Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2.0 Staff Report 04.01.16lronbridge Lots 251-254 Amended Final Plat - Exhibits Administrative Review (File FPAA-02-1 6-8422) Applicant is BH Holdings, LLC, Aspen Signature Homes of lronbridge, LLC, and Larry and Karen Rainwater April 1,2016 Exhibit Letter (Numerical) Exhibit Description 1 Public Hearinq Notice lnformation 2 Receipts from Mailinq Notice 3 Garfield County Land Use and Development Code, as amended 4 Garfield Countv Comprehensive Plan of 2030 5 Application 6 Staff Report 7 Email from Bob Johnson of the lronbridge Homeowners Association dated March 11,2016 8 Letter and supporting information from Kelcey C. Nichols of Wood Nichols, LLC representing Wendy and Anthony Bontempo (owners of Lot 250), dated March 28,2016 I Referral Comments from the County Surveyor - dated March 29, 201 6) 10 Modified Amended Final Plat - Submitted and Dated March 31 , 2016 11 Agreement between Bontempo and BH Holdings, LLC, dated March 31,2016 12 Emailfrom Kelcey Nicols of Wood Nichols Law - dated March 31, 2016 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 File No. FPAA-O2-1 6-8422 Di rector's Determination DP PROJECT INFORMATION AND STAFF COMMENTS TYPE OF REVIEW APPLICANT (OWNER) REPRESENTATIVE SURVEYOR LEGAL DESCRIPTION PRACTICAL DESCRIPT!ON LOT SIZE ZONING RECOMMENDATION Amended Final Plat BH Holdings, LLC, Aspen Signature Homes of lronbridge, LLC, and Larry and Karen Rainwater Karl Hanlon of KarP Neu Hanlon, P'C. High Country Engineering, lnc. lronbridge Planned Unit Development, Block 3, Phase ll, Filing, 1,2, and 3, Parcel 251, 252, 253, and 254, County of Gar{ield, State of Colorado. - 28 Eagle Claw Circle, Glenwood Springs, Assessor's Parcel No. 239501929251(BH Holdings, LLC - Lot 251) - 52 Eagle Claw Circle, Glenwood Springs, Assessor's Parcel No. 239501 329252 (BH Holdings, LLC - Lot252) - 76 Eagle Claw Circle, Glenwood Springs, Assessor's Parcel No. 239501329253 (Aspen Signature Homes of lronbridge, LLC - Lot 253) - 100 Eagle Claw Circle, Glenwood Springs, Assessor's Parcel No. 239501 32925 (Rainwater - Lot 254) - Lot 251:.4,597 Sq. Ft. - Lot 252:4,273 Sq. Ft. - Lot 253'.4,193 Sq. Ft. - Lot 254: 4,289 Sq. Ft. lronbridge PUD Zone District PA-20 (Club Villas Residential) Approval with Conditions I. DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSAL - REQUEST The Applicant is requesting an Amended Final Plat to adjust the lot lines of Lot 251 ,252,253, and214of the lronbridge Flanned Unit Development, Block3, Phase ll, Filing, 1,2,and 3. The parcels are located wiinin the lronbridge PUD PA-20 Zone District and are zoned Club Villas. There is currently a single family dwelling on Lot 254 while Lots 251 , 252 and 253 are vacant' The amendment would ilter the property line approximately 1-5 feet between each of the parcels in order to accommodate the ioof overhangs of each of the dwelling units. ln addition, the Front: N/A Rear: N/A Side: N/A amendment enlarges lots 251-253 to the rear approximately 1-15 feet.with the.largest increases occurring to Lots 251 (5-7 ft.) and 252(12-15fi).These lots do not have setbacks and do not have building envelop.L. Th.'r."s and dimensional requirements for the Club Villas Zone District are below. on March 31,2016, Staff received a modified Amended Final Plat in order to reduce the impact on Lot 250. This modified plat reduces the amount that Lots 252 and 251 will be increased to the rear from 1-15 feet to approximately 1-4 feet. This Plat is more fully discussed in the staff Analysis section of this RePort. 7. Club Vlllas Zone District lntent: lndividual tot and unit ownership with sinBle family residential structures and Affordable For-Sa le Residential Dwelling Units' permitted Uses: Single-family residential units attached or detached; deed restricted single famllY residential units comptylng with the requirements of the 6arfteld CountY Affordable Houslng Regulatbns anO AuiOitinel. (sections 4.07.15.O1and 4.14, Garfield County Zoning Resolutlon of 1g7g, as amended); non-habitable accessory buildings and structures; home offices; sales/rnarketing center; time share or ftactional ownershlp unhs; public and private roads; open space; tralls; utlllty and drainage easements Minirnum tot size: 4,000 square feet fOr detached units; no minlmum lot size for attached units - commonownershipofopenareaswlthinthiszonelspermitted' Maximum Gross Density: 8 dwelling unlts/acre Minimum Gross Density: 4.0 dwelling unitVacre Maxlmum bulldlng helght: 35' Mtnlmum lot width: no mlnimum lot width for detached or attached units Minimum lot depth: no mlnimum lot depth for detached or attached units Minimum prima ry building setbacks: parklng: A minimum of 2 parking spaces rnust be provided for each primary ltructure; this requirement may be satisiied uy-tne garage, driveway, on'street parking and/or cornmon parking ar€4. Density: 47 Units (Nher: No EuildinS Envelopes are required. Lots 259 and 285 are exempt from the minimum lot square footage requlrements. No changes to the existing access or utilities addition, no nonconforming conditions have modification. are proposed as a result of the amended plat' ln been noted which would result from the lot line 2 II. AUTHORITY - APPLICABLE REGULATIONS The Amended Final Plat Application is being processed in accordance with Section 5-305, Amended Final plat Review and Tables 5-103bommon Review procedures' Section 4-103 and 4-101 address details of the review procedures' The Application has been determined to be complete. Public notice was required for the Director's Decision in accordance with Sections 4-103 and 4-101 . The Applicant has provided evidence of completion of the required notice for the Directors Decision. III. STAFF ANALYSIS 1. The Applicant's proposal was reviewed against the Amended Final Plat Criteria contained in Section 5-305 (C), as follows: 1. Does not increase the number of lots; and - The proposed Amended Ptat witl not increase the number of lots. 2. Does not resuit in a major relocation of a road or add any new roads; or - The proposed Amended Plat wilt not result in a maior relocation of a road or add new roads. 3. will correct technical errors such as surveying or drafting errors. - The Amended Plat has not been proposed to correct technical errors. 2. No conflicts with the existing underlying zoning have been noted including lots size and setbacks. 3. No changes to existing utility locations or access are proposed as part of the amended plat process. 4. The Application was referred to the County Surveyor, who identified no issues with the proposed plat surveY. 5. The Applicant completed the County Public Notice lnformation form indicating that public notice was sent on March g,2016. Certified mail receipts were also provided. No public comments from adjacent property owners were received by the Community Development Department in response to the public notice. Staff has reviewei the Applicant's representations and evidence regarding public notice and it appears the requirements have been adequately satisfied' 6. An email was received from Bob Johnson of the Homeowners Association which states that,,The Association feels this is acceptable as long as it does not impede future development." 