Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
4.0 DD Staff Report 08.09.2017
Elder Minor Subdivision - Exhibits Administrative Review (File MISA-05-17-8535) Applicant is Jarad Elder August 9, 2017 Exhibit Number Exhibit Description 1 Public Hearing Notice Information Form 2 Receipts from Mailing Notice 3 Referral Comments from Chris Hale, Mountain Cross Engineering, Dated July 28, 2017. 4 Referral Comments from Dan Goin, Road and Bridge, Dated July 18, 2017. 5 Referral Comments from Levi Atwater, Department of Natural Resources, Dated July 10, 2017. 6 Referral Comments from Jill Carlson, Colorado Geological Survey, Dated August 1, 2017. 7 Referral Comments from Orrin Moon, Colorado River Fire Rescue, Dated July 31, 2017. 8 Referral Comments from Megan Sullivan, Division of Water Resources, Dated July 31, 2017. 9 Referral Comments from Morgan Hill, Garfield County Public Health, Dated August 1, 2017. 10 Referral Comments from Steve Anthony, Garfield County Vegetation Management, Dated July 31, 2017. 11 Referral Comments from Scott Aibner, Garfield County Surveyor, Dated July 31, 2017 12 Referral Comments from Kelly Cave, Assistant Garfield County Attorney, Dated July 27, 2017 13 Public Comment from Lois Martinez, Dated July 26, 2017 14 Garfield County Land Use and Development Code of 2013, as Amended 15 Garfield County Comprehensive Plan 2030, as Amended 16 Application 17 Staff Report Elder Minor Subdivison MISA-05-17-8535 August 9, 2017 PROJECT INFORMATION AND STAFF COMMENTS TYPE OF REVIEW Administrative Review — Minor Subdivision APPLICANT (OWNER) Jarad Elder REPRESENTATIVE Misty Briscoe -Garcia LOCATION The property is located at the intersection of County Roads 331 and 326, approximately, 3.3 miles south of the Town of Silt REQUEST WATER/SANITATION ZONING Subdivision creating two parcels of approximately 2 acres and 3 acres Onsite Wastewater Treatment Systems and a shared well. Rural COMPREHENSIVE PLAN Open Space / Public Land I. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSAL An Administrative application was submitted for a Minor Subdivision with a request to subdivide an existing 5 acre parcel owned by Jarad Elder, into two parcels. The Applicant's request is to create one new approximately 2.001 acre parcel from the existing 5 acres which is located at the intersection of County Roads 331 and 326.The proposed parcel B, currently has a permitted ADU on the property as well as a permitted pole garage. Parcel A has a residence and a permitted accessory garage. The parcel was originally created as part of the Mattingley Exemption, with the 5 acre parcel being split from a 63.9 acre parcel. The applicant has proposed that the two lots share the existing well. Wastewater is to be served by existing, permitted, Onsite Wastewater Treatment Systems. II. DESCRIPTION OF THE SITE The 5 acre parcel is at the intersection of County Road 331 and 326. The ADU on the north east portion of the property accesses onto County Road 326 and the other residence has a separate access onto CR 331. The site is split by a depression where the augmentation pond and an intermittent drainage channel are located. The site is well -vegetated and has multiple deciduous trees located on the property. The existing structures are built on the higher portions of the property. Aerial Photo Augmentation Pond ADU [Main Residence 2 ta111 kAm Ci $J nII i} ep 111 0 AI p1v 1 o Mm ox EP Site Plan County Road No. 331 III. WAIVER REQUESTS FROM STANDARDS The Applicant has not requested any waivers from the applicable Standards. IV. AUTHORITY — APPLICABLE REGULATIONS 3 A. Section 5-301 of the Land Use and Development Code (LUDC), designates the division of land that creates no more than 3 parcels, is served by a private well or water supply entity and does not require the extension, construction, or improvement of a County right-of-way, as requiring Administrative Review. B. Section 4-103 of the LUDC sets forth the Administrative Review Procedures by which the current Application is being considered. C. Article 7 of the LUDC sets forth General approval standards in Division 1, General Resource Protection Standards in Division 2 and Site Planning and Development Standards in Division 3. Minor Subdivisions are also subject to standards in Article 7 Division 4, Subdivision Standards and Design Specifications, Section 5- 301(C) and 5-402(F). The standards are addressed in the Application submittals and in the Staff Analysis section of the Staff Report. V. PUBLIC AND REFERRAL COMMENTS The Applicant has provided documentation that all required notice mailings have been completed in accordance with the LUDC. One public comment was received as a result of the public notice. It is attached as an exhibit and summarized below. Referral Comments received on the Application are attached as Exhibits and summarized below: A. Garfield County Consulting Engineer, Mountain Cross Engineering (See Exhibit 3): The following comments were submitted. • "The Applicant states that drainage requirements are not applicable since the structures are constructed and existing. However, the Applicant should verify that there is positive drainage away from the structures, that there are no areas of shallow ponding, and that existing drainage patterns are not causing erosion or sedimentation problems." • "The Applicant provides pump tests results from the well from over 15 years ago. Adjacent land uses, additional wells, drought, or other impacts can affect the production of a well over time. The Applicant should provide results of a recent pump test." • "The Applicant provided water quality testing results that appear to show that E. Coli was detected. The Applicant should verify the results and provide proposed method of treatment or test results showing the absence of E. Coli." B. Garfield County Road and Bridge (See Exhibit 4): The following comments were submitted. • "Patrick we have review the application for the Elder Subdivision both of the driveways have aprons and are up to code." C. Colorado Parks and Wildlife (See Exhibit 5): The following comments were submitted. 4 • "After reviewing this proposal I find no significant wildlife concerns regarding this subdivision." D. Colorado Geological Survey (CGS) (See Exhibit 6): The following comments were submitted. • "No new construction or improvements are currently proposed. We visited the site on August 1, 2017. We did not observe any surface conditions that would preclude the existing and proposed residential use and density. CGS therefore has no objection to approval of the two -lot subdivision as proposed." • "Rockfall. The existing ADU on proposed Parcel B is located below a small slope containing detached blocks of Wasatch Formation (claystone, siltstone, sandstone, and minor conglomerate). The blocks appear to be stable under current conditions. Future improvements should be located and constructed such that any grading, driveway, foundation, or other cuts do not undercut the slope or otherwise remove any existing material supporting these blocks." • "Erosion setback from unnamed drainage channel. An unnamed, intermittent drainage channel crosses the site from east to west. No flood hazard has been mapped for this drainage. CGS recommends an erosion setback for any future improvements on both proposed lots, to reduce hazards associated not just with rising floodwaters but also erosion and scour. The setback should be determined based on site-specific analysis of topography and soil erosion properties." E. Colorado River Fire Rescue (See Exhibit 7):The following comments were submitted. • "I have no requirements or concerns with this lot split on the existing property including building and residences. This lot split will not add any additional impacts to CRFR or our response to that area." F. Colorado Division of Water Resources (DWR) (See Exhibit 8): The following comments were submitted. • "Based on the above, it is our opinion, pursuant to CRS 30-28-136(1)(h)(I) that the proposed water supply will not cause material injury to decreed water rights, so long as the applicant maintains a valid well permit and the augmentation plan is operational. Provided the well continues to have a sustained yield similar to the rate reported in 1981, the water supply should be physically adequate for domestic purposes. Please note the long term adequacy of any ground water source may be subject to fluctuation due to hydrological and climactic trends." G. Public Comment from Lois Martinez (See Exhibit 13): The following comments were submitted. • "My name is Lois Martinez and I received, registered mail a notice that Jarad Elder has applied to change the zoning for a subdivision. I am assuming this is the area. Where me and my family owns minerals rights. For gas wells. I have no problem with the rezoning as long as he understands, he can not interfere 5 with anything that affect the income of my family from the gas wells. Lois Martinez" H. Garfield County Public Health (See Exhibit 9): The following comments were submitted. • "Drinking water: the shared private well that services the two properties has not been tested for water quality since 2003. Water quality tests are recommended every year for private drinking water wells, with more comprehensive tests every five years. Public Health suggests that the applicant should do a test on the well that is at least as robust as the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment Laboratory Services Division's Deluxe Colorado Package. A water treatment system should be use as necessary to assure safe drinking water for residents." • "Onsite Wastewater Treatment System: If the owner has not had the septic systems serviced and maintained since 2001, we recommend an inspection and tank pumping if necessary. The status and location of both systems should be known to be in good working order to protect groundwater supplies, including the residents' own drinking water well." I. Garfield County Vegetation Management (See Exhibit 10): The following comments were submitted. • "The county listed weeds, whitetop, Russian knapweed, and Russian olive are located on the property. It is too late this season to treat whitetop; however Russian knapweed and Russian olive may be treated this fall. Staff requests that the applicant treat the Russian knapweed this fall. Russian olive may be treated by using the cut stump method. Russian olive may be treated effectively in September and October." • "The County partners with the Conservation Districts on a noxious weed cost - share program that provides for partial financial assistance for noxious weed treatments. The applicant may contact the Vegetation Management Department for information on this program. Please provide this office with treatment records by October 31, 2017 (if any noxious weeds are located). A multi-year treatment program may be necessary." J. Garfield County Surveyor (See Exhibit 11): The following comments were submitted. • "Please refer to section 5-402 (F) Final Plat of the Garfield County Land Use Code. Once the plat is complete and correct please re -submit for review." • "Once these comments have been addressed and all final comments from the Community Development have been completed the Mylar may be prepared for recording. The Mylar shall be delivered to the Community Development office with all private party signatures no later than Monday the week prior to the next commissioner meeting day in order to make that meeting." K. Assistant Garfield County Attorney: (See Exhibit 12): 6 • "The title commitment was updated. There is a lender so the plat will need a lienholder certificate and signature. The plat should include a plat note that all easements and encumbrances in this updated commitment are referenced on the plat. The new title commitment number should be referenced." • "ILC—it looks ok. I had an issue with the northern access, but you pulled the subdivision exemption legal description for the property and it provided a legal to the southern portion of the road so access should not be a problem." VI. STAFF ANALYSIS Article 7, Division 1: General Standards 1. Section 7-101: Compliance with Zone District Use Regulations The development on the property is in general conformance with the dimensional standards for the Rural zone district. The minimum lot size in the Rural zone district is 2 acres and the smallest lot proposed is 2.001 acres. The Applicant's site plan shows the metal shop on Proposed Parcel B is located within approximately 20 feet of the proposed new lot line. Staff has determined that this lot line functions as a side setback and thus all structures meet required setbacks. 