requirements of the Colorado State Board of Health Individual Sewage Disposal Systems Chapter 25, Article 10 C.R.S. 1973, Revised 1984. 2. This permit is valid only for connection to structures which have fully complied with County zoning and building requirements. Connection to or use with any dwelling or structures not approved by the Building and Zoning office shall automatically be a violation of a requirement of the permit and cause for both legal action and revocation of the permit. 3. Any person who constructs, alters, or installs an individual sewage disposal system in a manner which involves a knowing and material variation from the terms or specifications contained in the application of permit commits a Class I, Petty Offense ($500.00 fine — 6 months in jail or both.). Applicant: Green Copy Department: Pink Copy INDIVIDUAL SEWAGE DISPOSAL SYSTEM APPLICATION ' OWNER J2 /y/,¢J' . J,?7. A-/067 ADDRESS -1- ��J y C /2„1//7 PHONE / - c7)(:') CONTRACTOR ADDRESS ( , S PHONE PERMIT REQUEST FOR: ( ) New Installation (X) Alteration ( ) Repair Application Approval by County Official: 17.7r Attach separate sheets or report showing entire area with respect to surrounding areas, topography of area, habitable building, location of potable water wells, soil percolation test holes, soil profiles in test holes. (See page 4.) � LOCATION OF PROPOSED FACILITY: County Legal Description 3 7 / �,� // 7 y S , Near what City of Town Lot Size O c/C_ WASTES TYPE: k.--) Dwelling, ( ) Transient Use ( ) Commercial or Institutional ( ) Non-domestic Wastes ( ) Other - Describe 7 O nF 7 .� �- J6 cc.. f"�1 BUILDING OR SERVICE TYPE: ;!�' S ,c- �' - v �— O�1�`!r�b c 1-`)".1-` c)" •y\ Gc''?. t e Number of bedrooms ��} Number of persons �— ( ) Garbage grinder ( ) Automatic washer ( ) Dishwasher < Af/e'b SOURCE AND TYPE OF WATER SUPPLY: ( X) well ( ) spring ( ) stream or creek Give depth of all wells within 180 feet of system: OK) If supplied by community water, give name or supplier: GROUND CONDITIONS: Depth to bedrock: �i ' k ti %-- j Depth to first Ground Water Table: Percent ground slope: DISTANCE TO NEAREST COMMUNITY SEWER SYSTEM: Was an effort made to connect to community system? TYPE OF INDIVIDUAL SEWAGE DISPOSAL SYSTEM PROPOSED: —) Septic Tank ) Vault Privy ) Pit Privy ) Chemical Toilet FINAL DISPOSAL BY: (`- Absorption Trench, Bed ( ) Underground Dispersal ( ) Above Ground Dispersal ( ) Other - Describe: Aeration Plant Composting Toilet ) Incineration Toilet ) Other - Describe: or Pit ( ) Vault ( ) Recycling, potable use ( ) Recycling, other use ( ) Evapotranspiration ( ) Sand Filter ( ) Wastewater Pond WILL EFFLUENT BE DISCHARGED DIRECTLY INTO WATERS OF THE q6 Page 2 STATE? /f,.% DEPARTMENT OF EMERGENCY SERVICES LMS • FIRE • RESCUE Mr. Eric McCafferty GARCO Planning Dept. 109 8th Street Glenwood Springs, CO. 81601 Dear Eric, LIG Q 9 1995 This letter is in reference to the Flood project up 117 road. Per our meeting, I wanted to advise you of some potential problems that may hinder our response to the area. As it stands now, there are several houses in the area that we will have difficulty protecting in the event of a fire. Any additional homes will only add to the problem. Our concerns are as follows: 1. There is no designated water supply for fire fighting anywhere in the area. 2. The road is narrow and does not provide the proper turn a rounds. 3. A bridge over four mile creek is not signed for it's capacity. Can we cross it with our heavy fire trucks? 4. The proposed road to the new house seems quite steep. It should not exceed Garfield County Road Standards. 5. The potential for the wildland/urban interface is extreme in that area. I suggest that any new homes meet the NFPA or Forest Service guidelines for mitigation. (Non combustible roofing, brush set backs ect.) 6. Proper addressing of the home is important. Addressing should be on mailboxes as well as in a visible place on the home. As I stated at our meeting, the potential is great for a fire in this area. I would suggest that the Flood's as well as any other persons living in the area be aware of our concerns. We may not be able to contain or adequately fight a fire because of the discrepancies. Even an ambulance response may be difficult because of the roads. If you have any questions or need any more information, please give me a call. S incerely, Jack Jones Asst. Chief, Glenwood Springs Dept. Of Emergency Services cc: file 806 Cooper Avenue • Glenwood Springs, Colorado 81601 • (303) 945-2575 • FAX (303) 945-2597 t• DEPARTMENT OF EMERGENCY SERVICES EMS • FIRE • RESCUE July 14th, 1995 Garfield County Planning Department 109 8th Street Glenwood Springs, Colorado 81601 RE: 4339 117 Road, Glenwood Springs, Colorado To Whom It Mat Concern: This letter is to verify that the above referenced property, owned by Dr. Bill Flood, is within the Glenwood Springs Rural Fire Protection District. The proposal is for two, three acre, single family lots. We would like to be assured of proper access to these lots, so we would appreciate being involved in the continued Planning/Building permit process. If you have any questions or need additional information, please do not hesitate to contact me at 945- 4942. Thank you for your time. Sincerely, James S. Mason, Fire Chief Glenwood Springs Department of Emergency Services cc: Jack Jones, Assistant Fire Chief 806 Cooper Avenue • Glenwood Springs, Colorado 87 1601 • (303) 945-2575 • FAX (303) 945-2597 t J