7. A letter and supporting information was received from Anthony Bontempo, owner of Lot 250, indicating that ttre prop-osed amended plat will diminish the value of their property by impeding theil view of Mbunt Sopris. Supporiing architectural renderings, an opinion from an apiralseir, a letter f rom their representing liw firm, and background approval information has been pi:dvioeo. The information and letter reJeived from Mr. Bonlempo is attached as an exhibit' The Applicant's law firm, represented by Kelcey Nichols,.noted that the application is not consistent with the standards in section 4-106, specifitally that the application will "change the character of the development,, and will "alter the basic relaiionship of the development to adjacent property'" While Amended Final plats are considered Land Use Change Permits, since Section 5-305 is more specific to Amended Final Plat applications, section 5-305 is the governing section of the code for this type of application. Unfortunately, the standards quoted relate to determining whether an amendment to an approved Land Use Change Permit is a substantial or Minor Modification and is not relevant for the County to use in reviewing an Amended Final Plat application. The review criteria for an Amended Final Plat are found in section 5-305 and are listed above in section lll.1. staff has determined that the Amended Final Plat as presented meets the review criteria listed in Section 5-305' Following further discussion between the Applicant and the property owners 9i r-ot 250' an agreed upon modified lot line configuration *". "rirnged. These modiiied lot lines alter the rear and side lot lines for Lots 251 and 2S2inorder to piese,ie the existing views for Lot 250. staff recommends that a condition of approval requiring that these modified lot fnes be carried forward for final review and recording. lv.SUGGESTED FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATION staff supports a finding that the Lot 251,252,253, and 254 of the lronbridge Planned Unit Development, Block 3,"Phase ll, Filing, 1',2, and 3 Amended Final Plat Application meets the requirements and standards of the 6rtii"tO County Land Use and Development Code as amended and is recommended for Administrative Approval by the Director of the community Development Department subject to the following conditions of approval' 1. That all representations of the Applicant contained in the Application submittals shall be conditions of approval unless specificaliy amended or modified by the conditions contained herein. 2. The Plat shall be subject to final review and approval by CounY Stqll prior to submittal of the Mylar plat for tinat execution, BOCC signature and recording lSee Condition #3)' All standard plat certificates and signature blocks shall 6e included on the final plat. The following amendments shall be made to the Plat: a. The names and addresses of all mineral owners shall be listed on the plat; b. The Book and page of the recorded Protective Covenants and Restrictions shall be added to the Plat; c. A Taxes paid Certificate shall be added to the plat for each Lot in a form Prescribed bY the CountY; d. The County Commissioners Certificate shall be corrected to match the form Prescribed bY the County; e. The plat shall reference the title work provided with the application and that all exceptionsnotedinthattitleworkareshownontheplat; f. A plat note shall be added explaining why this amendment was conducted' 3. The Applicant has 90 days within which to satisfy conditions of approval and provide the following documentation for Bocc signature and recordation: a. A plat mylar with signed Certificates that include Dedication and Ownership, Titie, Taies, Applicant's Surveyor, Lienholders and any mortgagees; b. Recording Fees. 4. The Amended Final plat as submitted and dated March 31, 2016 and depicting modified property boundaries for Lots 251 and 252 shall be the approved lot configuration' Vicinity Map Amended Plat - As Originally Submitted Amended Final Plat - As Modified (submitted March 31 , 2016) xo''NtrFiI* cNl 'rNrrr?tHl9Na AUINnOS H9lH q \6, (t ,;R i. i,i.;FS S" 913 'uil" ,,$[ri, li I l',1j' ^ft i:wqiE \. "qr$.*P' z1P'11 tco63"^ "-",^-3 .,,Rli 'e,b i g \ \Efrt\t-\a\_t\ \ \ --*--11 ) ot\qt l-o*J oo &-- Jo.,a), Lo UJF( F6 ciJlrj EE</:o\u'o Ez:)oU : o, Flo lrl t- t&o Fo !J!o(o tdu2 trFfoa, F c oz 3oF; 2o tr(, LIo zf I,Ja I& (Y)voo o 6Na F.o trol- TLo Modified Property Lines from Original Proposed Amendment c I Original Property Lines N.,,KiiiirS'9:.\ {/^$ ''*it u'""stu /. l- ilr+etr I PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE INFORMATION Please check the appropriate boxes below based upon the notice that was conducted for your public hearing. ln addition, please initial on the blank line next to the statements if they accurately reflect the described action. E My application required written/mailed notice to adjacent property owners and mineral owners. X Mailed notice was completed on the 8th day of Mtrch '2016' x All owners of record within a 200 foot radius of the subiect parcel were identified as shown in the clerk and Recorder's office at least 15 calendar days prior to sending notice. X All owners of mineral interest in the subject property were identified through records in the Clerk and Recorder or Assessor, or through other means [list] ..-..-..- r Please attach proof of certified, return receipt requested mailed notice' tr My application required Published notice' Notice was published on the day of .--_.---' 2016' .PleaseattachproofofpublicationintheRifleCitizenTelegram' My application required Posting of Notice' Notice was posted on the day of -'2016' Notice was posted so that at least one sign faced each adjacent road right of way generallY used bY the Public' I testify that the above information is true and accurate' Name: Signature: tr Garfield Cournty Date: r Complete items 1,2, and 3. I Print vour name and address on the reverse ' ' so thit we can return lhB card to you' r Atach thls card to the back of the mallpiece' or on the front if sPace '1. Article Addresssd to: Blue Heron ProPerties LLC 1007 Westbank Road Glenwood SPrings, CO 81601 cl C. Date of Delivery ?"/G- 6il-ffiiz trl Y"sD. ls dellv€ry address diflaront iiom lt€m l ' u re'-' iiiES,iitt"t oellvery address below: E No JI fr!r{ rr .Ir rl ru EtE Et (:l mr!r{ rnrlE rL {}a A, Slgnaturo E Agent Cl Pdorlty Mall ExprB6@ tr FegleterBd Mallil tr RslstoEd Mall Feoltloted OellverY tr Retum R€€lPtfor M*hand186 O SlgnatuB Conflmsrlonil E SlgnatuE Conflmallon Rosldct€d Osltugry ilt llllil llil lll I llll I I lll lllllll ll I I I ll lll lll 9s9o s4o2 1329 52Bs 2733 68 t=..,.,.n. .-h.. *ern r lmm *wice label ?815 l,?3U BDCIe 1,9I7 PS Form 381 1, .luty zots PsN 7530-02-000-e053 3. Servlc,e El Aduli SlEmtuleg Adult Slgnatut6 RBtlctsd Ddlwy tr Coiufled Mall@ El C€ttfled MallR€stlatsd Hlwry Domestic Return RecelPt ' GLEHI|O0O $PRINGST C0 EFdu.nRedpt(hsdc;py, $ ElRstuh Rsdpt (61@t onlc) t f]Ce.tmod MElt R€ldctod D.livqy I EAdult Slgf,duro fbquired 0 E] Adutt Slgnalm FsrhBd Ooiv€ry I 0fffi S3t{tS/2016 &oo r Blue Heron Properties 6nfi;i;i,W'^ 1007 Westbank Road i."dtiib,tii,i Glenwood Springs, CO 81601 LU.S. PostalService'" CEBTIFIED MAILO RECEIPT lGtdcted D€llvory I,.mr. 11 rrrcIr -l ru Ettf E3 [f,mr#l rnr{ EIr- 16.7{ WendY & Ant iiridrli,LM 4 Eagle Claw Circle -\-r ,ini;i?iii.i Glenivood Springs, CO 81601 r Complete items 1, 2, and 3' I PIint vour name and address on the reverse so thit we can return the card to you' I Attach this cad to the back of the mailpiece' or on the front if space Artiole Addressed to:D.G d"llr"ty "ddt*" anery1t trol 1a t t Yes It YES, €nter ENo Wendy & AnthonY BontemPo 4 Eagle Claw Circle Glenwood SPrings, CO 81601 ffi$6or r.j fii"i*'a*"lPl ti.nl'iPvt $ ERoturn Rerpt {otwmnlc) I frce^lf,od Mdl Bost'tctsd oorvsy $ -fiadun stgnatuc Rooutnd : E Mn srqq:-Iolr*:r egj;= U.S. Postalservice'" cEiirlFigD MAI L3 H EcElPr ,r"js COMPLETE IH'.S SECTION ON DELIVERY ilIilll llll illllllIIlll ll Illllll I I llll ll lll 9s90 9402 1329 5285 273375 ?81,5 1?3U UoBa 111? 1?35 ' PS Form July 2015 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 Domestlc Raturn Feceipt B n6lum R*dPt (h adcopy! fl Rotum Beolpt (6le1onlc) E codlfled Mall Fsst lgied DslvsY EAdult signsturc Rsqulcd EAdult Signalurs R6slr cted ikllwY ftafldn Signature Of Ironbridge LLC "diir,?in:ni, 1555 Palm Beach Lakes Blvd, -*ii6;r,Fi-,i' suite 1 1 00 r Complete ltems 1,2, and 3. I Printyour nam6 and address on the reverse so that we can return the card to you. t Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, or on lhe front if space permits. 