2. Section 7-102: Conformance with Comprehensive Plan and compliance with IGAs The parcel is labelled as Open Space / Public Land According to the Garfield County Comprehensive Plan of 2030. It is staffs opinion that this designation was is a Scribner's error. A Public Lands / Open Space designation is described in the Comprehensive Plan as, "Federal and state lands and land for which conservation easements preclude or limit further development." This parcel clearly does not meet this standard as it is a privately held piece of property without a conservation easement. The adjacent subdivision also is mislabeled. Surrounding parcels outside of the adjacent subdivision are designated as Residential Medium High with a suggested density of 2 to 6 acres per dwelling unit. The proposed subdivision creates lots of approximately two acres and three acres, which would meet the density recommendations for a Residential Medium High comprehensive plan designation. Additionally, no new dwelling units are being proposed as part of the Minor Subdivision. The ADU that will be located on one parcel was previously permitted with the County. The proposed subdivision is in general conformance with Garfield County's Comprehensive Plan Section 2 – Housing: Goal 1, which states, "To bring about a range of housing types, costs, and tenancy options, that ensure for our current and future residents affordable housing opportunities in safe, efficient, residential structures."This proposed lot split creates two smaller Tots, both of which will supply different sized lots than surrounding for County residents. This directly addresses the Comprehensive 7 Plan's goal to provide a variety of housing options. With this analysis, staff is of the opinion that the proposed subdivision is in general conformance of the Garfield County Comprehensive Plan. Comprehensive Plan Map 17927300356 )0727 I79;"30719? 2179 3120 7723 21709426002 • Urban Growth Area Industrial Mixed Use MI Commercial Res H (1/3 TO <2 Ac'Du)* Res MH (2 TO <6Ac/Du)* Res M (6 TO < 10 Ac/Du) Res L (10+ Ac, Du) Resource Production/Natural 3. Section 7-103: Compatibility 2T.' .;- i Parcels that are white or gray are considered Open Space / Public Land The proposed use is located in a rural residential area. Surrounding land uses are residential and/or agricultural in nature. The proposed subdivision would create a new lot, but would not create another dwelling unit, as the Applicant has proposed that the existing ADU would become the primary residential use on the new lot. It is Staff's opinion that the proposed Minor Subdivision is compatible with adjacent land uses. 8 4. Section 7-104: Sufficient, Adequate, Legal and Physical Source of Water The Applicant has proposed that both parcels will be served with well water from an existing onsite well (Division of Water Resources Permit No. 55921-F). The permit allows for water to be served to two single-family dwelling units and the well has served both the main residence and the ADU since 2001. The Applicant has indicated that there is a required augmentation pond on the property to meet Division of Water Resources augmentation requirements for use of the well by two dwelling units. The Applicant has supplied a proposed water well sharing agreement. The County Attorney has reviewed the agreement and recommended that as a Condition of Approval, the water sharing agreement be reviewed and approved by the County Attorney's office prior to final plat approval. This recommendation has been included as a Condition of Approval. The applicant has provided documentation that a 4 -hour pump test was completed in 2001, however the Garfield County Referral engineer included comments indicating that the pump test may no longer reflect the capacity of the well (Exhibit 3). He recommended that the Applicant should provide recent pump test results. The Division of Water Resources also echoed this comment by stating in their referral letter (Exhibit 8), "Provided the well continues to have a sustained yield similar to the rate reported in 1981, the water supply should be physically adequate for domestic purposes. Please note the long term adequacy of any ground water source may be subject to fluctuation due to hydrological and climactic trends." To address these two comments, a proposed condition of approval has been included that requires a 4 -hour pump test on the well. The Applicant has provided water quality tests from 2003 and also from June 2017. Neither of the tests address all of the water quality contaminants identified in Section 4- 203(M)(1)(B)(5)(C). Since neither of these tests is comprehensive, staff has included a suggested condition of approval that the Applicant test the well water to address all the contaminants identified in the Land Use and Development Code. This issue was also addressed by the Garfield County Department of Public Health's Comment (Exhibit 9), that stated: Drinking water: the shared private well that services the two properties has not been tested for water quality since 2003. Water quality tests are recommended every year for private drinking water wells, with more comprehensive tests every five years. Public Health suggests that the applicant should do a test on the well that is at least as robust as the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment Laboratory Services Division's Deluxe Colorado Package. A water treatment system should be use as necessary to assure safe drinking water for residents. Additionally, in the most recent water quality test supplied by the Applicant, the County designated engineer noted that E. Coli was detected in the water system (Exhibit 3). The Applicant should determine a treatment method to address the E. Coli in the well 9 water. As part of further water quality testing, the Applicant shall be required to submit a test that demonstrates there E. Coli and Coliform meets County standards according to Section 4-203(M)(1)(B)(5)(C) of the Land Use and Development Code. 5. Section 7-105: Adequate Central Water Distribution and Wastewater Systems The Applicant has supplied permits for both Onsite Wastewater Treatment Systems on the property, from 2001 for the ADU and from 1981 for the main residence. According to Assessor's Records, neither structure on the property has exceeded the amount of bedrooms that the septic system was permitted for through Garfield County. Referral comments from the Garfield County Department of Public Health stated (Exhibit 9): Onsite Wastewater Treatment System: If the owner has not had the septic systems serviced and maintained since 2001, we recommend an inspection and tank pumping if necessary. The status and location of both systems should be known to be in good working order to protect groundwater supplies, including the residents' own drinking water well. The County designated engineer's referral comments did not note a concern with either OWTS. Because both systems were originally permitted by the County, Staff has suggested a condition of approval that all OWTS' on the property be properly maintained. 6. Section 7-106: Adequate Public Utilities The applicant states that adequate public utilities are already in operation at the site and that Holy Cross Electric serves both the ADU and the existing dwelling. The applicant supplied an email from Holy Cross confirming that there is electricity at both the ADU and the existing dwelling. 7. Section 7-107: Access and Driveways a. The application was referred to the Garfield County Road and Bridge Department (see attached Exhibit 8). Dan Goin stated that both driveways have aprons and are up to code. b. The Applicant has supplied information demonstrating that both driveways for the proposed Tots meet the standards detailed in Table 7-107: Roadway Standards. 8. Section 7-108: Natural Hazards To address Section 7-108, the application states, "No proposed changes are being made to the land. The land will remain the same and therefore there shall be no new Natural or Geologic Hazards to be identified (including but not limited to falling rock, landslides, snow slides, mud flows, radiation, flooding, or high water tables.) 10 This application was referred to Colorado Geological Survey, to address potential natural hazards on the property. They had no objections to approval of the subdivision, however they did have several comments (Exhibit 6): Rockfall. The existing ADU on proposed Parcel B is located below a small slope containing detached blocks of Wasatch Formation (claystone, siltstone, sandstone, and minor conglomerate). The blocks appear to be stable under current conditions. Future improvements should be located and constructed such that any grading, driveway, foundation, or other cuts do not undercut the slope or otherwise remove any existing material supporting these blocks. Erosion setback from unnamed drainage channel. An unnamed, intermittent drainage channel crosses the site from east to west. No flood hazard has been mapped for this drainage. CGS recommends an erosion setback for any future improvements on both proposed lots, to reduce hazards associated not just with rising floodwaters but also erosion and scour. The setback should be determined based on site-specific analysis of topography and soil erosion properties. Staff has addressed these comments via plat notes that will be included on the plat. 9. Section 7-109: Fire Protection The application was referred to Colorado River Fire Rescue, who supplied comments stating, "I have no requirements or concerns with this lot split on the existing property including buildings and residences. This lot split will not add any additional impacts to CRFR or our response to that area." With this referral comment, it is staff's opinion the proposed subdivision satisfies Section 7-109 of the Land Use and Development Code. Article 7, Division 2: General Resource Protection Standards 10. Section 7-201 Agricultural Lands It is staff's opinion that the proposed Minor Subdivision will not impact existing agricultural uses. The density will remain the same, as the existing permitted ADU will become the primary residence on one parcel. No further development is proposed as part of the minor subdivision. With regards to Irrigation Ditches, the Application stated, "No irrigation ditches cross or adjoin the land to be subdivided." Staff did not note any irrigation ditches on site during the site visit. 11. Section 7-202 Wildlife Habitat Areas 11 The application was referred to Colorado Parks and Wildlife who stated, "After reviewing this proposal I find no significant wildlife concerns regarding this subdivision," (Exhibit 5). Staff agrees with Colorado Parks and Wildlife's assessment, especially since both dwelling units on both proposed lots are already constructed. 12. Section 7-203 Protection of Waterbodies The Applicant has provided evidence that there is an Augmentation Pond on the property that was created through the use of a dam. This pond releases water according to a Water Right and Augmentation Plan prepared by Resource Engineering in 1999, included in the application. This augmentation is required as part of the DWR permit 55921-F. Staff has determined that this pond qualifies as a water impoundment, which is defined in the Land Use and Development Code as: Confined water such as surface pits or ponds, wastewater treatment settling ponds, surface mining ponds, detention and retention ponds, artificial lakes and ponds (not related to agriculture), and produced water and condensate tanks. Water impoundment excludes tanks with a total tank volume of 5,000 barrels or fewer used exclusively for activities associated with Oil and Gas Drilling and Production, and Injection wells. Since staff has determined that the augmentation pond is a water impoundment, it does not qualify for a minimum setback from waterbodies. Therefore, although the Applicant has represented that one of the garages is located within 20 feet of the pond, it is not in violation of the Minimum Setback requirements. Additionally, all structures on the site were previously approved by the County. The Application suggests that the only waterbody on the site is the augmentation pond, however, the augmentation pond is filled by natural runoff. County GIS layers do not show a stream on this parcel and it is not mapped according to floodplain records. CGS addressed this issue in their comments by calling the drainage an, "intermittent drainage channel." Their comments about it stated (Exhibit 6): Erosion setback from unnamed drainage channel. An unnamed, intermittent drainage channel crosses the site from east to west. No flood hazard has been mapped for this drainage. CGS recommends an erosion setback for any future improvements on both proposed lots, to reduce hazards associated not just with rising floodwaters but also erosion and scour. The setback should be determined based on site-specific analysis of topography and soil erosion properties. Staff agrees with this assessment and has proposed a condition of approval that will address a waterbody setback from the unnamed drainage channel for any new construction. All current structures on the property were permitted by the County. 12 13. Section 7-204 Drainage and Erosion The Applicant provided topographic maps of the parcel to demonstrate that the site generally has positive drainage. The Applicant also stated that, "The subdivision of the Elder property does not include any development. Therefore there will be no change to the existing (A) erosion and sedimentation, (B) Drainage, (C) Stormwater Run-off because the existing dwelling, ADU and roadways are already in existence." The County designated engineer supplied a referral comment that stated (Exhibit 3): The Applicant states that drainage requirements are not applicable since the structures are constructed and existing. However, the Applicant should verify that there is positive drainage away from the structures, that there are no areas of shallow ponding, and that existing drainage patterns are not causing erosion or sedimentation problems. The single family residence, both associated sheds/garages, and the ADU were all permitted by the County. It is staff's opinion that since the structures are existing onsite and permitted, drainage was acceptable at the time of permit. Since no further development is proposed, it is Staff's opinion that the applicant has demonstrated compliance with this section. Any future development shall be required to meet positive drainage requirements. 14. Sections 7-205 Environmental Quality It is staff's opinion that no water or air quality issues are anticipated from the proposed project. 15. Section 7-206 Wildfire Hazards The subject property is identified as Not Rated, High, and a small portion of Moderate according to the Wildland Fire Susceptibility Index of the Community Wildfire Protection Plan. The applicant has represented that there are no slopes greater than 30 percent on the property. It is staff's opinion that the wildfire danger on this property is within manageable levels and is consistent with Code requirements. 16. Section 7-207 Natural and Geologic Hazards See Section 8 above. 17. Section 7-208 Reclamation No disturbance that would require reclamation is anticipated as a result of the creation of the proposed subdivision. Both dwelling units are already constructed as are associated driveways. As a result, a reclamation plan is not applicable. 13 Article 7, Division 3, Site Planning and Development Standards 18. Section 7-301 Compatible Design: The proposed Minor Subdivision is generally compatible with surrounding land uses. 19. Section 7-302 Off- Street Parking and Loading Standards: The Applicant has demonstrated through site plans that adequate off-street parking exists. 20. Sections 7-303 Landscaping Standards: The LUDC specifically exempts single family dwelling units from Section 7-303. 21. Section 7-304 Lighting: All exterior lighting will need to be downcast and comply with County standards. 22. Section 7-305 Snow Storage Standards: Adequate snow storage exists on the property. 23. Section 7-306 Trail and Walkway Standards: No recreational or community facility access areas are proposed. Article 7, Divison 4, General Subdivision Standards 24. Section 7-401 General Subdivision Standards The Applicant has supplied a water sharing agreement that will be used for the shared well on the property. The County Attorney's Office has suggested a Condition of Approval that the agreement be reviewed and approved by their office prior to final approval. Staff has included that recommendation as a suggested Condition of Approval. The Applicant did not show a maintenance easement for the well head and associated utilities on the plat. Staff has included a recommendation that an easement for this use be included on the Final Plat. 25. Section 7-402 Subdivision Lots No issues with lot configuration pursuant to this section have been noted. Final review and approval of the plat by the County Attorney's Office and the County Surveyor shall be required. 14 26. Section 7-403 Survey Monuments Compliance with these requirements will be confirmed through referral of the plat to the County Surveyor's Office. Compliance with any referral comments, corrections, and/or edits required by the County Surveyor should be included as conditions of approval. 27. Section 7-404 School Land Dedication School Land Dedication fees shall be required in accordance with the Land Use and Development Code. 28. Section 7-405 Traffic Impact Fees Traffic Impact Fees shall be required in accordance with the Land Use and Development Code. Any applicable fees shall be collected at the time of building permit. Article 5, Division 3, Minor Subdivision Review 24. Section 5-301(C)(1): It complies with the requirements of the applicable zone district and this Code. As proposed, the subdivision complies with the Rural zone district. 25. Section 5-301(C)(2): It is in general conformance with the Comprehensive Plan. See Section 2, above. 26. Section 5-301(C)(3): Shows satisfactory evidence of a legal, physical, adequate, and dependable water supply for each lot. See Section 4, above. 27. Section 5-301(C)(4): Satisfactory evidence of adequate and legal access has been provided. See Section 7, above. 28. Section 5-301(C)(5): Any necessary easements including, but not limited to, drainage, irrigation, utility, road, and water service have been obtained. Staff has included as a condition of approval that easements for the maintenance of the well and associated utilities be included on the Final Plat. 29. Section 5-301(C)(6): The proposed Subdivision has the ability to provide an adequate sewage disposal system. 15 See Section 5, above. 30. Section 5-301(C)(7): Hazards identified on the property such as, but not limited to, fire, flood, steep slopes, rockfall and poor soils, shall be mitigated, to the extent practicable. See Sections 8 and 15, above. 31. Section 5-301(C)(8): Information on the estimated probable construction costs and proposed method of financing for roads, water distribution systems, collection systems, storm drainage facilities and other such utilities have been provided. All utilities and infrastructure are in place on the property. 32. Section 5-301(C)(9): All taxes applicable to the land have been paid, as certified by the County Treasurer's Office. The Applicant will need to obtain the signature of the County Treasurer on the final plat indicating that taxes have been paid. This must be accomplished prior to the BOCC signing the plat. 33. Section 5-301(C)(10): All fees, including road impact and school land dedication fees, shall be paid. All road impact fees shall be collected at the time of building permit. Since the property is not located in the RE -1 School District, the Applicant shall pay $200 per dwelling unit to the appropriate school district. 34. Section 5-301(C)(11): The Final Plat meets the requirements per section 5- 402.F., Final Plat. As a condition's of approval, staff has suggested numerous changes that need to be made to the plat for it to meet section 5-402 F. of the Land Use and Development Code. VII. SUGGESTED FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends a finding that, with the recommended conditions, the proposed Minor Subdivision is in conformance with the Comprehensive Plan of 2030 as well as the Land Use and Development Code. Staff, therefore, recommends approval with conditions of the Elder Minor Subdivision application. Suggested Findings 1. That proper public notice was provided as required for the Administrative Review Land Use Change Permit. 16 2. That with the adoption of conditions, the application is in general conformance with the 2030 Comprehensive Plan, as amended. 3. That with the adoption of conditions the application has adequately met the requirements of the Garfield County Land Use and Development Code, as amended. Suggested Conditions of Approval Conditions Prior to Signature of the Plat 1. The Applicant has 90 days within which to satisfy applicable conditions of approval and provide the following documentation for BOCC signature and recordation: a. A plat mylar with signed Certificates that include Dedication and Ownership, Title, Taxes, Surveyor, and any mortgagees. b. Recording Fees. c. The following amendments shall be made to the plat prior to obtaining signatures. This updated plat shall be provided to, reviewed, and accepted by the Community Development Department, the County Attorney's Office and the County Surveyor prior to creating a Mylar copy of the plat and obtaining any signatures. i. The name and address of the mineral owners shall be shown on the plat. ii. The final plat shall include the Name, address, and seal of the certifying registered land surveyor preparing the Final Plat. iii. The name and addresses of the property owner shall be included on the plat. iv. The plat shall be in black and white ink, no color. v. The title of the plat shall be changed to reflect that it is for the Elder Minor Subdivision and it shall provide the correct legal description. vi. The lengths of all arcs, radii, and tangents shall be identified and sufficient data shall be shown for all curved lines on the Plat to enable reestablishment of curves in the field. vii. Lot A shall be identified on the plat with its corresponding area shown to two decimal places. viii. The area of Lot B shall be shown to two decimal places ix. The width of all adjacent right-of-ways shall be added to the plat. 17 x. Notes on the second page shall be changed to represent the proposed Elder Subdivision. xi. The Applicant shall remove any note or description of a parcel of land in the Cordillera Subdivision. xii. The name and map number of any bordering subdivision within 200 feet of the boundaries of the plat shall be included on the final plat. xiii. The width, purpose, and owners of all easements shall be shown on the plat. xiv. The footprint of any structures on the property shall be removed from the plat. xv. The locations of the driveways shall be removed from the plat. xvi. The septic and water property improvement information shall be removed from the plat. xvii. Any protective covenants/restrictions shall be noted on the Plat. xviii. The plat shall show a utility and maintenance easement that gives access to the well head and any associated infrastructure from both properties. xix. The Applicant shall include the following plat notes as describe in the Garfield County Resource Guide, as Amended. a. Noxious Weeds b. Open Hearth Solid-Fuel Fireplaces c. Exterior Lighting d. Right to Farm e. Maintenance of Fences, Rural Living, Etc. f. Mineral Rights g. Domestic Dogs xx. The Certificate of Dedication and Ownership shall be updated to match the approved language in the County Resource Guide. xxi. The County Commissioners Certificate shall be updated to match the approved language in the County Resource Guide. xxii. The Certificate of Dedication and Ownership shall be updated to match the approved language in the County Resource Guide. xxiii. The Surveyor's Certificate shall be updated to match the approved language in the County Resource Guide. xxiv. The Lienholder Consent and Subordination Certificate from the County Resource Guide shall be included on the plat. xxv. The following plat note shall be added to the plat: "No further subdivision of the parcels within Elder Minor Subdivision are permitted by Minor Subdivision, as defined in the Land Use and Development Code of 2013, as amended." xxvi. A plat note shall be added to the plat that all easements and encumbrances in the updated title commitment are referenced on the plat. The new title commitment number should be referenced. 18 xxvii. A plat note shall be added to the plat that states, "Future improvements on Parcel B should be located and constructed such that any grading, driveway, foundation, or other cuts do not further impact the slope or remove any existing material supporting the detached Wasatch Formation blocks." xxviii. A plat note shall be added that states, "Any new structure that requires a building permit on either lot shall meet an erosion setback from the intermittent drainage channel, determined through a site-specific analysis of topography and soil erosion properties completed by a Professional Engineer." 2. Prior to BOCC signature on the Plat the Applicant shall provide the Declaration of Water Well Use and Maintenance Obligations to the Garfield County Attorney's Office for review and approval. 3. Prior to the BOCC signature on the Plat the Applicant shall submit a water quality test for review and approval by the Community Development Department and the County designated engineer. The test shall address all contaminants listed in Section 4-203(M)(1)(B)(5)(C). If any contaminants are in violation of acceptable standards, the Applicant shall complete water treatment measures. Once water treatment measures are complete and/or installed, the applicant shall supply a new test to Garfield County Community Development and the County designated engineer to demonstrate water quality meets required standards. 4. Prior to the BOCC signature on the Plat the Applicant shall provide a four (4) hour pump test that meets the standards detailed in Section 4-203(M)(1)(B)(5)(a). The pump test shall include an opinion that the well will be adequate to supply water for the proposed uses. The pump test shall be reviewed and accepted by the Community Development Department and the County designated engineer. 5. Prior to the BOCC signature on the Plat, the Applicant shall treat any County listed noxious weed on the property. Garfield County Vegetation Management requests treatment records by October 31, 2017 if any noxious weeds are located. 6. Prior to the BOCC signature on the Plat the Applicant shall pay any applicable School Land Dedication Fees. Other Conditions 7. All representations of the applicant within the application and/or public hearing shall be considered conditions of approval unless otherwise modified by the Board of County Commissioners. 8. All exterior lighting shall be downcast and shielded and comply with Section 7- 304, Lighting Standards, of the Land Use and Development Code of 2013, as amended. 19 9. The property owner shall maintain onsite wastewater treatment systems on both parcels in good working order. 20 Site Visit Photos Access — Lot A Residence Lot A 21 Augmentation Pond ADU Access 22 Garfield County PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE INFORMATION Please check the appropriate boxes below based upon the notice that was conducted for your public hearing. In addition, please initial on the blank line next to the statements if they accurately reflect the described action. 