1, Micle Addressgd to: Aspen Signature Homes Of Ironbridge LLC 1555 Palm Beach Lakes Blvd, Suite I 100 West Palm Beach, FL 33401 ilIffill llll tilIllllIIffi llIllIllliI ll IllI lll 9590 9402 1329 528s 2621 40 E AdulislgnaturB 0 Adult SrgnatuE Bostlc{sd Piltuqryf] Cerrlfled Mall@ tl Codl0od MallRestrlcl€d Doltvery tr Collooton Dellvory tr Collect on Odlvory Resldctsd Dsiivory EI No ru rurr n-r{Ir ruE EI E] Etmr! rjl ul r-{Er! E Agent El Addro$ee C. Date of Delivery Yes lrafi sowicolabol) 7U15 173n CI00a 11I?1? a e Fs{Slcltdpdvnry tr Rlodty MollB(prsss@ El Rsgld€rcd Malnl tr Boslsl€rsd MB,l Hgsfict€d D€livsry tr R€t{nnnocdE$ MorElundlsa D SlgnatumCornmdlofltx O S{rnatuECo{rfimuilsr Beol$oted Delivery I PS Form 381 1 , .tuty zots PSN 7630-02-000-s053 Domostic R€tum Recdlnt I U.S. Postal Servicd" CERTIFIED MAILO RECEIPT rI, l rtr!r:l r!r{rr r{ ru E]EE 6trlrrrc Em ru d rjtrtEr- rL rjl !E-r{ ru EIaE Emr!r:l tJl r{ E r! Jay D & NancY Ann Billington 179 River Vista Glenwood SPrings, CO 81601 tts/$g/2$l$ Larry R & Karcn L Rainwatcr E Agent Date of D€llvery from ftem 1? bolowl E No B Prh3dty Msu ExPr€3sO llllllllllllllllllllllllllfill[!l!]!tllllll lHfg[,*"ffi.*..l:''"* lgiiffi11p- e5e0 e402 132e 5285 ;;;i;; lEiiiiffiul'fr*EtedDdlv.ry "ffffifug'"'*' on o'"]3U'""ctod Dotrvsry g $l;U$]ffin-,.*'r'"*Tl Domesl'tc Ao-urii ;wo'P' i I ps for, 381 1 , July 2015 PSN 7s3&02-000-e053 oneH*, l{E 611}{ .' fi Aetum Bo@ipl (hodtopy) E Botum Bsc€lpt (6locmnlc) E Cqnm€d l,tolt Rsilot6d E Adult SlonatuE R6q!1rud E Adult Sgnntrm Rasitloted ;l:rr;Aai'i:lvi,: 3814 N 95th Street s1;'ia;'Ji$4s Omaha, NE 68134 ;'.{rii;;?ip; Glenwood Springs, CO 81601 r Complete ltems 1,2, and 3' r Print vour name and address on ths reverse so th6t we can return the card to you' I A.ttach thls card to tho back of lhe mailpiece' or on the fiont if fl538 l2 Postrnatfi . H€Is Poslrnar[ llaro ,' g3/08/2016 16,71 JayD& '179 River /) Posimertv gf . a"r. "l 03t08/2ufi ru TT --Er:l r! 11IT .rt ru EI trlE Emrrr{ r tfl r:ttf,rr rrE EO ra r!r{trrI'alrulololol-II t6.7{ Charles Scott CourtneY tfl EO --Er{ r-r{ TTrf nRshrmBocdPt(bardoPy) t EFetudRocolpt{olocironlc) t Ec"dfaa Mdtnata"t"a Del}!!ry t EAduh signatu6 RoqulEd g ElAdult S4rn(tdD Rstrlcted oollv€iy S ;,a;i,irnii:]i/b: 26844 West Shadolv Circle Ci0i-Sil;?r;?Pi?r Olathe, KS 66061 E Rstum Beelpt 0'ard@Py) E ReM B*6lpt (elehnh) fl Adult sitnaturo R€qul€d nr\dr$ Sagnatuo Restrlclod Charles Scott CourtneY m 155 River Vista ;*iiid?tptd Glenwood Springs, CO 81601 {srl, orro*/zor6 Livins Trust $i'{-r;;7ir:'ri;r 3 5 I 0 *Hollow Court siii;;ziFi'i' Grand Junction, CO 81506 o B ! r,"^,nruEI6E cfmPrt l.r)r{E rL U.S. PostalService' CEBTIFIED MAIL@ RECEIPT Domestic Mail U.S. Postatservice' CEBTIFIED MAILO RECEIPT Domestlc Mail 053S,t2 8#* L. Lenderman U.S. Postalservice'" cEnrrrleD MAIL@ REcEIPT Eo rL .-0r:l rl,r1 ,Irrq ruIf,[f,[f Emrrrl ttl Er! I Complote items 1,2, end 3. r Print your name and address on the r€verse so thal wo can return the card to you' I Attach thls card to iho back of the mailplece, or on the fronl if space 1. Articl€ Addressod to: Jason J & Megan F Maceachen 134 River Vista Glenwood Springs, CO 81601 *q* :o ol Dellvery 3.tb tt Yes ENo tr Prlorlty Mall ExPres@ - O Reglstered Ma[n tr Foslgtered Mall Feerb-bd El€llv€ry tr FBtum Fl€celptfor M€rchard166 tr Slgnatur€ Conflrmatlonil E Slgnqture Conflrmation Eostrlct€d Dellvory il I lillll llll lll I ll ll I I lll ll I ll I ll I ll I lllll lll 95909402 1329 5285 262072 ,. Artlclo Number (*anster from servlce label) 7815 1730 UoEe 11r? D Ad$lt Jason J & Megan F Maceachen iii,idr4;'fi,6:i 134 River Vista -3iata'2iPr,i6- Glenwood Springs, CO 81601 ; PS Form 381 1 , July 201 5 PsN 7530-02-000-s053 Domastic R€turn ReceiPt ; U.S. Postalservice'" CERTIFIED MAILO REGEIPT Domestic Mail Only lestrictsd Dsllvery Deltuory.' r{J'JIr:l PrtIT ruEEE Emrrrq UIr{Er! 5rrl JI ln-| '.ato-lxlsIi EAdu[ ggn.tuE RequiBl t nAd* Srniltqo Batr,ct€d Dollv.ry 0 I netm arcePt 6roacopg E Fotum Relpr (e!*mlc) B cedmed Mqll Fe"hlct*l Bellvery Ironbridge Property Owners i,liJnin: ila:; As sociation, In c 1007 Westbank Roadcjfi siiirio' ?lpida' Glenwood springs, co 81601 Horg James L. Rose ;;i;fid ili:i!t,., P.o. Box 432 i'.$aiil?ipid..{r Rifle, CO 81650 U.S. Postal Service- CERTIFIED MAIL@ RECEIPT Domestic Mai! EXHIBITl+David Pesnichak From: Sent: To: Subject: Follow Up Flag: FIag Status: Bob Johnson <bob@fleisherre.com> Friday, March L7,207612:L8 PM David Pesnichak RE:lronbridge Lots 251-254 - Referral - Amended Final Plat Flag for follow uP Flagged The Association feels this is acceptable as long as it does not impede future development' Thx Bob Bob Johnson COO/General Monoger bob@f leishetre.com Phone (970) 704-1515 ext.115 Fleisher Reol Estote 981Cowen Drive, Ste B-5 Corbondole, CO 81623 www-f leisherre.com From: David Pesnichak Imailto:dpesnichak@garfield-county'com] Sent: Friday, March 04,2OL61-1:04 AM To: scott Aibner <saibner@comcast.net>; Kelly cave <kcave@garfield-county.com>; Bob Johnson <bob@fleisherre'com> subject: lronbridge Lots 251-254 - Referral - Amended Final Plat Hello, The Garfield county community Development Department has received an application for an Amended Final plat on a parcels owned by BH Holdings, LLC, Aspen Signature Homes of lronbridge, LLC, and Larry and Karen Rainwater (Lots251-254)inlronbridge,Block3,phaselt,Filing T,2,and3.AttachedistheReferral Formregardingthisapplication' please open and read it for instructions on accessing a digital version of the application. Your comments are an important part of the evaluation process. ln order to review all appropriate agency comments and incorporate them into the staff report, we request your response by Fridav March 25, 2016. To access the application, go to: http://records.garfield- rchName=Bui Thank You ! David Pesnichak, AICP Senior Planner Garfield CountY Comm unity Development Department EXHIBIT g WOOD NICI]OI.S. LLC ATTORNEYS AT I,AW March 28,2016 Mr. Frederic Jarman CommunitY DeveloPment Director Garfield County Planning Department 108 8th Street, Suite 401 Glenwood SPrings, CO 81601 Hand-delivered Re: Opposition to Final Plat Amendment lronbridge Phase ll, Filing !'2'3 - Lots 25-254 Dear Mr. Jarman, ThislawfirmrepresentsWendyBontempoandAnthonyBontempo(collectively,the ,,Bontempos,,), the owners of 4 Eagle Claw Circle, Glenwood Springs, Colorado, more particularly described as Lot 250, lronbridge Planned Unit Development, Filing 1, 2 & 3 ("Bontempo Property")' The Bontempos oppose the Final Plat Amendment lronbridge Phase ll, Filing 1",2,3-Lots 251-254 ("Plat Amendment") due to the adverse impact that the Application, if granted, will have on the Bontempo Property' Although the plat Amendment has been designated for the Administrative Review Process' the Plat Amendment, if granted, will have a significant negative impact on the Bontempo Property' The Plat Amendment is a ,,Land Use change" as defined under the Garfield county Land Use code: Land use change. Any development, grading, construction' activity or operation that changes the basic character, configuration or use of land or structures after the enactment of this Code constitutes a change in land use. Garfield County Land Use Code, Section l'5- 17. The plat Amendment will substantially change the current configuration of Lot 251' Lot 252 and Lot 253 as shown on the Amended Final plat of Block 2 of Phase ll, recorded on July 22,20L4, Reception No. 851541 l'20t4 Plat"). Moreover, the Plat Amendment will both "change the character of the development,, and "alter the basic relationship of the development to adjacent property"' which is the Bontempo property. see Garfierd county Land Use Code, Section 4-J-06. Accordingly, the proposed Plat Amendment must be denied under section 4-106 of the Garfield county Land Use code' lf granted' the plat Amendment will result in a diminution in value to the Bontempo Property and may also constitute a taking, l. The BontemPo ProPertY The Bontempo property, Lot 250, is located immediately behind the three lots Applicant BH Holdings, LLC, proposes to expand. The Plat Amendment will have the most significant impact on the JoSLYNV.WooD:JVW@WooDNlcHoLSLAW.CoM-KELCEYC.Ntcuot-s:KCN@WoODNICHoLSLAWCoM 201 MAtN STREET, sUtrE 305, cARBONDALE, co 81623 | PHoNE 970.963,3800 | FAX 877 '4225070 Bontempo Property, on which the Bontempos have built a single story house. The current view from the Bontempo Property is shown on the architectural drawings and brief ,,movie,, attached Exhibit A. The architectural drawings show the existing conditions, the conditions after houses are built on the existing rots as configured in ir,e 2ot4 prar,and the conditions if the prat Amendment is granted. The drawings