0 My application required written/mailed notice to adjacent property owners and mineral owners. Mailed notice was completed on the -/ day of , 20..,. All owners of record within a 200 foot radius of the subject parcel were identified as shown in the Clerk and Recorder's office at least 15 calendar days prior to sending notice. All owners of mineral interest in the subject property were identified through records in the Clerk and_Recnrder orAssessor, IoIr through utile' means [list] � 1 f+ l4 Pity C�% l CoVVI.R_•t (i i(+ 1 � r. l�i1i'�1l1#rl�.tJ G� I*i'l J tt-1 le . ■ Please attach proof of certified, return receipt requested mailed notice. 0 My application required Published notice. Notice was published on the day of , 20_. • Please attach proof of publication in the Rifle Citizen Telegram. 0 My application required Posting of Notice. Notice was posted on the day of , 20_. Notice was posted so that at least one sign faced each adjacent road right of way generally used by the public. I testify that the above information is true and accurate. Name: Signature: Date: - (:{� yo rf\ X217 17 Totot Postage ind FosC ▪ �� . Sent To y $Frasiaird yF.o: oris000i No. 07/21/2017 • "City, Troia, 21/V43- xi.' . .�A'•�Y� f:f 112.Ilf51'.hi.7:.i:,. I}rje're : rc r lixstrtf lt4 VS. Postel Servicer" CERTIFIED MAIL' RECEIPT Domestic . Mali Only . or;doZ{yery.1Pf ir)izfiiinrn, Vi$it;olil.iigi3Stcp...a)<svf yy. ira�s;001». "f`IIR-, l" '.'1. • Cert(f(esl Irian Fee $3.35 $ 42.75 CTliir esvlc@S& Feea (check5oo After rte5 rpvr'r-,(P, 0 Return Receipt (hardcopy) $ PU.'++ti• . . ❑ Relurn Receipt (electronic)Postmark ❑ Cedlned Mall Restricted Delivery 5-$F0• "- Here b,_� . ❑Adult Signature Required 5-#--[+ :...."-`". ❑ Adult Signature Restricted weary 5 1154:, Poa(ago $0,49 Ltd Postage ond¢op: Serif To bbffII 'timer and 02 07/21/2017 Vhy, Stale, Z/P+4° SPOITIMI Seo -tomo fvai441 service pr®vlCaes tries Tonovvirltg deriesirl' re A receipt (this portion of the Certified Mail Iahni) for an elechonie return receipt, see id A unlque identifier for your mailpiece. associate for assistance. To receive Electronic verification of delivery or attempted return receipt for no additional fee, USPS® -postmarked Certified Mail retail associate. - Restricted delivery service, which I d31Wou lythe acicliessee speeped. to ilia addraiiseds 8otheirred agent,. Adult eignaturo corvlce, which requires the signee to beat least 21 years of ace !not delivery. e AMAe7AO of delivery (including the recipient's sigigrrtunt, dial Is !Brained by Ihn Poslal Service' fora specified period. Important Reminders You may purchase Certified Mail service with First-Class6•aai a Carolyn Andrews or Priority M EXHIBIT 0 Certified Mall t 14541West Bates Place international n G Insurance cow Lakewood, CO 80228 with Certified I of Certified Ma insurance tout certain Priority E For au addition. endorsement on the rnhilpiece, you may request the following services: - Return receipt service, which provides a record of delivery (Including the recipient's signature). You can request a hardcopy return receipt- or an electronic version. For a hardcopy return receipt, MOW PS Form 3811, Domestic Holum R OM:attach PS Form 3811 to your mailpiece; k.e, With ilrs of ago specified `*d agent IS Id bear a ark on Certified Mail Rpm t p Post Offce'" for postmarldng. if ydaft't need a postmark on this Cerlified Mail receipt, detach the barcedod portion' of this label, affix it to the mailpiece, op d appropriate postago, and deposit the mailplece. IRIPO RTAf1T, Save this receipt for your records, P5 Form 3600, April 2015 (Reverse)PSN 7530-02-000-9047 Certified Mail service provides the following benefits: for an electronic return receipt, see a retail associate for assistance. To receive a duplicate i return receipt for no additional fee, present this USPS® -postmarked Ceditied Mall receipt to the. retail associate. - Restricted delivery service, which provides delivery tnilho addressee specified by.patne, or to the sddfessen o authorized agent. - Adult slgat(lure service, which requires the signee toboellrast21 years of age (not available at Ma. a A receipt ((his porton of the Certified Moll label). 0 A unique identifier for your mallpleco. o Electronic verification of delivery or attempted delivery. a A record of delivery (Including the recipient's signature) that Is retained by the Postal Service - for a ervice'"fora specified period. lmportanl Itanrfnders: You may pun:hesh edited Mail service with First -Clan Mail °, F1Irst•Class Package ServiceP,-- or Priority Mail' service. ocnlernrtnlieatfwi tli Mark A. Huttner & Cathlyn J. Huttner � hro5lancer 21427 East Ottawa Circle with CorliO efCedifled Aurora, CO 8(1015 (n0ur00001 certain Pric u For an addi endurse010 the fo8owlo. - Ilelum rcocfpt service, width provdae a record of delivery {Ineluding the recipient's slgnature.)- lba can requests haadcnpy reblrn receipt or an 01108ani0wagon. For a hardcopy return receipt, complete P$ Form 3811, Domestic Return Reculpt; attach PS Form 3811 10 your mallpiece; If4PORTANi: Sava tits reoelpl for paur records, P5 Forrn 3600, April 2015 (Reverse) PSN 7530.02.000.9047 •endce,which I years of ago `oe specified lo dud agent (pt Is hould hoar o einiark on )nt your rruYOndleang: a you don't need a postmark orf this - Certified Mat recolpl, detach the barcoded porton of eds./ode, WIN It 10 the matpfece, apply • , apprapdalo postage, amt deposit the mailpiece.. Certified Mail service provides the following benefits: ° A receipt (This portion of the Certified Mall label). for an electronic return metal. sea a retail 8Aunique identifier for your mailpleco, assadalafor assfeleoce.TOreceive aduplicate r ° Electronic verification of delivery or attempted return receipt fo( he additional fee, propane lids delivery. USPSO-pnatmarlred Certified Mal receipt to Ilia - eArecord ofdelivery (ircludingthe recipient's retell associate. algnatsre) that is retained by the Postal Service Restricted depvarysetvica, Which pfgyides fora Specified period. deliveryi (O tie 'addressee splro1rNidby name, or to the adthossra+s anther/zed agent important Reminders: - Adult sinnahire comi,n mhirh ram„i,uc x n rYaumaypurdr Jimmie Beres,Jr. first -Class Mail; f CerUlfedMaNlsen4 221 Rye Beach Road, Apt. #1F Mich • International mail, Mage Huron, Ohio 44839 ified rInsurance coverage gent with Certified Mail of Certified Mail se insurance covaragi certain Priority Mal, NIT a For adth[fonel tea, and (vtth'a' ra ter ,tieu„rxn• „ pin pI. please present h000lsl'fn n p I lids Certified Mallrecefpl, please presentyour endorsement do the matiplece, yaer mayrequesl eerlilfad Mali item at!Vast Office' for the 131101ving services: postnwrldng. If you don't needs postmark on this - Return receipt service, whleh prat/bias a record Certified Mat rec0]pI, de(ack Ilia barnacled pudica of delivery (including Iho rociplantt signature). of this label, affix R to Iho moilpieoe, apply You can rcqueal a hardcopy rolien recefpt or on appropriate postage, and deposit ties mallp]eee. &retonle uoeslon. Far a Irardeapy return receipt, complete PS Form 3611, a eroeosa'arigfcrm Receipt; attach PSForm 3811 to your mailpiece; IMPORTANT: Save this receipt for your records, :Form 3C U Q, April 2015 (Reverse) PSN 7530-02-000-9047 D ED m ..n ru rl 0 rI D D D ..Cf .n D N N u, D rU r1 D r9 D D D D .n bgfairgbriaOt MAIL') FIECEI Pt Frr'a 16Y6S-k - DENVER .f i2s131 L' !) 1 Certified Muff Fea 5 U 0543 112 Extra Services &Nee prank box, odd fee ep aro) 0 Return Receipt (hardcopy) 5 ❑ Retum Receipt (electronic) 5 $0 -fin ❑Cedi11 d Mail Restricted Delivery S.-__ ❑ Adult Signature Required 5 ❑Adun Signature Restricted Delivery $ Postage $0.49 Total Po to i asld vg..4 Sent ii liue3 rir r. No., or PO CiFy, Stere 211°O'4Y Postmark Here 07/21/2017 F rice d;�IifI,70f5 P? N76V1•ov 7.8.1iKa 'see ilei ll 1,34.11191.1. 11, 5: Postal Service”' QF .TIFIED MAIL1' RECEIPT o.. �ahi�s[Ic Marl only FpY:deliverylihl !r!ailon, Vibsite 01 v..)s v.flspc:cpmF. AURORA Pr' CDF3OQ1ff 11 If' 1 Certflled Mail Fee yy 5 $,.1 Neu SoNCOs & Fees rnessaboti odd tOCUPP ❑ ReturnReoelpt (hardcopy) S_SD - ❑ Return Receipt (electronic) S t%(�>zl _ Postmark ❑Cediaed MeilRestdctedDerrvery $ BO___;� '^ Here ❑Adulrsignalme Required S ..7"+• ©Adultetpnaloo Restricted Delivery r 0 050 0543 02 Pastas $0.49 a D .-0 .n D N D N vf:r-'.,'•• .• r It:,lr.ipplO 1 ayenerriea PV9as service provides le A receipt (Ihls porton of the Certified Mail label). in A unique identifier for your mailpiece, le Electronicvedgcatlon of delivery or attempted deliver/. ° A record of delivery (Including lire recipient's signature) that Is retained by the Postal Service'" for a specified period. • Important Reminders: re You may purchase Certified Mall snrvlre with FlatclnxrP, IDouglas Denton or Priority Mail a Certified Mall s p.O. Box 7947 International e' a Insurance cove Midland, TX 79708 wills CerWled P of Certified Ma insurance COVE certain Priority ▪ For an addiUona.. .........• ..L endorsement On the mallplate, you may request the following services: - Retum receipt service, which provides a record of delivery (Including the reelplehre alpnatura). You can request a liardcopyretum receipt or an ulogroaic version. For u hardcopy rehire receipt, compacta PS Form 3811, Domes Rohm Recelpl; attach PS Form 3811 to your mailpiece; tfle following benefits: for so electronic (shim receipt, see a retail associate for assistance. To receive a duplicate return receipt form additional fee, present this USPSemoslmadred Certified Mail receipt to the retail associate. - RasWde3delivery service, which provides delpfary to the addressee esifcMed by dame, or to Iho addressee's authorised ripest. - Adult signature setvlpe, which requires the e,nn an fn ho at le mat 31 vanrc of on. mot R, Welch us of age veised nd agenA Id bear a 'ark on nes wr enee rmn I n:wpr, prcocu pr mom your Certified Mail Ilam eta Pest office for pasimorklap.11 you ddn'I need a p01lnialkon Ibis Certified Mag receipt, detach the hareadod portion of this !Ask aiflx p to Ilse mnliptoce, apply appropriate postage, and deposit the meifplece. IMPORTANT; Savo Nils receipt for your records. PS Form HOG, Apd12015 (Reverse) P5N 7650.02.000-9047 Certified Mail service provides A receipt (this portion of the Certified Mail label). o A urdque identifier for your maifplece. Electronic verification of delivery or attempted delivery. E A record of delivery (Including the recipient's signature) that is retained by the Postal Service"' tor a specified period, Important Reminders: ""layprllciv 1 Chris Stratton Rist -Class Mai or PriorityMall, P'0' O. Box 878 Gornto Mail sr iptarnal(onal m Ouray, CO 81427 a Insurance cover with Codified W of Certified Mail Insurance cover certain Priority L .._..._. o For an addllienal.fee,.and with a proper endorsement lathe hairpiece, You may request the following services: - Return receipt service, which provides a record of delivery (Including the recipient's signature), You can request a hardcopy return receipt or an electronic version. For a hardcopy return receipt, complete PS Farm 3811, Domestic Return Receipt; attach PS Form 3811 to your mailpiece; PS Form 3800,Apd12015 (Reverse) PSN 7530.02-000. the following benefits: for an electronic return receipt, see a retail associate for assistance, To receive a duplicate return receipt for no addittonal fee, present this USPS® -postmarked Certified Mall recelptlo the retail associate. - Restricted delivery 001010e, which pomades delivery tetria njtdri=sMee speb(Qed,hy name, or to the addressee's authorized agent. o . II d, which ps of age garaged . jII8 agent -,h bear USPS poslnr3rk.11 you woldd liken postmark on • Vila Certified Mail receipt, pleas$ preaontyaur Coddled Mali item at a Past Urger for pnotmerldng`lf Yee dea'I n08d a poslm5k on this Cerfil€ed Mali receipt, detach Ilio burcOded portion - oi lids fabs!, affix 11 to the maifffleco,apply 2f iropdale postage, oral deposll 1110 mailpieca, IMPORTANT; save this receipt for your records, 9047 t7: n -I O 1:0 N a d N cis ai E?I'Vic6• CERTIFIED MAIL'T' RECEIPT Da,» stir urn/ Only .. - .... ;• s:; ;;17•k r Gr doUVcrjr 1131(]Tin%l1� MI F1 >�;T •;;7718' Q Jr_l'dp'!']511ru ai V, U, i1.•,u$j75.G�r71�(.; _ Certified Mall Fee $3.65 1 tria Extra ery cos as (Chock Aoso addrae ate) ❑ Return Receipt (henicopy) $ ❑ Retum Receipt (electronic) $ ❑ Certified Mao Restricted Delivery $ ❑ Adult Signature Required $ ❑ Adult $Ignalure r'rrslikled Delivery $ $U -CIU 40.00 $0.00 Postage S • $0.49 Total Postage and Fees $6.59 Sentra$ire9lei1i/�1pL or• I3 0543 02 ON&am --- ------------------------- ---•-----,-., .... nn:ra ;lar: r-.r:o; • :-}4 ' .r :.rtls,,-. U.S. Postal CERTIFIED IVIA1101TECEIPT Domestic Mall 'airy k for (tyihv1ry;ofnrni:Ilinii..visit;t)ttrviobs14421 wtveyusps;carri.`. • ;t.}; r.Lyr LrtlI:Lt Malt atatt VIt:t0 IJrfivirardtt Ll Etc, lVrr4W1[atj 8J1311tl lt8if. t7 A receipt (this portion of the Certified Edell lebcij. for no electronic retvm receipt; sees reldll el A emigre identifier for your nlallploca. associate for as015tence.Te receivea daprlaala fl ElecuanLCvorihcauon of dehvaty or attempted Mum receipt for no additional fee, present 1111e LLSPS®-posimatked Certified Mall receipt lo Ilia retail associate. - ttestdclod &dim yservice, which provides derJoiy.fa Ille.addreser specified by harm, er lolhdaddre acsaulhorucdagent: - Adult algualuiesetviLe, which requires the nit ..n..... ,.r.,.,n ,not deft ory o A record of dol very (indudmg the recfpfonth algnabito) 8In1 Is related by the Patel Service'' for a epecipad period. Important Rnmlmioroi ® YOgminpurcne� first -Clem MO Lois Martinez or Priority Mail, ocarugedma11a4945 Mark Dearling Blvd, Lot 170 Inlcrnnhe cove Colorado Springs, o Irestrmnae ccove CO 80918 with Certified h of Certified Mai Insurance cove certain Priority For an additional pee, and Wein a proper endorsemelit oh file mallpince, You now request the following services: - Return receipt service, which provides a record of delivery (Including the recipient's signature). You can request a hardcapy return receipt or an electronic version, Fora hardcopy return receipt, complete PS Form 3811, Domestic Return Receipt; attach PS Form 3811 to your mallpiece; irdPORTAk@ Sava this receipt for your records. PS Foam 3800, April 2015 (Reverse) PON 7530-02-000-9047 a, which Irs of aye 1pcciticd lel agent id bear a ark on 100 COIVrLOO Mall rattler, masa present per Serried Mull item at. a Peal Mee for postmarking. If you don't need 8 poalmet k oil this Certified hlell receipt, detach Ito barcoded portion of this label, affix it to the mailpiece, apply appropriate postage, and deposit the mailpiece. Certified Mali service provides 11 Areceipt phis podia of rho Wald Mab label), 11 Aunique identifier for yalu mafploco. • Electronic verlgcalfen of delivery or etlempled dahvety. • A record of delivery (Including the recipient's algriature) That Ls retained by the Postal Service' . fora specified petted. - c cinfportanlRaj71Vplayphfltffdh05aLinda Lawerence 17t61.CtasaMalle, 15 El Paso Blvd., Lot 115 lir Pdslily Mats° a uCodified btaltsen ivian'itou Springs, CO 80829 Intematlonal me11 • IllM8811CocOve[aj with Certified Mai of Certified Mall s insurance cevoray - . , - ....... certain Priority Mall items. 0 For an additidnatfee, agdtvilii-a proper endorsement on the mallplece, you may request the f81811,1ng services: - Return rocelplaent°, which provides a record of delivery (Including the reclplonlh signature), 11xteaa regiirol a hardcopy roam receipt or an alecuanic version. Fal bet deer/ return receipt, complete PS Form 3011, Damask ltelum Rocelprralien PS Fe/m3811 to yawl mallplece; iMPII 1T1810 Save this mcelptfor your records. PS Form 3800, April 2015 (Reverse) PSN 7590.02-000.9047 ;ertifiaci [Mail service provides the rtol following bene$iitsfor mlalt associate for assisiatloo.T0 receives/upl[saia relent receiptfor no ndt88eno1 fee, preset 1h1s LISPSIDlestmalfrod Certified Malt recoIptto the retail associate. - Restricted delivery sa1Vlce, which provides delivery to Me addresseespecliled by name, or •,_.,.,..,.:u.. o,,'a a1EarELLdegbrd: the following benefits: FOC en *diorite return receipt, see a :Walt n011001 to for asslulerlco.To receive a dupllceto return receipt fa;no additional fee, present this VSPS®-paslmhiked Cedtffad tdatl recolpl to Ma salad associate. - Restricted dldlvary sendoe,whkh provides dohvety to the.addreOsu dll aeclled byname, or I nn.rr , �...-.. �vhildr age )cited ogonl . 1.Ceptea as regal proei of cwSng, it ohauid hoary LISPS posiraarlCS Yov'vrould ilk a postmark en this CorliPld Mail receipt, please present your Certllad MuE1 Eleni eta Pose Mend' for postmarking. If ydir dant need a psalmatk On this Coddled Mai] receipt, detach the barcoded porden al 1hist:Mei, attic 11 lo the mailpiece, apply appropriate postage, and deposit me m1Hpiece, A receipt (this portion of the Certified Mall label). A unique identifier far your mailpiece. 1 Electronic verification of delivery or attempted delNerY: r A record of dollen Oncled the reelplenr8 signalise) Ilaol Is retained by She Postal Service foraspectiied pe'-" tinpnrinnttiomNJohn C. Thomas e Youmaypurom F.O. Box 6881 First• Class rdaEla clrPilaf ltySall' San Antonio, TX 78209 s Codified Mail se international mr oi Insurance cover wiW Certified fit of Certified Mail insurance coverage automatically included with ceilaln Priority Mail items. 0 For an additional fee, and wish a proper endorsement on the ro0Elpiea;,jrau may request me .01(1100S0rldta8: RCWRI fecelptselvice,wllirtr Provides a timed of delivery [Including rte sn1iplelll'ssignalure). NMI Can molest 8lwideoPy r0101 n I aC9lpt Dr nn electronic v0r$tan. Far a hardcopy return racolpt, complete PS Form 3811, fOomea#JC 110188) Reoerpeattach PS Fenn 3011 10 year mallplOO.0 which of ripe oafed. fly¢agent accepted as leg& pine tit u,un0,.. +' 1I3edrd I USPS poslmaiie.lf.you would like a positrmrk on ttds CetSlled Melt receipt, pleaso prosenl your Certified Mag Item at a Past Cilifar tar postmarking: if you don't need a pasimatkon tiffs Cetttfed Mali menlpi, detach the barcoded pndinti W 1118label, alflx it to the malipieca, app1Y appropriate postago,and deposit ltlemaypiece. •I tritPORTAhit Sage this receipt for your records. , PS Form 3800, A012015 (Reverse) PSN 7530-02-000-0047 Ln r9 r° .A fid rR 0 0 0 -a .1 0 N rl 0 N 0 t-9 1-9 ru 0 r1 0 O 0 0 .A ..n 0 rR 0 r- cO —o- , 0 r9 0 0 0 i i p'o17• i -of: CERTIFIED MAIL° RECEIPT Dorosticio ,-Oily - .. . .Forittgvis1l:pi rveepeitc lilN v�y,rrs)rs.:coni,': col f.o ,sea; r cp kr) Certified Moil Foo $3.3 -+r 5 Extra Services & Fees ibhockeroa ur/F84 o iec) D Return Receipt (hardcopy) $ ❑ Return Receipt (electronic) $ $0.000 ❑ Certified Mell Restricted Delivery $0i^-_ ❑ Adult Signature Required $ _stsr...700.- ❑Aden Signature Rese,Ieled LeaNefy $ Peerage S $01.49 Total Postage end Peep S $4.59 &roar anti ip .trio., or M tla fro, GRy, Lu`19-i0. 21f 41 Sent To 0543 02 Poslmnrk J Nem ('7/21/2017 s� olr�l;�Buo iq�r7�o�,,Ps r:g5:p ti U.S. Postal Service" CERTIFIED.IVIAIL' RECEIPT Domestic Alai! Drily For'cl ivory IPilPr RAL is 7;Lt+) ,try it 1/yeta,oits f 6ylvty. uses -Corte :ti -1r1, .t .1 Sit-"•• r --1.;o; • r jr lr Certified -Malt Fee $3.35 s 12.75 fcxfro SOrvfcea & Fees &heck0o., ride r.krfliti bare) 01101189 Receipt (ha rdcopy)• $ iV--V�IV^ ❑ Return Receipt (elootronlc} $ >a0 a1 J •y'S ❑ Certified Mall Restricted Delivery $ ❑ Adult Signature Required$_tam-04� �- ti , -� Very 0543 02 ❑ Adult Signature Restricted 09110050 $ Postage $0.49 ?Sabi Postage and n.55, Sent To uiiaa�anof : & . ii)5 $tale, *ilbi* Postmark =.Here P7/21/2017 ' 5rEma t ki6r..$� pSsj;IO�yp.• ,"y„ l... Postal Service"' , TIFIED NMA112 RECEIPT 06-1. 1a1ln'atili Iiisil:u4(1ryrtbsiits at; hrrlyr6uspr5,gi7Vie sAitAq!a?,{r mph CerfirledMail Fee �� $13.35 Extra Services & Fees peck box, addroa rs ❑Rcluin tlooeipt(hardeopy) $ ❑ Return Receipt (electronic) $ $0.00 ❑ Certmed Mall Restricted Delivery $ *0.00 0 Adult Signature Required $ 0 Adult Signature Restricted Delivery $ 501.00 0 Total Postage and Pees $ 6r59 F' - r1 0 1` - Postage 1101.49 0543 02 i00Sl Arndt Hire 07/21/2017 Sent To Miller R&M Ar ., or Fragox No. •L`7iy, Stale, QIP+4t° r to en€tereu 116011' :3U11tb® tsr,dV tlJE:ti ® A receipt (this portion of the Certified Mall label). li A unique Identifier for your mallplece. n Electronic verification of delivery or attempted delivery. ® A record of delivery (Including The recipient's signature) that Is retained by tho Postai Service for n specified period. bnpoftant lieminddrs: © You may punt'-' lamas nn.n o.nilro with Flrat•Cleaa Lori Nelson or Monty lila la Codified Moll 7710 East 131' international! o Insurance col Bixby, OK 74008 with Certified of Certified M Insurance cot certain Priorii e For an addiilonat too, ern van u 10„v i endorsement on the mallplece, you may request lila following o rviceo: - Return receipt service, lyfllcll provides 0 record of delivery (including hie IeCipllnl's signature). You can requests ilardcopy locum receipt Fla an electronic version. Fir a hantcnpy return receipt, comp:file PS Form 38(1, sear orcin datum Racrrief attach PS Form 3831 to your mailpikce; LIM aU11UWlleaf I.mit rcr rca. for an electronic return receipt, see a retell associate for assistance. To receive a duplicate return receipt for no additional fee, present this USPS® -postmarked Certified Mail receipt to lira relail associate. - Restricted delivery service, which provides delivelyIoiho addreoseespedfled by name, or to the addrusae`e'setlih011iedagent: ' - Adult signohtrese ica,Allah regimes the ....,„,....,.„1.1,, , 'a -'Ii , MN. n ,,F.,.0.10011 I ce, which ars of age specified red agent 1a (laid bear a Hark on MI5 carmen man recelpr, please present your Certified Mail item et a Past Office- for postmarking.lf 'fu don't Flood a postmalft on this Certified Mall receipt, detach' the barmier! portion of this label, affix it to the mailplec6, apply appropriate postage, and deposit the mailplece. IMPCRTAfbT: Savo this receipt for your records. PS Form 3600, April 2015 (Reverse) PS0 7530-02-000.9047 Certified Mail service provides the following benefits: A receipt (this porilon of the Certified Mail label), for an aleclronfc retimi receipt, sea ardor as A unique Identifier for your mailplece. assoetatn for assialalrru.To receive a dupliCate Electronic verification of delivery or attempted solum receipt for no additional fee, present 00s • dellvery, o A record of delivery{fncarding the recipient's Signature) that is relainrd by UiSPostai Service'" fors specified period. ImportantRemladers: e Ynu may purchase Cerfipsd M,11 c.r.u.•, ,.,Fla First -Cies Jordan Beres or Priority, ▪ Canieedh4 221 Rye Beach Road, Apt. #1F Intimation y insurancbt Huron, Ohio 44839 will Certif. of Certified insurance c certain Prio E For an odds I,. - endorsement on.lpe tno)Ipiece; you may request the fallovdnp shrvices: - Return lacelpf scrvtce, vlh!d, provides n record of davory (including fro recipients signaler). you can request a hardcopy raMn l receipt or an tdcolronle voodoo, For a hardcapyrelum receipt, compete PS Fenn 8811, llomar(!c Rohan Receipt; attach PS Form 3811 Ie your meiipiece; IMPORTANT: Save Ns receipt for your records. PS Form 3800, ApOl 2015 (Reverse) 05147530.02-005-9047 f13P5tii-poobnarkad Cerlihod Maiiiecelpt lathe ;aloft associate. - Restricted delivery servleo, width presides delbrery in the addleper spsfhfed by naalo, or i to lbo'ndd%s1se's heriliofflafliegerti: ,' - Adult signalure cervine. which rangkes the ie(not ena%ubleit } years of ape }cespoclilsil mired agent Ufa iaatd hear a ."npu 111111kon this Certified Mali receipt, please present your Certified Mall Item ata Post Office'" for • poslmeride0.l1 you front feed aposhilark on this Certified Melt rOtiefpl;detach lite harcndad portion 01 Urfa label, affix Rio Res malip:aee,apply - appropriate pellage, and dopasf the malipiece. Certified Mail service provides the following benefits: rr A rncefpl{this portion of rho Codified Mall label). foran ciocbenlo return recalpl, see a retail io A unique Identiliertor your mafipioce. user -fele for asslulanco.To melee duplicate r e. Electra* verllrcalion of delivery Or otrrrrrptod delivery. I, Arend of dolrery (including Iheradpienl's signature) Mat Is retained by tho Pastel Service' for specified period. Important Rerldnrranor 11 You may pur0lsler First•paalfail' G�•orge G. V orPrlorilyhian,, P Q u Cerli(!ed Mairso, SOX 13557 lnfernolfonai rr r O�'ii t1 ufnswancocdvai lie', CO $0201 with Certified al Ceriilfed Ma frmurancs tour cerlol10 Priority Mori -. Foran additional (ea, and with a proper endoraenrrul do 11m mal lasa,yiiu may mildest Ina fallawlep a1H1d*P,5; Return receipteervlce, which provides a record of delivery (Including Ma recipient'salghnlure), V.111000 requests haulm,/ robin] rocoipl oxen electronic version. Fora Irardeopy return recap', conlyfelo PS farm 3011, f10eme54 Relwn Receipt; attach PS Form 3811 to your nialipiece; R nso le be keg 21 yms of ego (nOt relurn receipt for noodditfonal fee, present lids USPS(poabnarkerl Ced111ed Mai) receipt la Ihn . , retell associate. - Restricted delivery cervica, which provides deilvpry in,1181. addressee apef�3U0�dd btpnma, or In Use addressne'eaurlie 2arlaborir: -AduhsigneI strvlrn,which requires Me aught, Jr. Col Med Mali !lent s' poslmarflin8.11i you don't null a postmark on 0 10 t:endied Mail receipt, detach the bareotled portion el MI5 label, affix it to the maflpfeco,apply appropriate pushups, and dapaafi Ino malpiees, which 1 als5 cItfad spoof 'Firma Oris an +your ILMPOR ANT: Save lids receipt for your records. PS Form 380�, April 2015 (Reverse) PS17530-02.000.0047 .A nr m r9 ll 7017 0660 . 'osrv�e CERTIFIED MABL1'' REC.E1PT Doh? estic Mali OIlly T.� ii11l i7�', tf2ON $3 Lit iliYo''161,4 YwY'i�•�I1s 7. BIXBYt tIi' 74016{. Certified Mali Fee $3.35 xrraservices &Tees(sAackbar,eddfea '�•UII tel' ❑ Return Receipt (hardcopy) S U� ❑ Flamm Recelpt(electronic) $—Sa. 00 ❑ Cerdeed Mail Real -rioted Delivery $ _40.00 ❑ Adult Signature F1101,5rerr $ -S,�__i in —— ❑AdultSignatureRnwretseDelivery$ Postage $0.49 fatal Postagosnd Fen s t $5,59 S entra S treet andApf. lT a e Box Gyry, trate, ZlP+0- Ps Flt !1. ao0 8 ('543 �V. 02 Poaknadc Ifora 1)7/21/2(117 3,,J n30 07.9,0D- 041::) , CERT1py _ IC,® RECEIPT Or;rriesfic !Mail Drily , •jf ° 1 it iv piraffiY �l tlpn vi'si tsliylf. g)?5 A ly iYIY'.rrSItSrcrw1;v'- 1iIRON) pW 4-43$9q.., ji • I Certified Mail Foe J35 S . J_t %Ira. SeryICa3 Feet {Ch�efrboa. odd see p iaelf El Swum Receipt (hardcopy) $ �Q. �� ['Return Receipt (electronic) $ ❑Certified Mall Restricted Delivery $U • (lU ❑Adult Signature Required $ $1r1y1. tf1i rfj� ['Adult Signature Resldcted Delivery $ Postage in Teta! postage and Dees '4 Sent ro r - Nieto rnufElpl. 