show that there wi, be a significant impact on the Bontempo property if the prat Amendment is granted' The plat Amendment will substantially reconfigure the relationship between the Bo.ntempo Property and Lot 251 in particular, to the detriment of the Bontempo Property' on the 2o1I4Plat' Lot 251 is located behind the Bontempo property. rf the prat Amendment is granteo, t-ot zsr wi, move armost 16 feet closer totheBontempoPropertycomprisingbothprivacyandviewsontheBontempoProperty. TheBontempospurchasedtheBontempoPropertyin200s'Lot250isacornerlotwith unobstructed views, The Bontempos are rong-time Roaring Fork Varey residents. wendy Bontempo has rived in the vailey since 1gg1. she is the vp of*rinance and Administration at Mason and Morse' she is the formerBusinessDirectorofChallengeAspen,whereshealsotaughtadaptiveskiing.AnthonyBontempo haslivedinthevalleysincelgT5.HemanagedtheTowerRestaurantinSnowmassandnowworksfor Telephone Systems Consultants as a senior technician' TheBontemposlookedatnumerouslotswithinlronbridge.TheBontemposselectedLot250due to its location and the relationship between the neighborlng tJs (Lot 251, Lol252 and Lot 253) which provideforprivacyandunobstructedviews.TheBontemposfurtherpaidapremiumpriceforLot250, which was crassified as a ,,premium,, lot due to its unobstructed views, privacy, and corner location' Not only were these features important to the Bontempos, they have a significant impact on the value of the BontempoProperty.lfthePlatAmendmentisgranted'theBontempoPropertywillnolongerbea "premium" lot. TheBontemposwereoneofthefirstpeopletobuildinlronbridge.Theirsinglestoryhouseis oriented toward the south, Mount sopris and the Roaring Fork River. they have buirt their house to take advantage of these views' Their porch is on the southern side of the house' Il.ThePlatAmendmentfailstocomplywiththeGarfieldCountyLandUseCode. ApplicantBHHoldings,LLC,hasfiledanapplicationtosignificantlyexpandLot25l'thelot immediately adjacent to the Bontempo eroperty to the south' totzizand Lot 253' Applicant purchased Lot 251 and Lot 252 onDecember 3t,zor5. Rppiicant purchased Lot 253 on october 29,2015' All of these lots were purchased subject to the 2014 plat. The Bontempo Property is immediately adjacent to Lot 251' Aplatamendmentcanonlybegrantedifitwillnot,,changethecharacterofthedevelopment,,or ,,alter the basic relationship of the development to adjacent p].o[""y'" Garfield.County Land Use Code' section4_106. rnthiscase,thepratAmendmentchangesthecharacteiofthedeveropmentbysubstantially altering the relailonship between Lot 250, the Bontempo Property, and Lot 251 and Lot 252' This change isimmediatelyevidentinExhibitA,thearchitecturaldrawingsandmovie. ThelotsonEagleClawCircleareapproximatelyonetenthofanacreeach.Reso|utionNo.2014- 1.4 changed the Club Villas Residential areawithin lronbridge, where the Bontempo Property, Lot 251, Lot 2s2, andLot 253, are located. No setbacks are required. Ex. B, Resolution 201'4ir4' No building envelopes are required. Ex. B, Resorution zot4-L4. Resorution No 2014-14further arows a maximum buirding height ofthirtyfive(35)feet.Ex.B,Resolution2OT4-t4.ThenegativeimpactsontheBontempoPropertyfrom 2 the prat Amendment wiil be compounded by the fact that there are no setbacks or building envelopes to provide a buffer. [:'j:".r. rot rine of Lot 251 is currently 80.94 feet, as shown on the 2014 Plat' Applicant seeks to expand the northern boundary of Lot 251 by 15.85 feet, or 19'58%' An expansion of almost 20%is significant, particularly on a lot of approximately one tenth of an acre with no building envelope' no required setbacks and a maximum buirding height of 35 feet. The southern boundary of Lot 251 is currently rocated entirery behind the Bontempo eropertly. Accordingry, a house buirt on the current Lot 251 will not interfere with the views from the Bontempo property or decrease the privacy on the Bontempo property' However, if the Plat Amendment is granted, the southern boundary of Lot 251 will move south L5'85 feet closer to, and in front of, the Bontempo Property. The Plat Amendment will compromise the view from theBontempoPropertyandtheprivacyoftheBontempoPropertyasshownontheattacheddrawingsand movie prepared by architect Jess Pederson. Ex. A, Architectural Drawings and ,,movie.,, The expansion of Lot 251wilr both change the character of the development and "arter the basic relationship" between Lot 251 and the BontemPo ProPertY' Lot 252 TheexpansionofLot252isalsosignificant.Applicantproposestoexpandthesouthernboundary of Lot 252 by armost 6.92 feet. As shown on ttre 2014 prat, the western boundary of Lot 252 is 80'19 feet' Applicantproposestoenlargethisboundarytothesouthto8T.l.lfeet'Again,thisexpansionwouldhave a detrimental impact on the Bontempo Property. Ex. A, Architectural Drawings and "movie'" lll. The Plat Amendment will Decrease the value of the Bontempo Property' The plat Amendment, if granted, will convert the Bontempo Property from a premium lot to a non- premium lot, thereby altering the character of the development and causing a diminution in value to the BontemPo ProPertY. christie Leonard, a real estate broker at Roaring Fork Properties who has 20 years of experience in real estate in the Roaring Fork valley, has concluded that the Plat Amendment' if granted' will have a negative impact on the value of the Bontempo Property. Ms' Leonard has sold properties within lronbridge and at other golf course communities throughout the Roaring Fork Valley' ln her extensive experience in realestate,buyersintheRoaringForkValley"valueprivacyandviews'"Ex'c'Affidavitofc'Leonard'fl4' lf granted, the Plat Amendment will decrease the view and privacy at the Bontempo Property' Ex' c' Affidavit of C. Leonard, tl6-9. lt is Christie Leonard's professional opinion that the Plat Amendment' if granted, will decrease the value of the Bontempo Property' Ex' C, Affidavit of c' Leonard' tl6-9' The Bontempo Property was appraised in 2015 by Kapaun & company before the proposed Plat Amendment.Theappraiser,GregoryKapaun,foundthattheviewfromtheBontempoProperty"hasa very good unobstructed view of Mount Sopris'; which is a "desirable amenity in this market"' Ex' D' Letter from Kapaun. He further stated that the unobstructed view of Mount sopris "was considered to be a significant factor" in the valuation of the Bontempo Property' lf the view from the Bontempo Property is comprised or obstructed, the value of the Bontempo Property will decrease' ( ,U-*- lV. Conclusion ThePlatAmendmentcannotbegrantedundertheGarfieldCountyLandUseCode.TheCodeis specificalry concerned about reconfigurations that alter the "character of the development" and "alter the basic relationship of the development to adjacent property." Garfield county Land Use' Section 4-106' The code and process are designed to protect ownersr incruding the Bontempor, IfoT significant changes that wourd adversery affect their prop"r,y. Granting the prat Amendment wi, significantly alter the character of the deveropment where the Bontempos purchased a home g years ago' The plat Amendment will substantially change the relationship between the Bontempo Property and Lot 251 and Lot 252' at a time when the Bontempos have already Juilt their house and can make no accommodation for these changes. Accordingly, the proposed Plat Amendment must be denied under code' The Bontempos respectfury request that the prat Amendment be denied in its entirety with respect to Lot 251 and Lol252' Weappreclateyourattentiontothismatter.Pleasefeelfreetocontactmewithanyquestions. ResPectf ullY submitted, !,J Enclosures: T.ExhibitA,Architecturaldrawingsandflashdrivewithmovie(withguide); 2. Exhibit B, Resolution No' 2014-14; 3. Exhibit C, Affidavit of Christie M' Leonard; and' 4. Exhibit D, Letter from Appraiser Gregory Kapaun' CC:Wendy and AnthonY BontemPo 4 Guide to Architectural "Movie: Second Description 0 Existing conditions: Bontempo Property, Lot 251, Lot 252, Lot 253, Lot 254 L-2 Conditions under 2014 Plat (brown buildings): Bontempo Property, Lot 251, Lol252, Lot 253, Lot 254 4-8 Conditions under Plat Amendment (blue buildings): Bontempo Property, Lot 251,, Lol252, Lot 253, Lot 254 9-12 Conditions under 2014 Plat (brown buildings): Bontempo Property, Lot 251, Lot252, Lot 253, Lot 254 13-18 Existing conditions: Bontempo Property, Lot 251-, Lot 252, Lot253, Lot254 19-21,Conditions under 2014 Plat (brown buildings): Bontempo Property, Lot 251, Lot252, Lot 253, Lot 254 22-24 Conditions under Plat Amendment (blue buildings): Bontempo Property, Lot 251, Lol252, Lot 253, Lot 254 2s-26 Existing conditions: Bontempo Property, Lot 251, Lot 252, Lot253, Lot254 EXISTING PLAT PROPOSED MASSING ON EXISTING PLAT nrr' i _ tl:"i1:::t_tt:a.. PROPOSED MASSING ON PROPOSED PLAT AMENDMENT EXISTING PLAT PROPOSED MASSING ON EXISTING PLAT PROPOSED MASSING ON PROPOSED PLAT AMENDMENT CtrENI Anthony & WendY BontemPo 4 Eagle Claw Circle Glenwood SPrings, Colorado 81601 OESCRIMON Sheet DescriPtion PRO]EO NO, < ProjectNumber> aolg I.B. Lot Lone Adj. Impact StudY ISSUE March25,2016 REIS5UE < RelssueDate> APIDERIIN TCHI':CTUtI EXISTiNG PLAT - view -'.r:,- PROPOSED MASSING ON EXISTING PLAT- view from lot 250 porch PROPOSED MASSING ON PROPOSED PLAT AMENDMENT- V|CW fTOM IOt 250 POTCT CUENT Anthony & WendY BontemPo 4 Eagle Claw Circle Glenwood Springs, Colorado I 1601 from lot 250 Porch l il L] Illl llltrlil! l|ifl,[t[H{,/]lJ'lll l,'lIItJI]iJ#i'll'$i, ll ll I ReceDtlonfl: 847515a1t?St2at4 lt l1 25 A{ J'a. nlbe-rcc i oi ls nec rep 30 O(i Ooc Fee 0 0o CARFIHLC CoUXTY Co STATEOFCOLORADO ) )ss County of Garfield ) At r regular meeting of the Board of county commissioners for Garfield county, Colorado, held in t5e Commi-isioners'Meeting Room, Garfield County Courthouse, in Glenwood Springs on, Monday, the 246 day of March A-D. 2014' there were present: John Martiu Commissioner Chairman Mike Samson , Commissioner Tom -lankovskv _, Commissioner Frank I lutfless Kellv Cave Assistant County Altonley Jean Alberico -.------, Clerk of the Board Andrew Gorsev , County Manager when thc following proceedings, among others wcre had and done, to-wil: R.ESOLUTION NO. ?O Iq - I'I AREsoLUTIoNoFAPPRoVAI,FoRANAMENDMENTToTtmIRoNBRIDGE PLANNEDT]NITDEVELoPMENTSETBACKSINTtm'CLUBVILLAzoNE DISTRICT TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THE SETBACKS INDICATED ON THE, FINAI, PLAT FOR IRONBRIDGE PHASE II' TILINGS I' 2 AND 3. Recitals A. The Board of Counry Cornrnissioners of Garfield County, Colorado, reccived a request for an amendlnent to the lronbridge Planned Unit Development to remove the setbacks in ttre CtuU Villa zone district to be consistent with the setbacks indicated on the konbridgc F'inal Plat Phase Il, Filings l,2 and 3. B. Ironbridge is a 533.5-acre propeny approved for a Planned Unit Developmetrt (PUD) consisting of 292 u-nits and +40o-acres of open space located on CR 109 between Westbank and Teller Spiings in Sections I & 12, Township 7 South, Range 89 West of r-tre 6th P.M', Carfietd County. The Board of County Commissioncrs approved and amendcd this devclopment in Resolutions 98-80, 99-067, 2OO4-?O,2004-26,2006-35. aDd 2ffi8-41. The developmenl was originally known as Rose Ranch. C. The Director of Community Development is audroriz-ed by the Board of County Conmissioners to approve, deny or approve with conditions a Minor Atrrendment to an approved pUD pursuant to tti Gurfi"t,l County 2013 Land Use and Dovelopment Code, as ameuded (LUDC)' , County Attomey ( f il lIJiI LiUj l-tiflf ,t Ullr i "'htl il #f ttl lr l ll$hi ll ll l $,",'r'J l,l iii 1 i"-'it :i""^:'; :"" A"36' 33n' I e L o co ut T Y c o 2 ol 15 R€c D.TheDirectorofColnmunityDeveloprnentissuedadecisionletteronMarchll'2014' conditionallyopp,oti"gth"'"qut'tundproviding,noticetotheBoardofCountyCommissioners (BOCC) as required ;;;;inft, -irrl socc ,lio nor request a call-up to a public hearing on the Director decision withirr the 10-day ,"ri.* p"riod, and as such, the Director decision is final' E'TheDirectorofCommunityDevelopnrenthasnradethefollowingdeterminationsof fact: 1. That propcr public notice was provided as rcquired for the Director decision' 2.Thereviewwasextensiveandcomplete,thatallpertinentfacts,mattersandissues were subrnitted with regard to the requesl' 3. That for the above stated and othcr reasons the proposed Amendlnent to thc tronurioge.pup i,-in,t,. u.,t int.,".i of the health, safety. convenience, order, prosperiiy and welfare of the citizens of Garfield County 4. The application has adequatcly met the requirernents t-rf the LUDC' RESOLI.]TION NowTIIIIREFORE,BEITREsoI,vBDbytheBoardofCountyCommissionersolGarfield CountY, Colorado' that: A. The forgoing Recitals are incorporated by this reference as part ofthe resolution' B.ThePUDAnrendnrenttochangethcsetbacksintheClubVillaZoneDistricttobe consistentwiththeFinalPlatishereby'pp,"'"aandthePUDGuideandPUDPlanis attached as Exhibits A and B' COMMISSIONER CIIAIR IOHN F' MARTIN ' Aye ffi 'nY"ffi 'av" r- Datedthis Zl - daYof- ATTES'I': thc Board UPon nrotion dulY made following votc: A.D. 1lt tly.rptlhr4 lti!\il]l,i rU ft\i't'rll trr Lltll t i] ll ll I s"".,.?i iaill l"I'?zli',.:" ;:""1t' tlp. t Er D cor il -v 40 APPllcablliW To carry out the purposes and provisions of the Garfield county Zoning Regulations' as amended' the lronbridgePlannedUnitDevelopment(PuD)zoneDistrictisdividedintothefollowingzonedistrict classifications: lntent: lndividual lot ownership with sintle family detached residentialstructures PermittedUses:Single-familyresidentialunits;withoneallowableaccessorydetachedhabitable structure consisting of one ueoroom, studio, or work shop toBether with one bathroom, and the grossfloorareaofwhichshall ^oiu*t"tOlOotq'ft'tobecalleda"casitaUnit" EachCasitashall be used and or occupied "r.tuiu"fy ty tn" owne4sl or the family members and guest(s) of the owner(s) of the subject lot. rne'casiil snarr not .ontuin any kitchen facilities and shall not be leased; non-habitable accessory Ur',o,.rt '"1 "iutt""'' home offices; sales/marketing center; public and private roads; Private Open spafe Easements; open space; utility and draina8e easements Minimum lot size: 0.70 acres River Residential 1 Zone District (PA's 3 & 8) River Residential 2 Zone Dlstrict (PA e) . 2O,O0o Square Foot (Minimum) Residential Zone District (PA's 2,4, & 15) 15,000 Square Foot (Minimum) Residential Zone District (PA's 1, 5, 10, 12,73,15, 17 & 18) 9,000 Square Foot (Minimum) Residential Zone District (PA's 6, 7, LL, 14, 79, 7rl| r Medium Density Residential Zone District (PA 19 & 22) o Club Villas Residential Zone District (PA 20) . Common OPen Space Zone District . Golf Course . Common OPen Space (General) 1. Zoning Oistrlcts River Residential 1 Zone Distrlct IRoNBRIDGE PUO - Sixth Amended and Restated pUD GUIDE Page 3 ol 11 !U+i,iJ,r*'ji1.,p. i$:lll:li,x *: :::::T' " " Maximum building height: 35' Minimum lot width: 175', except for lots which are narrower due to added depth MinimumlotdepthlTS,,exceptforlotswhicharemoreshallowduetoavailabledepthbetween road and wetland/boundary 30' from ordinary hiSh watermark Minimum Primary building setbacks: Front:40,forlotsthatareaminimumof20o,deep;30,forlotslessthan20o,deep Rear: 5o, for lots that are a minimum of 200, deep; 25, for lots less than 200, deep Side: 3d for lots 200' minimum width; 25' for lots less than 2oo' in width Parking:Aminimumof4offstreetparkin8spacesmustbeprovidedforeachprimaryresidential structure; this requirement may be satisfied by the garage and/or driveway' Density: 21 Units Other:Buildingenvelopesvaryingfromtheabovedescribedsetbacksmaybefinali?edatthetime of the final subdivision platting. 