04Msri; 2iFe+dw (1543 (12 Postmark Here 07/21/2017 pAn_ U.S. los#a! Service:':; CERTIFIED MAIL' RECEIPT ROnestic,ail C]rll)r •Fo tnrrn;tiori; 11811clad;trei7•slfe rat•.rvv,W.ljekr0 .if77tP.yr:� DEN r-g0li#O O ,o 11 kti EL Candled Mali Fao- S $$.:r5 EklraSeNeaa.& Fens (cheek box. add feet slei CIReturn Receipt (hardcopy) ❑ Return Receipt(eleatonic) S $0 ❑ Certified Mall Restricted Delivery $ _se703— ▪ Adult Signature Requhed ilVT LL��44FF ❑ Adult Signature Restricted Delivery $ $0 .00 Poolape 5 $0.49 Total Postage ped Foos s }_ $5.59 Seat 7'o Sireei araifAjit: �)o.; G`r1y, &rofe.21°«d 0543 '02 Postmark = �� _ HerR • 0,4 07/11/2017 WitiZifa rttC 1A For; dsllvery.: rif rrriation, ITNNEGMAYA C.•` 11, Certified Mail NO $3.35 s - xIraSorvlces&Peestrlreckneir,eddiesare) 0 Return Receipt (hardcopy) $ 33 ; y El Return Receipt (electronic) $ $0.00- 1=1 Cerlined Mail Restricted Delivery $ so. C10--- ❑Adull Signature Required $ $ ri rr 00 ❑Adult Signature Restricted Delivery $ Paalepo $0.49 Total postage and Taos g $6.5 Soot To -Rieffiiind' pr: VO., Crry, Slate, 21P+401 65443 02 Postrnarit Hero 07/21/2017 07/21/2017 AI:'Ser Service" D MAIL' RECEIPT "Fol=del l"1'r ` ;t .iii»,'vlsf 1;burrvioba110'61+;ytrtv:uti(is:cci>r'- GI ir,),j .�UHC�r oN>4'�.p l i) Cerllfled 101111 Fes $3.35 ��77�� Extra Services & Fees terrace 40.1; add lee 6$�4A11]rp�pr.�7die) ❑Rerum ReceiplfhardcoP1() ❑ Return Receipt (electronic) $ $,0 00 ❑ Certified Mall Restricted Delivery 5 en R 00 ❑ Adult 61gnalure Required $ +�57 ❑ Adult Signature Restricted Delivery $ $`r 00 Footage S $1-1.49 iotct Poot°go and Fooe d $6.59 r1543 02 Posimoril 1ler° 07/21/2017 3yrrr T8 War0;1501 f: ; or7�tJ LIZ S, 'emi,3E1U ; fq.,(11 Q1 .;iz.h!.. r • 5 2a 'ui F' )1Rv4r.se'iflr inafry:ritir, OR)r. MIDLAND:, T 7;P7O2; Biermied mail serwce provides e A receipt (thls portion of the Certified Mall label), ▪ Aunfque identifier for your meigtlece. ▪ Eleclrente verification of delivery or attempted delivery. ro A record of delivery (including Me recipient's signature) that 19 retained by Urn Postal Sal vier: fora specified period. lmporfant Runrindeis: ▪ You may purchase Certified Mall service WIIh or rtmr loMcCuHiss Resources a Certified lei lntdrna,fone621 17th Street, 112155 Iv%rn, rwa Denver, CO 80293 Wulf f:arU of Certified insurance c certain Pilo u For an addil endorsement 1101 the mailpeco, you !nay request She following ser vices: - Ralurn receipt service, witch provides n recent of delivery (Mete Wog Um recipient's shgn51000). Yen can request a hardoopyretum receipt orae (decennia version. For a hardcopy 101)101100911)3, complete PS Form 3811, Dw 1.9110 Return Receipt; attach PS Foray 381 i 10 year mailpiece; tnr3 totiowing Clenemt%s: for an electronic return receipt, ace o retail associate for assistance. To receive a duplicate return recelpt tar no additional fee, present INS USPS®•po3lmarked Certified Mall receipt 1t ills retail associate. . Rendered delivery oervfcry I'd ioh prorldoc defivei11olite addra)SsseeSpecified byname, or , to the ad8ressee'sautlxul:odapanl - Adult signatures0Mca,WhlCh requites the 1 signee to be alias' 21 years Of ago (not • vlce,wh a0 1 years of I1Qe. t Lc/alba Krt. j ,t Is 1 (ouldbear a 1 rimed{ on 1 int your . , Corbfled Mall Item eta. Pod Office" for pesimer0lny1li you don't need a poslmaik on this Certified Mall recolpl, deleek Ira barcoded portion - 0f Udo affa!f to IN mallplece, apply appropriate postage, and deposit tlla mallplece. iMPOROAIthSave fills receipt far your records. • PS Form 3000, April 2015 (Remise) PSN 7050.02-000.9047 Certified Mail senfice provides s A receipt (this portion of the Certified Mail label). a A unique identifier for your mallpiece. U Electronic verification of delivery or attempted delivery. a A record of delivery pmluding the reeler ears signature) that Is relafned.by the Postal Service - for a specified period, important Reminders: e YPII may pilin' ""-'r sms..n0n L.otih FUST-1:iass101 Lupton Energy LLC or Priority.Mal a Certified mail: 2854 Elim Drive inlornalianat 0 {Ylsumnae Grand junction, CO CAV tWlll Celt1tled of Cedi1ad hi lnsureaco ca ccrtal10 Prlorll e Foran ad010410a,ene Nina wy... oedursalneat 01i.the mollpiscc,yen may 10quod the following services: • Return receipt setvicc,w11lch pieWdlls arecord 01 doliivsry (including filo recipient's stnatwe)- You can request a hardcopy return receipt or an eleciranle version, For a hardcopy return receipl, complete PS Form 3811, Domesffr, Return Recuipi; attach PS Form 3811 to your mallplece; the following benefits: for an electronic return recelpt, see a retail associate for assistance. To receive a duplicate return receipt ler no additional fee, present thls USPS® -postmen Md Certified Mail receipt to the retail associate. - Restricted delivery service, which provides , dellve(yio the addressee specified byname, or tette addressee's eulflorized agent: Mull alarmism service, Mitch requires the signee to tie:atlepd2t years of age (not Ce wfr1Ch ' Are ciao japec11Eed ked agent !Is fold hear a plark on 11 your Ccr111iod Moll 'lomat 0Post Omen- lar posh -narking. 11 goulei need a postmark ea Ibis Cerlilied Mall receipt, delach Ih0 barcoded po011o0 of Ulla label, afflx 1(10Ibe maiiplec0, apply ap1nopriate postage, and deposit Me rnaUpleco. 81501 IMPORTAII11 Save this recent far your records. PS Form 3800, April 2015 (Reverse) PSN 7530-02-000.9047 Certified Mata service provides the following benefits: ° A receipt (This portion of the Certified Mail label). for an electronic return receipt, see a retail I LI A unique Identifier for your mailpiece. associate for asslstallce,Te receive a duplicate el Electronic verification of delivery or attempted return receipt for no additional fee, presentthis delivery. o Arecord of delivery (including the recipient's slgnalure) That Is retained by the Postal Service"' for a specified period. important Reminders: e You may purchase Certified Mail service with First-ClassMalP,-First-Class Package Service". Priority Desert Part1 ers 111 ir▪ lternaliena 'Famine ci P.O. Box 3579 withCmtiffe Midland, TX 79702 of Cariilied I insurance et certain Prior e For an addili endorsenten, the following seri'Ices: - Hellen receipl0500100, which ',ravines 10 record Certified Mall (ocelpt,dela dr the barcoded portion df delivery (leciudirlg the recipient's signature), of This label, affix it to the mailpiece, apply Yalr oafl rogdseiahardeopy totem receipt Oran appropriate postage, and deposit the mallplece. electronic version. For a hardcopy return receipt, complete PS Form 3811, Domestic Return Receipt; attach PS Form 3811 to your mallplece; IMPORTAI3T: Save ibis receipt for pour records. PS Form 3800, April 2015 (Reverse) PSN 7530.02-000.0047 USPS® -postmarked Certified Mall receipt to the retail associate. - Restricted delivery service, which provides deilyyoanIo.the addressee spedf(ed by name, or le the'oddreesee's authorized egeht. • Adult signature service, which requires the signee to heal least 21 years of age (not • 1 rvice, which r years of age ; Fiiispedlled . agent (tis Mild bear a - Nark an' ht your eel 11150 mail nem ata Post Office"' for paslrrlarkfeg. If you BQ0'1 need a postmark on this 0 ED IT' m .nd r'I n -u D lti r1 D N F1J m D r1 D II -El N r1 D F` - D r•9 m rt.; D 1I D D 7017 0660 !Certified Mail Fee • J.J • 5 IQ Ile So Con cos pad- ear; eddrau Mu) ❑ Return Receipt (hardcopy) $ $0. 00 ❑ Return Receipt (electronic) 8 . ,0r�.� ❑ Certlned Mall Restricted Delivery S $ir. L+ ['Adult Signature Required S L+ ❑Aduitfiigaalura R9 10led 00110001 Postage $0.49 eta °stage and Fees 6.59 Arrest srrrf •r, , o.; orrr5V6a Wt5. CI 543 02 'Ci71.21 /20117 YIDS Ms stord, 2i°+45 agivISMMINI 4�erotrie I mart ,UF 24I6e prcAlrruUs trim; Iorlou2irrg nen F1iR ; s A receipt (this portion of the Certified Mall label), a A unique identifier for your mallpiece. to Electronic verification of delivery or attempted delivery, ® A record of delivery (intruding IN recipients signature) Ofet Is retained by the Postal Service' for a specified ported, Important Ramiaders: m You nmy puidtaoe Cerlilled Mail service with Fust•Clesa AfnB', Firer o 6trsre6ifin at rafadl. atPdorityMaiaser Rufus Craig Patch aria Kristy tee Patch for an electronic 'Mumu'Mumreceipt, see a retail associate For assisiatico.To receive aduplicate return receipt tor no additional fee, present this USPSO-postmarked Certified Mall receipt to the retail associate. - Restricted deltvelyservice, which provides dai(uery,to the ogresses speellied,hy name, or In the addressee's atri ioiiaed agent. - Adltllalga Mare service, which requires the slgnno to Nal least 21 years at age (not a Certified Mall service 1 International mall. 951 West Williams, Unit 218 33w llCodi coverage i! Fallon, NV 89406 of Certified Mall sere insurance coverage) cerlain Priority Mall 1 e For an additional fee, endorsement on the mailplece; you may moon, the following services: - Return receipt service, vfiich provides a record of delivery (Including the recipient's signature). You can request atom/copy return receipt or ern electronic version. Fara hardcopy return receipt, complete PS Form 3811, Domestic Return Receipt; attach PS Form 3811 to your mailpiece; 1MPORTAFIR Save this receipt For your retards. ' PS Farm 3000, Apd12015 (Reverse) PSN 7530.02.000.9047 'eh Igo zd fit iia postmarking. if you ddil't need a postmark on this Certified Mail receipt, detach ISa bereedod porilon of flits label, affix II 11:r the malipieco, noel/ appropriate poslapef and deposit the mallpiece. Certified Mall service provides the following benefits; A receipt {gds *keel the Cerlined Mab label). • Aunique Identifier far your malploco. ▪ Elerlrenle verification of delivery or oitempted delivery, a! A retard of delivery¢nciadfng IN recipient's signature) that is relented by flit Paalal - eryIco^' for a speelfled ponvd, fn tp orient ltsmlnclera: yea may ori: Bay Minerals LLC fast. Grassi orP,arlty.6 501 South Cherry 5t Certified Ml intermittent Denver, CO 80245 1e Insataneei wide Certifi of Certifier' insurance certain Pdo.._, •For en ark/Weal fee, end L with proper erldorsemeol o, the maliprete you may request the fallmvfng services: - Relent rarefy' 55 I a, 84111(1 prattles record of dellvory iincluding the recfp]ent's striatum). Zhu can requests hardcopyrelupR receipt or an aleslmnlc version. Fera hardcopyralum receipt, complete PS Form 3811, Vonresfic Return I(ecarAattach PS Form 3811 le your m itpfoca; for nn oioclranu rearm receipt, sec a retell 0230t(ate for assisranco.TO. receive a daphcalo return receipt tar no addidenel fee, present Ihls USP50•pes(0at0t ed Codified Mail reeedpt to IN relag associate, - Resirirded dellveryzervlce,1411118 provfdas detNet'to the addr‘essea Specified trigona or fa the addiusaea's eA borted igen - Adult signature service, which ramifies the ^"^.r.lnast21yearsofago (nal r4so,n7hrch 44 hearse/ eag hriseci agent r I fipfis Mould bear a I hnlmarh an reet, Suite 920 1510 Cemlleu v,,,, . r,_onl your Certified Mall Item al a Fast Office"fOr poshnerldng. if yid don't need pusbpadl on this Cergflod Mall receipt, detach the barcoded portion of lids lobs), affix 11 to the mallpiece, apply appropriate pestage, and deposit the mallpiece, f SPOIiTANT: Save Ihts receipt for your records, 'S Form 3000, April 2010 (Reverse) PSN 753002-000 90 47 Certified Mali service provides the following benefits; A receipt phis portion of the Codified Mall rebel). for an electronic return receipt, sea a retail o A unique ldeftlirrcrfar year maiiplece, 'madam for assistance. To receive a duplicate 2 Cie chomp vedlcailoe al d011801yor sliemptnd return receipt 10( noadd;donai her prosattlhl delivery, u A record of defiuery paeloding the rdciplanrs quarrel thous retained by lite Pastel Service"' ref specified period. Important RerGldprs; ✓ You may purchaser Certified Mail service vdllf - H,01.C18s3Matr -' -..._ ti_ ^ •cn.r n9 or Priority Oka Magic M & R LLC �eerbrfadMatf: 1720 South Bellaire Street, Ste. 1209 idfernatienal t(05ancecon d Denver, CO 80222 with of Cedllled 841 !r otlrance OW certain Pdatif' Far an ndb is endorsement On lira mai/piece, you troy,cyv.v, the fallowing eorvlOn: • news recelp Service, Mkt provides record of delivery tinctudfng the ree(ptem a signature). Yhu can regaesta hardcopy return racefplaran electronicverefen, taro hardcopy return rsseflrt, complete PSFenn 381T,rroraoli Rehm, RaccipFottadr 58 term 3811 10 'aur megp(ece; IPIPORTA rts save this receipt for war retards. i Form 3800, Apri12015 (Reverse) PSN 7630 02-000-9047 dsPse.poslmarked Cedfgad Mail rdoelpt lathe retail associate. Resldcted delivery service, which provides dorivory lo pin addressee spudfipd by game, or to the oddrOlo,o s authorized agent - Adel Slgnaittreservida,v'h(c11 requires the 1 signer] to beat least -21 years elago {not rfratihle el retail}, •;o,whfcll lrsofago . specified • itid agent i 'Act boaca -tun. )your poslmarkfai.lryon'don'Ineed apostmark an Ihfs Certified Mall receipt, d0tech IJIy bartudedjrmdan Milts label, affix II lo ilia maiiplece, apply appmprlato postage, erattlapasft the mallpiece. 4. m -13 nJ ri l=1 rR D D ..0 D N D N N Er Cp m ro ru D8 D rl D D D 0 ..0 D $�i 5 rrl ▪ sant 7o 1� drier ilii fpC-k, ar7 rI' , 'vista ervlce CERTIFIED MAIL° RECEIPT ,Darm .slic I)7aif Or/ fit r dl livery iriforriiatfori, V101f Ottr 1 'e]3 1� '�li yrvrv,rrsps FALLS > i/V :$9tt1pt„ia i ` Certified Mall FOS $3 •..Tor 5 extra Sarvlces & Fees (61401ba., adeno ale] ❑Return F1eoe tpiarotopyt i!+. _�, ❑ Return Receipt (electronic) $--10.00 ❑ Certified Man Restricted Delivery 5 $I ❑ Adult Signature Required 5 $i� .l_tf� ['Adult Signature Restricted De1Nery 5 Posinge S $0.49 'Total Postage and nags 9 66 5 r senna ' 7.41267/1 Strciuf iiri Ap„ f: ydv� 0543 02 `;Postmark Here- . - •. 07/21/2017 drily; Stege re, 71+4 fiair U.S. Postal Service'"` CRTIFI ED M A I L° RECEIPT iii?91 y$i t Qniy iellift9 + Iaj*mgtlor1, visit oarwe1site„pt.,vii5rusps isti / 1 i 1 Cmllned Mall Fee �r J1 m Er m IL rR D r-9 D 0 O D D N r9 acme' armiAp[. a., Crit' )are, 28P#42 Extra Services & Pees rrrar01W, sd4lres, 7ru3 levo) ❑ Reim Receipt (hardcopy) $, �1, fit__ ❑ Return Receipt (electronic) 5 10 _ 00 ❑ Certified Mali Restricted Delivery 8 _$0 .. 00 ❑ Adult Signature Required 8 $il.00--- ❑/idul1SrgnaturoResldcred0e ocry 8 Postage 5 $I_I.49 Tato1 Postage and Foes [1143 . 02 e obtrnerir utero ��11r 67/21 /2017'. adz '.U$, -Postal Service' CERTIFIED MAIL® RECEIPT .;KaXyle.l.. bjfj]aii j11 011.31,11L.,,0 ts 4at.otty; asps, grli 4 , :0' DNiVEI nf- e0, -7 Certilled Maii Pea. S _/,') afro Vory(eeaa Fera (o8V6kb¢y odd fos$, 0pp(ater ❑ Return Receipt (hardcopy) $ ❑ Return Receipt (eiecironlc) 5 $ a flu ❑ Certified Mall Restricted Delivery S ❑ Adult Signalure Required 5 $4.00 --- ❑ Advil SignaaoResl,etedDelivery 8 Paalage 5 $11.49 Total Postage and Pig. . S9 Sent To I '1. 054 G1 imark ere 02 !711,1. 07121121117 kJ w.Wa crrrC4a vvrcll 100[d1C(: proV6cles the TolIowing benefits: a A receipt (tilts potline of IIIc Certified Mall label). for an electronic return receipt, see a retell a A unique identifier for your mailpiece. associate far assistance. To receive a duplicate 1a Electronic Wilms/Ma of delivery er attempted velum receipt fur nu retrial's' int foe,prnerd Iliba • delivery. USPSWposlmerked Certified Mall receipt to lire a A record of delivery 594111din5 the recipient's retell associate, 51500iine) that is retained by 810 Poelel Swvlun- Rallulcled dollvery ralvicn, edelch provide'. for a specified period, deiivaryieitho eddressn speedied by name, fir 1olli adtfrossee'S earn lied egCrll: ' fnlpdrfdnt Ragdadri r: - Adrift sigmlure service, which requires Ilia Yat' maypurclieseCerlined faith service with signet, to heal least 21 years of age (not First -Class Mall? First•C ase Pacisage Soodoe.• . - available at reran). orPriddry'Mdla Bay Energy Partners LLC n Certitied!half el irllernalidiuillm 1512 La rimer Street, Suite 250 u 1110141310 C0yef with fledified M Denver, CO 80202 of Codified Mai Insurance cove certain Priority a For ars eddrnohr endorsement m- . the fallowing services: - Return receipt service, which provides a mond of delivery (kisiuding ilio recipient's Signorine), You can requ04 a hardcopy return receipt or an eieclranic.rers)cn. for Iraldcopy relum receipt, complete PS Form 3811, Domestic Return Receipt; attach PS Fonn 3811 to your mailpiece; IMPORTA tin Save this receipt for yaur records. PS Form 3800, April 2015 (Reverse) PSN 7530-02-000-9047 F, 'ankh IS ol age pacified Id agent d boar a irk on - Pur postmarking. ff-you don't need a pastmark oR Ills Certified Moll receipt, detach Ile harceded portion of Ws label, affix f1 to ISa mailpiece, apply appropriate postage, and deposit the mallpieco. Certified Mail service provides the following benefits: for nn electronic mann receipt, sea a retail associate for assistance. To receive aduplicate return receipt for RD additional fee, present this USPSi•peelmarked Certrtied Mail receipt to this Weil associate. _ - Restricted derveryservite, Mich provides • delivery falba a40 res rerraXei{Md ki flame, or to Ilse nddressoe's aullionteil 011001, - Adult signature service, which requires the plane* la he at f0a5121 years er age foot a Areerdpt (this porlfnn rdthe Certified Maillabeq. o Aundque Identifier for your mailpiece, a Electrarlle verification of delivery or attempted delivery. a Aruserd of delivery (fndodinp the recipient's signature) that Is retained by the Festal Service'" ter a specified purled. Ilnporfanf Reminders: you May pllh'I• - .••••_.....-... „glh ETOt•CrassME Devra L. Altman codified Mei/ 2020 East 4th Ave e Codified Mair lnlenra0onalr Denver COR Insure/Me cot , 80208 mu' Certified of Certified N lnsuranca co certain Priori. 0 for an addlflaasrl feu, end Min a pruner endorsement an the rnailaleoe, yen may request the following services; - R011lm receipt SDNICO. which provides a retard of delrrery (Including tiro recipients Signature). Yee can request a hardcopy return receipt orsn oleetronrc version Fara hardcopy relum receipt, complete PS Corm nit 0omasflcRefute Receipt noel' P5 Farm 0811 favour manpleco; IMPORTANT: Savo this receipt for your records. PS Form 3800, April 2515 (Reverse) PSN 7530.02-000.9047 ice, wild )ars Mugs specified god agent Is I , fi +old hear malls on al -tilled Malt item sla,Peat Office"for ,".. postmarking. Iyou d Ai l need a postmark en }!rte ' Certified Mali receipt, detach the balroded parllen al this label, atlix it to the mallpdoca, apply appropriate postage, and deposrl the mailplece. Certified Mail service provides the following benefits: a A receipt (this portion of the Certified Mail label). is A unique identifier for your mailpiece. ® Electronic verification of delivery or attempted • delivery. a Ameard of delivery Occluding the recipient's Sfgnalero) that is reloined fly the Pas lal Service' fr r a speehfed period. inporlarff Rsrnlrlders: a You may pwpha2u f Bay LLC Firer -01m Mail? 0 orPriorigrlIell"s0r 1512 Larimer Street, Suite 150 a Certified Malt sarvir €lltematiarlaf mall. Denver, CO 80202 a Insurance Grammar with Cslurled reg of Certified Mail se Insurance coverag certain Priority Mat ,. ;eara Far an additional fee, andivFfh a properthis Certified lteit receipt. prem Jon endorsement on the dlallpiace,'you may request Corned Mall item al a Post Doke -for Iho following services: posimerkirefl you Orel need a postmark on lilts - 1.Etvm racelpt service,10111111provides a rncoiil of de0ve 1n0111dk the foo ien(s sl nalore , l his Mai! receipt, thedet Me ha, apply portion ryt � p 8 ) al this lnbei afros It to Ifle ma8pfeco, apply You can request a Ilardrepy relnm receipt arca appropriate postage, and deposit the mailpiece. eleolronis version. Fare hardtop; rattan receipt, Complete PS FOrn1 3819, D4masficRefrrrn Retrad-altSdi PS Form' 3811 to your nlaOpiece; IMPORTANT: save this receipt for your records. PS Form 3800, April 2015 (Reverse)P214 7530-02-000-0047 for an eieaftOo c 101190 reealpi, sea a relall associate for assistance lb receive a duplicate rearm receipt for no additionai fee, present [hi,' USPSID•postme rked Certified Mall reeeipLie the . 1 raid/associate • - Reetrieted delivery service, %/dell pinnldee denoorylo-u1e ad1fR18se specified byname, or • to His addresarr eAaltiorited'ageht: Adult srynaturastoke, which requires the I ..—..a7.119 •b^n: til anti fnOt filch 1 ago • (ed . gent m N m • ri D CD D CI e'en' jaUlAtL�`' RECE bri; visit 01,0'.. /sbs)Ie'et 9' /Wes v :;triad 0ENVEi7 ► c0 s _, U (' c;entrlad 12a11 Fee at - DP430314 €astir redo, ofd At, dna) Return Recolpt(hardoapy) S . 1 ❑ Retum Receipt (electronic) $ SCL00 ❑ Certified Mall RoabiutoodLlellvery 2-4 _ ❑Adr,ll Wu nal en l0e11dm0 A i43.00 0 El Mail Mgr -return Restricted Delivery $ V4r Postage 80.49 Total Pootage 04051 Fees $ 86.59 r- 1-9 D 11'- N 0543 02 Pos(rnark �1II�°r° r ? 00A/2017 Soot 81= o afanTN- ur i ser cify, $1Afe, 2']144 -Rtzttnti; n �)rR�cV rE'F: Av.PG;••:C'0004fikk9at7..:. `ec.flrr5er.ar 14-1:411-0 61.0411 .ejy f1'11P 1 a ioY3i:: Ysi _ig$ 3isite_?ai. +w?!�ys 'sr 41�I ``a # DENVEfc r :.:C0' it 1. Coddled Mall re. $3.35 Extra ..BN ce5 & ed5 (e0oek loom, ado, rcnglipprpt+dele) gndllgp Receipt (hardcopy) S- UJsa UU11`11 ❑ Retum Receipt (electronic) ❑ Certified Mall ReStricled Delivery $ V), III) ❑ Adult Signature Required $ 80a00 ❑ Adult Slgnalure Restricted Delivery 2 • Jff P%Singe r-�111 ' 80.49 s07/21/2017 •'1 001 .r9 !)'J'/ s $11.1111 0543 02 Postmark Here rR CI D D ..0 . N ✓ a N Sant To Sweet--; •r.: 1t,,OYPO ay, $fate, 2IF#4° SFri[{JIIF88 WEIREM ap$a2•d0. '00 15,,r ' (gip U.S. Postai Service' CERTIFIED MAIL`'` RECEIPT ❑ornr!Strc Meiji 01210', For rfr-1R•or.)r in10.170iiop, v)s19.l:ur y'1ebpfte al uvae.Y, asps: riOJlt DENS T1-•C0j °10 Codified Man Foe 83. 6.1 S ExtraYRes &Net Cox. Med lav raj ❑ Holum Receipt (hardcopy)) S ❑ Return Receipt (electronic) $ 80 - 00 - ❑ 00,011 ed Mail Restricted Delivery S._114.410 ❑ Adult Signature Required 8 ___g_ • ['Adult Signature Restricted DNWO ry 8 Poslago S 80.49 Tow PDS Ipso and Foes r 86.59 Sent To tiraniandA oi7'ti.ok 11,11 '1 1'- 0543 02 r, merit ��f �Heie • Pr 07/2./2017 remotes 'wail service provides me rouowing l7enenitS: o A receipt (this portion of tha Certified Mall label). a A unique Identifier for your mallplece. ea. Electronic verification of delivery or attempted delivery. Id A record of delivery (Including the recipient's signature) that Is retained by the Postal Service"' for a specified period. Important Reml - eYou may purchr Left Hand Resources LLC ) First -Class Mail 1720 South Bellaire Street, Ste. 1209 is,whlcll or Priority Mail' lage pecllled (d agent Is Ild bears USPS pesimadf. if you WOum hire a posmiarkan this Certified Mall l receipt, please present your Certified Mali dem pt a Post aigca'" for paslmarWng. if y&u don't need a poshnark on this Ceriiflsd Mail receipt, detach the barcoded portion of this label, affix ii to the mallplece, apply eppropdale postage, and deposit the mallplece. for an electronic retum receipt, see a retail associate for asslstance.To recelve a duplicate return receipt for no additional fee, present this USPS/0-postmarked Certified Mall receipt to the retell ossoclate. - Restricted delivery service. which provfdas delkery'iq•111e addressee speciged by name, or to the addmcsee:e authorized agent.. a Carolled Mail 91 Denver, CO 80222 International m 0 Insurance cove with Certified h of Certified Ma Insurance cove cerlaln Priority Mail items. ® For an additionaliee, and wilt a proper endorsement ori the malipleca, you may request the fallowing services: - Return receipt service, which provides a record of delivery (including the recipient's signature). You can request a hardcopy return receipt lir an electronic version. For a hardcopy return receipt, complete PS Farm 3811, Domestic Return Receipt; attach PS Form 3811 to your mallplece; IMPORTAJIT) Save Ns receipt for your records. PS Form 3800, April 2015 (Reverse) PSN 7530.02-000-9047 Certified Mail service provides the following benefits: e A receipt (this portion of the Certified Mall label). for an electronic return receipt, see a retail o A unique identifier for your mallplece. associate for asslstance.To receive a duplicate o Electronic verification of delivery or attempted return receipt for no additional tee, preseet this delivery. o A record of delivery (Including the recipient's signature) that is reialned by the Postal Service' for a specified period. Important Reminders: w You may pGchas9:Certilled Malt service with Frer•Class Mali" -eeef•cress Package S4reiee°, , -- available at retail). orPriority Mar Retova Resources LLC denverysent°.wirldi e Cerllged Mail E 187 lmof age iniernatlonaln South Reflait'e Street, Ste. 900 6pecdled ®Insurance cove Q ri VE r egont with COW , COCC' 80222 of Coaled MI Is Insurance cov 1Id bear a certain Pdorit nark on ® For an addlllo t your endorsement'one,v,,,.,, the following services: postmareiag. n you mo, _ irk on this - Return receipt service, which provides a record Certified Mall receipt, detach the barcoded portion of delivery (Including the recipient's signature). of this label, affix it 10 the mallplece, apply You can request a hardcopy return receipt or an appropriate postage, and deposit the mallpiece. electronic version. For a hardcopy return recelpl, complete PS Form 3811, Domestic Return Receipt; attach PS Form 3811 to your mallplece; IMPORTANT: Sane this receipt for your records. PS Form 3800, April 2015 (Reverse) PSN 7580.02-000.8047 Certified Mail service provides the following benefits: el A receipt (this portion of the Certified Mall label). el A unique Identifier for your mallplece. ea Electronic verification of delivery or attempted delivery. a Areoerd Of delivery (including the recipient's slgrlatuet) that is retained by the Postal Service' for a specified period. Important Reminders: ® You may purchase Certified Mail service with First -Class htlrlEa F1rat-pass Package Service, or Pdonti Ma"' ®Certified Mal Next Generation LLC international m Insurance ca co 714 Pontiac Street wilhCertmed Denver, CO 80220 of Certified M Insurance coo certain Prloril) El Foran addi[iol endorsements __•• Me following services: - nature receipt aervke,wlnich provides a record of delivery (elcladprg file reclpieat'aelenatwc). You carr request o hardcopy Settee receipt erall eleelrerlic version, For a hardcopy return receipt. complete PS Form 3811, Oswego Rehm Receipt; attach PS Form 3811 to your maiipiece; IMPORTANT: Save this receipt for your records. PS Form 3800, Apd12015 (Reverse) PSN 7530.02-000-9047 USPS® -postmarked Certified Mall rceoipt to the retail associate. - Restricted delivery service, which provides - delfvery lathe eddreesse speckleel hy,name, or to tlid'eddreasee sauiharized agent. -- - Adult signature service, which requires the slgnee to beat least 21 years of age (not far An electronic return receipt, sea afolag essoclale for assisfance,TO receive alloy/oak) return receipt for no addigaaal fes, present Ihfa ' USPS®•postmalkod Certified Mag receipt to the retail associate. - Restricted delivery servlco,wlrlc r plovkles delheoryeo the add ossee seed/led by name, or to theaddfe3$oeralantiteliter agent: • - Adult signature service, which requires the slgnee to be at least2l years of aae (not 4lee,4Alich ears Of age i specified ked agent lis �lld bear lark on wrunce Mail item al a Post Oka" for po11maeking (f you dant need u postmark on Ihle Cedgied Mall receipt,detadl Ihe halcedod portlee shills fabol,elllx It to the mallplece, apply approprlale postage, and deposit the matiplece. u-' Lf1 co m -0 ru r9 D rI D D .A .n D N r� 1. - .os a ervice CERTIFIED MAIL° RECEIPT L Domestic Mall Only Poi delivery urforrnatlon, visit our website at www.u,ps.ro ar'''. - A (1. cr-. Certified Mali Fra $3.3r 0 t.2 7.5 Extra Service5-a Fee3 01100 11014 add loo $ iivryUU ero ❑ Return Snell! (hardcopy) ❑ Return Receipt (electronic) $ $0.00 ❑ Certified Mag Restricted Delivery $ 50.0��0,y ❑ Adult Signature Required $ $0.00 ❑Adult Slgnalure Restricted Deevary $ Postage S $0.49 m .1 ru rI D D D -o TO tel Postage and s F �'.