2. River Residential 2 zone oistrict lntent: lndividual lot ownership with single family detached residential structures' Permitted Uses: Single.family residential units; with one allowable accessory detached habitable structureconsistingofonebedroom,studio,orworkshoptogetherwithonebathroom'andthe gross floor area of which shall not exceed 3oo sq. ft., to be called a "casita unit". Each casita shall be ised and or occupied exclusively by the owner(s) or the family members and guest(s) of the owner(s) of the subject lot. the casita shall not contain any kitchen facilities and shall not be leased; non-habitable acceisory buildings and structures; home offices; sales/marketing center; public and private roads; Private Open Space Easements; open space; utility and drainage easements' Minimum lot size: 0.50 acres Maximum building heiSht: 35' Minimum lot width: 100' MinimumlotdepthlT5,,exceptforlotswhicharemoreshallowduetoavailab|edepthbetween road and wetland/boundary 30 from ordinary high watermark Minimum primary building setbacks: Front: 35, for lots that are a minlmum of 175, deep; 25, for lots less than 175, deep Rear:50'forlotsthatareaminimumoflT5'deep;25'forlotslessthanlTS'deep Side: 30'for lots 150' minimum width; 20' for lots less than 150' in width Parking:Aminimumof4offstreetparkingspacesmustbeprovidedforeachprimaryresidential structure; this requirement may be satisfied by the 8ara8e and/or driveway. IRONBRIDGE PUD - Sixth Amended and Restated PUD GUIDE PaSe 4 of 11 llll llfrtir,Elld.lll\llillii! liilht l'Jflhrr l'rllt"'i' ll ll l El,,'lidilll": ,a':3",.:"i:.^4"3i'33R! IE, D co"N'/ co Density: 17 Units other:Buildingenvelopesvaryingfromtheabovedescribedsetbacksmaybefinalizedatthetime of the final subdivision Platting' 3. 20,0il) Square Foot Resldential Zone Distrld lntent: lndividual lot ownership with single family detached residential structures' PermittedUses:sinBle-familyresidentialunits;withoneallowableaccessorydetachedhabitable structure consisting or one ueoroo., studio, or work shop tog€ther with one bathroom, and the gross floor area of which shall t;;;-;; 300 sq' ft'' to be called a "casita Unit"' Each Casita shall be used and or occupied ",.ru'i'"iv tv tr"'" o*ne(i) or the family members and Euest(s) of the owner(s) of the subiect lot. fn"'.irit. snatt noi .rnt.in any kitchen facilities and shall not be leased; non-habitabte accessory buldiigr;;i ,,r;our"r; home o*ices; sales/marketing center; public and private roads; Private Open Spale E"sements; open space; utility and drainage easements' Minimum lot size: 20,0O0 square feet Maximum building height: 35' Minimum lot width: 80', measured at front building line Minimum lot depth: 150' Minimum Primary building setbacks: Front: 30' Rear: 20' Side: 10' Parking: Aminimumof4offstreetparkingspacesmustbeprovidedforeachprimaryresidential structure; this requirement may be satisfied by the garaBe and/or driveway' Densityl 27 Units Other: Building envelopes shall be finalized at time of subdivision' 4' 15'OO0 Square Foot zone District lntent: lndividual lot ownership wlth single family detached residential structures' PermittedUses:Single-familyresidentialunits;withoneallowableaccessorydetachedhabitable structure consisting of one ueuroom, stuaio, or work shop together with one b1tlro?ml all the gross floor area ot *t ict strattlriierceeU aOO sq. ft., to be cailed a "Casita Unit". Each Casita shall be used and or occupied .*r"i'"iv Lv tt" o*ne(i) or the family members and guest(s)'of the owne(s) of the subject lot. ir,"'.lriiu ,t.rr not contain any kitchen facilities and shall not be leased; non-habitable a.c"r*ry uuitoiig*^i tt"ti"*'; t''o'u o*itut' sales/marketing center; public and ;;;;;;;;;t, Private open spaie Easements; open space; utilitv and drainase easements' IRONBRIOGE PUD - sixth Amended and Restated PU0 GUIDE Page 5 of 11 ?u+H#*$i{{:$:.'.:}:'Il *::T:::i:''',' Minimum lot size: 15,OOO square feet Minimum lot width: 80', measured at front building line Minimum lot depth: 120' Maximum building height: 35' Minimum Primary building setbacks: Front: 30' Rear: 20' Side: 10' Parking: A minimum of 4 off street parking spaces must be provided for each primary residential structure; this requirement may be satisfied by the garaEe and/or driveway' Density: 70 Units Other: BuildinB envelopes shall be finalized at time of subdivision' 5' 9'000 Square Foot Zone District lntent:lndividuallotownershipwithsinglefamilYdetachedresidentialstructuresandAffordable For-Sale Residential Dwelling Units' PermittedUses:single-familyresidentialunits;deedre5trictedsinglefamilyresidentialunits complying with thu."qri'.tll"ni' oiiht c"fi"ia to'nty Affordable HousinB Regulations and Guidelines. (sections 4.07.15.0ir"a q.10, Garfield county_zoning Resolution of 1978, as amended); non-habitable accessory buitdin'g"s.].jr,ir.*r"r, home office; siles/marketing center; public and private roads; open spacei utility and drainage easements' Minimum lot size: 9,OOO square feet Minimum lot width: 175', measured at front buildinB line Minimum lot depth: 90' Maximum buildinE heiSht: 35' Minimum prlmary buildinB setbacks: Front: 25' Rear: 20' Side: 10' For lots in Planning Area 19: Front: 10' Rear: 20' Rear: 10' IRONBRIDGE PUD - Sixth Amended and Restated PUD GUIDE Page 6 of 11 i$+i#iliii$i#':,',:l'll[:ll:]l','j jlli:'"" Parking: A minimum of 2 off street parking spaces must be provided for each primary residential structJre; this requirement may be satisfied by the tara8e and/or drivewaY' Density: 36 Units Other: Building envelopes shall be finalized at time of subdivision' 5' Medium DensitY zone Dlstrlct lntent:lndividuallotandunitownershipwithsinglefamiIy/mu|ti-familyresidentialstructuresand Affordable For-Sale Residential Dwelling Units' Permitted uses: Single-familyresidentialunitswithoneallowableaccessorydetachedhabitablestructureconsisting of one bedroom, stroio, o, *oit sniplogether with one bathroom, and the gross floor area of which shall not exceed goo sq' i', i"iu;'lled a "Casita Unit"' Each Casita shall be used and or occupied exclusivety fy tne ownerG) or the family members and guest(s) of the owner(s) of the subject lot. casita units are noi riro*"d ,n pl zz. rtra casita shall not contain any kitchen facilities and shall not be leased' Multl.familyresidentialunits;deedrestrictedsinSlefamilyresidentialunitscomplyinSwiththe requirements of tne carnefO Couniy lftordabte Housing Regulations and Guidelines' (Sections 4.07.15.01 and 4.14, Garfield co-'niy zoning Resolution of 1978' as amended); attached and l detached non_habitable acc"riorV OuifOingi and structures; home office; sales/marketing center; time share orlractional ownership units; iublic and private roads; open space; utility and drainage easements. Minimum lot size: 4,OOo square feet for detached units; no minimum lot size for attached units - common ownership of open areas including parking areas with in this zone is permitted' Minimutn lot width (detached): 35', measured at front building line Minimum lot dePth (detached): 50' Maximum building height: 35' Minimum setbacks from lot lines: For PlanninB Area 19: Single FamilY Front: 10' Rear: 15' side:5' Multi-FamilY Front: 10'from street Rear: 15' Side: 0, with 10, minimum between primary structures, excluding attached units IRONBRIDGE PUD - Sixth Amended and Restated PUD GUIDE Page 7 of 11 Illl li,rrJfiUf,ftltilillll U,{ltrtldrililllltltr,l'rrltl + ll ll I p.."ogie6p; 847515 ??'3?'?3'$":'.I iB 3[ .i:"i":'B'66'3nt':rto ;o "trr co For Planning Area 22: Single Family Front: 20' Rear: 15' Side: 5' Multl-Family Front: 15'from street Rear; 15' Side: 0' with 10' minimum between primary structures, excluding attached units Parking: A minimum of 2 off street parking spaces must be provided for each primary structure; this requirement may be satisfied by the garage, driveway, on-street parking and/or common parking area. other: Building envelopes shall be finalized at time of subdivision. Density: . Planning Arca 72: twenty (20) units Planning Area 19: seventy-eight (78) units 7. Club Villas Zone Dlstrict lntent: hdividual lot and unit ownership with single family residentialstructures and Affordable7 For-sale Residential Dwelling Units. permitted Uses: Single-family residential units attached or detached; deed restricted single family residential units complying with the requirements of the Garfield County Affordable Housing Regulations and Guidelines. (Sections 4.07.15.01 and 4-14, Garfietd County Zoning Resolution of 1978, as amended); non-habitabte accessory buildings and structures; home offices; sales/marketinB centec time share or fractional ownership units; public and private roads; open space; trails; utility and drainage easements Minimum lot size; 4,000 square feet for detached units; no minimum lot size for attached unats - common ownership of open areas with in this zone is permitted Maximum Gross Density: 8 dwelling units/acre Minimum Gross Denslty: 4,0 dwelling units/acre Maximum building height: 35' Minimum lot width: no minimum lot width for detached or attached units Minimum lot depth: no minimum lot depth for detached or attached units tRoNBRIDG€ PUO - Sixth Amended and Restated PUD GUIOE Page 8 of 11 lill lL,ltlttilHltllft,iiiJIlIFilllltliltrih'lrhl' ll ll I RecGDt.io^S:847515 ?i'3?'?3'1":'':; 13 3l,i:'L?'B'!6'f,o*,'o io,,Nry co Minimum Primary building setbacks: Front: N/A Rear: N/A Side: N/A Parking: A minimum of 2 parking spaces must be provided for each primary structure; this requirement may be satisfied ny"the garage' driveway' on-street parking and/or common parking area. Density: 47 Units Other: No Building Envelopes are required' Lots 259 and 286 are exempt from the minimum lot square footaBe requirements' 8' Common OPen SPace Zone Distrlct lntent: To provide a hierarchy of privately owned open space' both developed and undeveloped' a. GolfCourse lntent: To provide an opportunity for recreational golf' PermittedUses:Recreationalsolfcourse;golfclubhouse-facilitiesincludingbutnotlimitedtopro shop, restaurant; tounge; aririig range; go-lf related activities; golf shelters; golf course maintenance and accessory faciilties; tennis; iwimiiirL poot; volley ball; health/fitness center; utilities; utilities access Maximumstructureheight:3S,restrictedtogolfcourseclubhouseandhealth/fitnesscenter [rifJi"g, other structur;s limited to maximum height of 25' MaximumstructureheiEht(utilities):3S,,restrictedtowaterstoragetank;otherstructureslimited to maximum heiSht of 25' Minimum building setbacks: To CountY Road 109: 30' To any adjacent residential use: 20' other: Golf course acreage will be finalized during plattinB; golf course may be parcelized/platted for ownershiP PurPoses b' Common OP€n SPace (General) lntent: To provide open areas for recreation' visual relief; buffering and wildlife habitat Permitted Uses: Useable open space, limited open space; community gardens; parking;'trails; pedestrian linkages; golf car p"tfi ponat' overiooks; drainaBe and utility easements; utilities; utilities access; Public fishin8 easement IRONBRIDGE PUO - Sixth Anrended and Restated PL''D GUIDE Page 9 of 11 llll ffi|Jlttt[fl mlrl$l'l'llUl,rl*lf lllrtllltl{'ltrlil ll ll I Receptjonn 847515dr/25/2014 tr ,1 25 Ai J.an clh..rcoli oi 15 Rec F!. $0.00 ooc Fee 0 00 6AFFIEL0 CorIlIY aO lronbrldge Planning Area Breakout 2ltzl2OL4 tla*^t ^;PA-1 1to6 riooo sq+t. tuin) Residential PA-2 7to15 ZO"OOO Sq*t. lt"tin) Residential PA.3 16 to 28 River Residential 1 PA-4 43 to 50 20,000 Sq. Ft. (Man) PA.5 51 to 58 15,000 5q. Ft. (Min) Residential PA.6 29 lo 42 9,000 5q. Ft. (Mrn) PA.7 62,71 to 79 SP00 Srt. Ft. (Min) Residential PA-8 63 to 70 River Residential PA-9 80 to 96 River Residential 2 PA-10 97 to 100 15,000 Sq. Ft. (Min) Residential PA-11 101 to 105, 770,771 9,000 Sq. Ft. (Min) Residential PA.12 106 to 111 15POo Sq, Ft. (M,n) Residential P4.13 150 to 165 15,000 Sq. Ft. (Min) Residential PA-14 112 to 113 g,Ooo Sq. Ft. (Min) Residential PA-15 114 to 124 ZOPOO sq. rt- lwtin) Residential PA-16 125 to 132 15,0@ sq. Ft. [Mrn) PA-I7 133 to 149 15,000 Sq. Ft. (Min) Residentral PA-18 166 to 169 f SPOO Sq. ftLmin) Residential PA-19 772 to 249 9^0OO Sq. Ft. (Min) Residential Medium DensitY Resl!!!!igl PA-20 250 to 295 club Villas Residential PA-21.59 to 61 9,000 Sq. Ft. (M.n) PA-22 297 to 316 IRoNBRIDGE PUD - Sixth Amended and Restated PUo GUI0E PaSe 11 of 11 --- M;aium Density Resldentlal li:*itHT r+:*:l,lllT:',.i:: :: :::'.:'.,' HOSE RANCH Planned Unit DeveloPment a---@>{}5;-- cwmc *u L AFFTDAVIT OF CHRISTIE M. LEONARD STATE OF COLORADO COUNTY OF GARFIELD ) ) ss. ) I, Christie M. Leonard, being first duly swom on oath states as follows: I . I am over the age of 2 I and a resident of Garfield County, Colorado. 2. I am a licensed real estate broker in the State of Colorado. I currently work for Roaring Fork Realty, 1370 Main Street, Carbondale, Colorado. 3. I have been a licensed real estate broker in the Roaring Fork Valley for 20 years. During that time, I have worked as a real estate broker for homes in Ironbridge and other golf course communities such as WestBank, Aspen Glen and River Valley Ranch. I am familiar with residential real estate values in Ironbridge and in the Roaring Fork Valley. 4. In my professional experience as a real estate broker with 20 years of experience, buyers in the Roaring Fork Valley value privacy and views. 5. I have visited the property owned by Wendy and Anthony Bontempo, located at 4 Eagle Claw Circle, Glenwood Springs, Colorado ("Bontempo Property"). 6. The Bontempo's single story house is located on a comer lot, Lot 250, and currently has an unobstructed view of Mount Sopris from both the porch and the master bedroom. The Bontempo porch is also private due to the present location of Lot 251 and Lot252. These features make the Bontempo Property a "premium" lot. 7. I have walked the Bontempo property, and the adjacent lots, Lot 251 and Lot252. I have also reviewed an appraisal of the Bontempo property prepared in 2015, the drawings prepared by architect Jess Pederson, and the proposed plat amendment. Soorz"--,/H^ # NOTARY PUBLIC - State of Colorado g. It is my professional opinion that the proposed plat amendment, which would bring Lot25l approximately 16 feet closer to the Bontempo property, will be problematic to the value of the Bontempo Property. Lot252would move approximately 7 feet to the south' On lots this size, which are approximately one tenth of an acre, 16 feet has a significant impact on privacy and views. The proposed plat amendment, if approved, will compromise the privacy and views of the Bontempo Property. If the plat for Lot 251 and Lot 252 is amended as proposed, the Bontempo Property will likely no longer be a "premium" lot' g. It is my professional opinion that the value of the Bontempo Property will decrease if the plat is amended and Lot 251 artdLot}52 are expanded as proposed' FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT. ,ii Christie M. Leonard Subscribed and sworn to before me this &5Auy of March 2016. sEAil l{otary Pubtic StatG o, Cotorado rD 20154044943 17 KAPAUN & COMPANY REAL ESTATE APPRAISAL SERVICES P.O. BOX 1945 GLENWOOD SPRINGS, CO 81602 Phone: (970) 945-1063 Email: kaPaun@soPris.net March 22,2016 Community DeveloPment Director Garfield County 108 8th Street, Suite 401 Glenwood Springs, CO 81601 RE: 4 Eagle Claw Circle Glenwood SPrings, CO 81601 I appraised the above-identified property on April 6, 2015. The subject property has a verf good unobstructed view of Mount Sopris. An unobstructed Mount Sopris view is considered to be a desirable amenity in this market, and therefore, this property attribute was considered to be a significant factor in the valuation of this property. Sincerely, Gregory W. Kapaun CertitieO Residential Appraiser , #1313494, State of Colorado To: From: Subject: Date: Rodney, Upon review of the Amended Plat of Lots 251-254, Block 3, Phase 2, Ironbridge PUD, I have no comments or corrections to be made prior to approval for survey content and form' Once all final comments from Community Development have been completed, the Mylar may be prepared for recording. The Mylar shall be delivered to the community Development office with all private party signatures no later than Monday the week prior to the next commissioner meeting day in order to make that meeting' Sincerely, Scott Aibner Garfield County SurveYor cc David Pesnichak- Community Development Department ilriletr ? Gurlield CountY SURVEYOR SCOTT AIBNER, P.L.S Rodney Kiser - High Country Engineering Scott Aibner - Garfield County Surveyor Plat Review - Amended Plat of Lots 251-254, Blk 3, Ph 2 Ironbridge PUD 0312912016 109 g th Street ,Suite l00B . Glenwood Springs, C081601 , (970)945-1377 , Fax: (970)384-3460' e-mail:saibner@garfield'countycom d 1oc E =r$!l:5! - IHeEa = i9E ZfIF;U [i I8l ] ! rii Il;Eso -dgo01tII AMENDED PLAT OF LOTS 25I THROUGH BLOCK 3, PHASE II, DEVELOPEMENT SECTION I , TOWNSHIP 7 SOUTH, RANGE A9 WEST OF THE 6TH P,M. COUNW OF GARFIELD, STATE OF COLORADO PUT NOTES ,)E ^@16FEaDr t E .tu^rre 8lqsE *u * u r) Rd b ar ev^Ic 4 J .) l@ ruE^rrudtu ..)^T*RfEB.(@$cffi ]*MrYu4ffis/reeE ..)uma0ffirNdftD{AE.,/lE-E r!) ro lB ffil aH& ils@{r6 -r l) e s0 *l6;ffirgs#;.,Jf;;H#.ffi;'ffi[r#*rm* ffimffiffi SHEfrI . NOES, UNDUSE, SHEF2. OWERSCEMHSIES SHffi 3 . PHEEI,BLOCK3.HLING COMMON ARil Eil{turGeqlcFlNn,EPi)e(drcffin,B@rLoE4a, Ee, do N 4) RIq&D E VICINITY MAP @ couw SuRv*oR,s cERnncaE SURVEYOR'S NOTES: '.).saM6mqseR ,,oqr'{-E'tam (d@E 2r, 2ra 4 a @ ao #) ao .6 r r 'l€r (lE'r ru!ffi!&il$|id&'qi$fr.d,L_E,ffiJl"t* rucEmHcaE i)B*"nEffibffi^'*ffi**E* llg**,HtffigffiruH.H,ffiT-Hx" lf"trJ'ffits$l,S*****"-*.,r€*ffi'lli,g,'#3ffiy"H,:'3.?- ()*ffifffiffiu'68 E&-J,^it"ffiHq*.,il1i-itg--Hjggtffin coufficottrssroNER'scEmnilE q&,tsiEg,tr4@tx"niffi*lqE?ry'E*f: - fi"AflFt!?&tF&11f-*:]:,-'lj.i&H""eEiitrui..t@rE* & fffiHlil,'3'"HrEsre,ffi#"Y".""-tr^F#b#ffi.H$;ffiflry***.ffiffih trH#rx#,;,""xf,.}(rcrm&4&em lz)48(a*6il."* ffi"":-ffi.H'g!B$9*.T^g.g,#q-sJ,rffi#"##.: ADE&ENNf,PUT*8624*E r Gt@r @E 2r, 271 24 .4 'F M d) aD &M J c ilE dhr.{futun(reNEffiffie*dils imcr @ .) u oar E1 .doms N ir'rdk tu 6&ffi IfIUMBDfrNE@ ^5 Em b. a5s s ffi amnE SURWOR'SCERIHdE AMENDED PLAT OF LOTS 25I THROUGH 254, BLOCK 3, PHASE II, sEcrroN'"1?Y#3'IJ"?,YJI;H?E:?::iL.FrHE6rHPM' rrx**dr)^E*tud{ n^r4 fi8NEfufu CEMECAE OF DDICAION OMERSHIP (LOT 5I ND LOTSA 6cg2f rc(('r@')€el6 rd lwr. rt,@ 6rh 2e E notu z.r CEMIHAE OF DEDICAION OMERSHIP {LfrE) 1('xa16a, Ntrdr@tutudo gfv r- bq.Y. um ffi G a ffi[ 6 d sffi6.Er'ili-i@ :mNB(rrE*tu 6& .6rc1(ItrEF$B 6tr. rN R cillrudp .n M sdd me dn .Y rE ffils) uPe ru ar rim @'*nlr mhofte.st€EYg,m und,DEsrm.s)qE@ ) t, =E$E;s{ H rii:Z!U8U EiEIe fi!EBU a !E{; r igE II6qso'dgo01iII 9qr ltq lBj i8;\ !xiE oClts iucE EI:H fI? i II l.l I EIuIi { ( c olIE PF PZ 50 64 uCr] e B u0rEO EI @E ;ENO:E K-ots 9 2111@2 20F3 SECTION I , TOWNSHIP 7 SOUTH, RANGE 89 WEST OF THE 5TH P.M. AMENDED PLAT OF LOTS 25I THROUGH 254, BLOCK NED UNIT D COUNTY OF GARFIELD, STATE OF COLORADO LOT270 qo "h,*,a ,\8\ .B\e\ Etr?\ ';nq\A t\y I "\ %'\ GRAPHIC SCff#(sE) LEGEND @,oiffiMs *"?* r _".,&, /-+$6 vo' d zoaz_i E;:l _ EEqgE9;gi I6lfrU ir I8S !F *0! iz;tR if ;Ego'd9oE1tI ! CeD LOT 252 4,0231 S.F. 0.092t AC. @ LOT 253 4. t93i S.F. 0.096r Ac. @ LOT 254 4,2891 S.F. 0.099t AC. P9F !tr 5;6 +q3'- xiE EIE 9tq C:H 'iE 2lai@? 30F3 Oso@@@@xr";rE@. I e ! I I Ia E8 !iEBCIEI i 't i i q3! ii;iix;i- t usEEfrr"h a' I n"" q* itq E EE I E iIiiE: iIitl! tl3!i!riitl !a:3t l!l;i !gtr; i:rir ^& ..*$b" ,/r$tr {*'Y,Y FIx Ul{zooozU {6z UT rflX J E { Tlov Fo{a Ng IN UIE =FIzUm E'Tt- { .8,. f-oftu d .#"r.oa IU Olki t Bt6^ ei\, *frdc, :; :-:5 ^Ets{/E]ixHt EiQa XEfrH" =('\ utle cil P E:l :to! D6 111o-D-1I9:r+9. --.-, A 1€OO922.t 9A7;;#;"ffi --=ffiips*"* '[u I' "'lr '',.,,1 L I tgs!9scgs !t*iiiiiii t ;ir!E'5!iE EXHIBlT U A6REEMENT THIS AGREEMENT (the "Agreement") ls entered lnto as of the Effective Date set forth below by the following parties: Wendy Bontempo and Anthony Bontempo (collectlvely "Bontempo") BH Holdings, LLC, a Colorado llmited liability company ("BH Holdings") Each of the foregolng ls a "Party'' to the Agreement, and collectlvely they constltute the "Partles" to the Agreement. RECITATS A. On February 16, 2016, BH Holdings filed a Flnal Plat Amendment Application lronbridge Phase ll, Flling 1, 2, 3, - Lots 251to 254 ("Appllcatlon"). B. BH Holdlngs is the owner of Lot 251, Lot 252, and Lot 253, as shown on the Amended Final Plat of Block 2 of Phase ll, recorded on July 22,20L4, Receptlon No. 851641 ("20L4 Plal"l. C. The Bontempos own 4 Eagle Claw Clrcle, Glenwood Sprlngs, Colorado, Lot 250, as shown on the 2014 Plat. D. On March 28,2}L6,the Bontempos opposed the Appllcation. E. By this Agreement, the Partles deslre to resolve the Bontempo's opposltlon to the Applicatlon. TI{E PARTIES AGREE AS FOTLOWS: t. Recltals. All recltals to thls Agreement 8re $ue and correct, and form a part of thls Agreement. 2. Consideratton. The Parties acknowledge that thls Agreement ls based upon the exchange of good and valuable consideration as set forth more fully herein, the adequacy or sufflclency of whlch ls hereby acknowledged. 3. Plat Amendment. The Parties agree to the proposed Plat Amendment attached hereto as Exhlblt A, and hereby lncorporated lnto thls Agreement. The Partles agree that BH Holdlngs may amend the 2014 Plat to move the southern boundary of tot 251 south from the current locatlon on the 2014 plat by no more than 3.49 feet, as shown on Exhlbit A. The Parties agree that BH Holdings may amend the 2014 Plat to move the southern boundary of Lot 252 from the current location on the 2014 Plat by no more than 1.71 feet, as shown on Exhlblt A. The Parties agree to the other amendments to the 2014 Plat as shown on Exhlblt A, 4. Withdrawal of Opposltlon. Upon the executlon of thls Agreement, the Bontempos shall wlthdraw their opposltlon to the Application. 5.Entire Agreement. This Agreement constitutes the entire Agreement between the parties and may only be modified ln writing signed by the Parties. Governlng taw. This Agreement shall be governed by the law of the State of Colorado and the jurlsdiction and venue to resolve any dispute regarding thls Agreement shall be ln the courts of Garfield County, Colorado. Counterparts and Signlng. Thls Agreement may be executed ln multiple counterparts, each of which shall be deemed an origlnal, but all of which, together, shall constitute one and the same instrument. This Agreement may be executed by facsimile slgnature or e-mall, which shall have binding effect. Coples of origlnal execution pages of thls Agreement shall have the same force and effect as the originals themselves. Representations, Warranties, and Covenants. The Parties represent, warrant and covenant that they have taken all necessary action to authorize the executlon, delivery, and performance of this Agreement and have the authority to execute, deliver and perform this Agreement and all the transactions contemplated hereby. 9. Effective Date. The Effective Date of this Agreement shall be the date that the last Party hereto executes this Agreement. 10. Bindlng Effect. This Agreement is binding upon and inures to the benefit of the Parties and their respective officers, directors, successors, helrs, trustees, receivers, partners, and agents. 11. Severablllty. lf any provision or any part of any provision of this Agreement shall, for any reason, be held to be invalid, unenforceable or contrary to public policy or any law, then the remainder of this Agreement shall not be affected thereby and shall remaln in full force and effect. 12. Construction. This Agreement is the result of negotiations between the Parties, who are represented by counsel. Thls Agreement was lnitially drafted by counsel for Bontempo as a matter of convenlence only, and shall not be construed for or agalnst any Party on account thereof, but shall be construed according to lts plain meaning. Paragraph headings in the Agreement appear for the convenlence of the Parties only, and shall not be used ln the interpretation of the Agreement. Where context requlres, the singular includes the plural (and vice versa), the dlsJunctive includes the conJunctlve (and vice versa), and the masculine, femlnine, and indetermlnate gender pronouns are lnclusive rather than exclusive. Agreed to by: 7. 8. slstlto Date zf ztlru Date 2 r EXISTING PLAT PROPOSED MASSING ON EXISTING PLAT PROPOSED MASSING ON PROPOSED PLAT AMENDMENT DRAWNBY:r' |?EllT.[?*rmber> &t$iff$srffitnsh l l'i61ffi,qs,eaau;' lFrnnprttg-Hddv ' nn lJ l{Hlr f.l lJ NHg! L..r. I March25, 2016 il*[1[,-m8", I EDERSEN I.IITECTUR,E EXISTING PLAT PROPOSED MASSING ON EXISTING PLAT PROPOSED MASSING ON PROPOSED PLAT AMENDMENT DRAWN BY:J. P. DESCRIPTION Sheet Description PROJECT NO. <ProjectNumber> PROJECT I.B. Lot Lone Adj. Impact Study ISSUE March25, 2016 RE.ISSUE <ReIssueDate> CLIENT Anthony & Wendy Bontempo 4 Eagle Claw Circle Glenwood Springs, Colorado 81601 APEDERSEN ARCH!TECTURE EXISTING PLAT - view from lot 250 porch PROPOSED MASSING ON EXISTING PLAT. view frOM IOt 250 POrCh PROPOSED MASSING ON PROPOSED PLAT AMENDMENT- view from lot 250 porch PRO]ECT NO. <ProjectNumber> PROJECT I.B. Lot Lone Adj. Impact Study ISSUE March25,2016 RE-ISSUE <ReIssueDate> CLIENT Anthony & Wendy Bontempo 4 Eagle Claw Circle Glenwood Springs, Colorado 81601 Sheet Description APEDERSEN ARCHITECTURE