`r9 0543 02 r/'rsastmark C ,f% Heti] 07/21/2017 Seal m 1}r 3iivbiairdApi 0.., car eti dry date, .21F'+44, PS Form 3800, April 2015 PSN75ap-02-aoo-9047 See tlrwerss:.rer Inslrturt+.orl U.S. Postal ServiceTM CERTIFIED MAIL° RECEIPT l Domestic Mail Only Far Aeliyery intorrn anon, vlieets lar website nt w1V1v.trs(15. COM 9, DEr ri t t C9.; .$07 i! A !fi Certified Mall Fee $3.35 Extra Services & Fees &fox -kink odd ree ,� dare) ❑ Return Receipt (hardcopy) $ Ulll �,I�1 ❑ Return Receipt (eleclronio) $ $0-00 - ❑ Certified Mall Restricted Delivery $ $0. 00 ❑Adult Slgnalure Required $ $0.00 ❑ Adult Signature Restricted DulIVery $ 51 Postage $0.49 Tatar Postage and Fees $6 59 N- Senl Tb • SlieoianilAji�4 or Ci ox u1 m co m -ru II 1-9 O D .11 -D N '-9 D N &tete, 2 4:30(-- 0543 02 Postmark Here 1 r i at. 07/21/2017 • T-e6-5a1AUL I'S Form 3000e.April 2015 PSN7630-(12-00D-9047See Reverse for l:r•;Iry tion U.S. Postal Service' CERTIFIED MAIL° RECEIPT Domestic Mail Only Cerlllfed Mail Fee rr xlra SarvFces R. Fees {cried. box add reads pr7G op'rWO ❑ Relum Receipt (hardcopy) S ❑ Return Receipt (eleclmnlo) S 50.00 ❑ Cedlfed Mall Restricted Delivery $ 0 0 CAW! Signature Restricted Dellvery $ 50.1)0 $3.35 ['Adult Slgnalure Requlred 8 Postage $ Total Postage and Fees 50.49 s t I $6.5 Sant T .911'98I and�pl 0543 02 Postmark Here 07/21/2017 tierciTlef.T malt SePviae prowlaeS Elie T®11Owing 1ienentstl re A receipt (111s portion of the Certified Mall label). for an electronic return receipt, coo a rstall re A unique Identifier for your mailpiece. associate for assistance, To receive a duplicate return for noedrfiflonplfee,presentthis a Electronic vedficallon of delivery or attempted � delivery. ▪ A record of delivery (incfading the recipient's sIpnature)thatIsielafuodby1110Nall 3M/ice' fora specified period. lorputhuillfgrnLrri rs: N Y0,1 may perrhar^:r._'--;r.n Alen setvtea With F6rs[-crasshtah MIrnointe LLC or PrferftYIeidl' E, which u Certified Mad s, r•O• Box 3358 mar ago Intemaifenel m �Ped(0d G there icecove i riglewoodl, CO $0155 d agent with Certified 1 of Codified Ma inserancecola - Idbear a certain Merit+) - arfton Firer an addidonel rl e, nee wi Y r o p• . .your oodolsement on die malfd?oce, Yoe may ro40e5l Cerffffed Mall um at RNA Omce"'tor lhefollmv1afl services: postmarking. If You don't need a posonark011 tide - Rolm receipt service, which providesa record Cairn e l Mad reoefpl,delech the barcoded pardon of do111(o1y (111010b1Irlp 1110 reciPienasignature). of this Iahel, altfx It to the mallpiece; apply You Can request altsrdcopy return receipt or an appropriate postage, and deposit the mailpiece. electronic version. Fora hardcopy Weer receipt, eemplele PS Form 9811 Peniesdu Return feceiai aitachPSForm3811 to your mailpiece; IMPORTAIIT1Save this receipt far your records. PS Form $8013, April 2015 (Reverse) PSN 7530-02.000.9047 USPSCkt.I100i larked Certified Mail receipt to the retail associate, - Re. tricled delivery a0Rd00, which prov)dee dolly:94 tolhd addreasegsitOiliittby:pamo,or to the addressee's adode0d Spent. - Melt01gna1310 cervlue, w111011 mulles iltd shines to be al !east 2f years of age (not Certified Mail service provides the following benefits: el A receipt (Ibis portion of the Certified Mall label). e A Unlquo Identifier for your mailpiece, . ® Electronic verification of delivery or attempted delivery, a A record of delivery (including the recipient's signature) that is retained by Me Postal Service' far a specified period. for an electronic relum receipt, see a retail associate forassiatenco.To receive a duplicate relum receipt for no additional fee, present this USPSee-postmarked Certified Mall receipt to the retail associate. - Restricted delivery service, which provides delivettollhnoddre segepeev1Rodbyname,or to the aadressee's'uuihedted'agerit,, Important Reminders; - Adult signature seryl ce, which requires the You may pdrChase Certified Mali service with slgnee to by at €opet2l years of ay0 (cot Flrsl•ClassMall Richard Altman & Company arf1rlorflyrlrialF 6CwtllledMslie 1801 Broadway f#315 Inieroalroeui m elnsuranceWve Denver, CO 80202 with Csrfllind 1 of Certified Me insurance cove certain Huth e For an addlgoge, ,,,.,......�_ . endorsement on the mallpteo9, you may request the following services: - Return receipt service, which provides a record of delivery (Including the recipient's signature). You can request a hardcopy return receipt or an electronic version. Far a hardcopy relum receipt, complete PS Form 3811, Domestic Return Receipt; attach PS Form 3011 10 your mallpiece; Ceratleoreau.uer„a. , postmarking. If you don't need a postmark on this Certified Mall receipt, detach the barcoded portion of this label, affix it to the mailpiece, apply appropriate postage, and deposit the mallpiece. e, which pot ago ipgdfad zd Mehl Is Ild hear a lark on !your IFRPORTAIIT Save lifts receipt for your records. PS Fon 3800, April 2015 (Reverse) PSN 7530.02.000-9047 Cerrtified Mail service provides a A receipt (thls porton of the Certified Mall label). el A unique identifier for your maiiplece. e. Electronic verification of delivery or attempted delivery. s A record of delivery (Including the recipient's signature) that 10 retained by lhe Postal Service' for a specified period. the following benefits: for an electronic return receipt, see a retail associate for assistance. To recelve a duplicate return receipt for no additional fee, present this USPS® -postmarked Certified Mail receipt to the retail associate. - Restricted de8vory servfcc, w11(•ch provides delivery(Tire oddrOssea apfemed,ifl1tne, or to the addressee's authorized agent. Important Reminders: - Adult signature service, which requires the lbu maypurchaao.CorRtiod IAallsravko with sign to beat least 21 years of age (not First-Clas6Mail2 re.1-11eabortnnnCervirea_ - , availahleatratalh- or Pdmiiyniall* Snyder Oil yl, which e certified Mall se rs of age Intemalionalmr1560 Broadway, Suite 2090 reeifled 1 agent iltsuraricecover Denver CO 80202 Cor ramedfid r of Certified Mai insurance cove certain Priority I ® Foran addlfonl endorsement on me maeplecv, yep n,ay ,"o". the following services: - Fielum receipt service, which provides a record of delivery (Including the recipient's signature). You can request a hardcopy return receipt or an electronic version, For a hardcopy return receipt, complete PS Form 3811, DomesdcRerun) Receiphallaclr PS Form 3011 to yourmailplece; imponuN'h Save lids receipt for your records, , PS Form 3600, April 2015 (Reverse) PSN 7530.02.000.9047 1bear a 1 rk on dour postmarking. II yod don't need a postmark on this • Certified Mall receipt, detach the barcoded portion ' of this label, affix it to the mailpiece, apply appropriate postage, and deposit the mailpiece. - - 1411 m nJ co m .11 ru rc r-1 0 0 0 O -a 0 N rR 0 N fu 0 ..0 ru - rR 0 1-i 0 0 0 II ..0 ..0 0 r- 1-9 r1 0 N 0660 0001 0126 N ra 0 N • �jr 5ur-W '1010 fr tiarrf r i;if6 Ef$9Q(jr'-CD180f5 I f1 is 1.1 \._ 7 li Certified Mad Ice '. r 5 S. E%Ira SnrvlCea & Fees perk herr. ariafeo arep ❑ Return Receipt (liardcopy) 5, ❑ Return Receipt (electronic) $ ❑Certified Moll Restricted Delivery $ ❑ Adult Signature Requhed $ U Adult Signature Restricted DelNcry $ 568L' tcu.u0 $0.00 $01.00 Postage 11 $0.49 Tote! Postage and FOOS $ 1n $6.59 0543 02 Poale:ark Here • OL$12fl sora if J Vieanrljflrir:7ila,lF i f 1t', $foie; A:4 4Z' i•'u.;, nig-'•r"°it t: U,S. Postal Servicem CERTIFIED MAIL') RECEIPT DrirggstJp 17aJi. Only . -oro` '?ry"rijprrnati.n -visit 0111 vitt ,s teal •ev tee/ ps.coe71°:_ Di:[v ,1i t3I t 01017 11 A 11... UJ r r Certified (Orli! Fee $ $3.35 cel tx1ra Ss vT U eea(cheekbow eddlaeds5 pret ❑Froxun I{ecvlpt (hardcopy) $ $0.-1.11) ❑ Return Receipt (electronics) $ ❑ Certified Mall Restricted Delivery $ 1. 0 ❑ Adult Signature Required $ $0.00 ❑ Adult Signature Restricted Delivery $ L' pomp $0.49 lore) Postage end Fees 01543 02 -• Postmark_ Here 07/21/2017 y, dare, 2(Ped b an.1 t 4jaul4O Ftil c7iii...tniaf Iviifw s'�_ � /$� Tie t'f1 t� rO iI • 1j1 E• 1 ll,-', !1 f%1� Certified kW' Fee $'1.35 01543 42 Extra Selvlces & Fees &beckbnw add respaA7ivtlare 02 ❑ Return Receipt (hardcopy) ❑ Return Receipt (electronic) S-ewlD_ ti.g` postmark ❑ Certined Mall Redacted Delivery s __ � {�_ ,. Here ['Adult Signature Required $ I . 00 •'`_ - DMA Signature Restricted Delivery 5 f •: ' Postage total Postage andFsp.59 Y+p Seal TO f (-1 $[reaF lino( . kik+., ni (j��� $0.49 �7ty'''''', ITAt'!r'' 07/21/2017 MU. IaRMW 6Np�h c -i i.3ngl;.:(10 :! A lecelp1 phis porliesof tilafartifed Moil label). A unique identifier for your nlahpleco. u.Electronic vedlicelion dalivwy orallenlpld dolvory. n A record o! delivery (Ihctudfng the rccfplcrll's ofgmtluro) !halls retained by the Pedal Service" for aspecified meld. foranokra-onto relum ocelot, sea a Feld associate 1eras01s18nc0,T11 rococo dupittasto micro receipt ler RD additional lac, presontUds USPSer-poslmadlod Certified Mali reeelpt to 1110 retail associate, Remitted delivery service, with molts deliveryta(rip addressee specified by. mime, or to the addressees authorized agent, f1r11fOriRfltliarrllflflaT.S; - Aduri sIjjoobna rhnvk:e,wldeli aware; 111' 1 d you may porch^F^ renitled Mail sorvko 101113 signee be at feast 2.1 years of age (not nrst•Classla; HOFFME1STER, HAROLb F & DEANNA M ozsshlCh , n CodifiedlMali 232 326 COUNTY RD rntemafoaal SILT CD 81652 4 81st/rake CO' wish Certifier of Certified h Insurance or certain Prior For anaddilonarisu endorsement en tha m311place, you may request the following services; - Return receipt service, which provides a record of delivery (Including the recipient's signature). You can request a hardcopy return receipt of en electronic version. For a hardcopy return receipt, complete PS Form 3811, Domestic Return t}ars of age ; ter: d agent Is Odra edhl bear a iraarleon ntyour • Cerb8odMan gout u!ur�r ...._ paatmarkrng:If you.den't need n paslmadi on this Cerlirled blaU reoelpt, detach the barcoded padien of Olin IahW, agile R to the maliptecea}1}p1y appwpdafe postage, and deposit the m0lrplece. Receipt; attach PS Form 3811 to your mallplece; iMPORTA1NT: Save tuts receipt far your records, PS Form 3800, April 2015 (Reverse) PSN 7530.02.000.9047 •.f • Certified Mail service provides the following benefits: e A receipt (ibis portio rel Oat Caddied Mailfor an electronic return receipt, sea a Ida rr A unique (demt]Rer for ywum811place. associate For 'resistance.To receive a depurate n Elechanic verification of delivery or attempted return receipt fo( no additional lee, praaenl 1610 cfe1{vely. MPS& postmarked Cerlifmd MSH race+(Zito the A record of delivery (hududlog the reciplant's felon assn ]late. signature) Ulat la 101311 ad by iso Pesti Service' liastricicd degv6lyservica,whlcll plovldes for o specified pelted. delivery loth d asg�p@aspnclflod by pome, ar (0!he addl rauRfart:edaj3adl. 1111parl1Rf Ronninrinr.Q: melte ",ro comb,. euhl.t rnnrd0AC the a You may {raref)arfl-1OMPSON, BRENT MYERS SR & BRENT Flest-Class4gail''Ml:RS 11 • or Priority Maine : V+hlcil I ooCertified Mall sail380331 COUNTY RD 1olage inlernaheranal4 1LT CO 81652 reified I 811001 o with ocoy vli Wilfred Ail: 01 Ce11lnedMail I fnsnrenr8 coven ibeer a 0et191n Priellly fid,.,.,.,,,,,.. Dan Imo edrnsnyw,eeuuru hew • pwoirolli0rr III For enaridity! lee, mid while peeper 1111: Certified Mall receipt, please present yell' endorsomerltori the rndl(ploee,y¢a may request Codified Mall Ram ata Post Otfico'" for the following se vicasi postmarking:lfyeu doff I deed aFramer k en Mrs - Mum receipt service, which provides record Certified Melt receipt, detach the barcoded portion of delivery(Including the re1a(d0nl'safgnaturo), of Mislabel, affix 8la the Inallplece,apply Ulf Cir request a llankopy retool rocelpt er011 appropriate postage, and deposit the malfplere. elesirwdeversian, For a hardcopy relemreceipt, complete PS Form 3011, 008108 k Return Reen{ptretlach PS Form 3811 to your mallplece; IMPORTANT: Save this receipt for your records. PS Form 3800, April 2015(19009100)195047530-00-0009047 Certified Mail service provides a A receipt (This portion of the Certified Mali label). m A unique Identifier for your mallplece. • Electronic rerllicallarr or (laaveryaretiempled delivery, w A rseold o! delivery (lncludfog The recipient's sinn3hire) that is retakted by Ilea Postal Service' 10ra specified period. fmpartnrrt fter+ll+rrlars: u Youicily lIiAAj1ltivmAN MICHAEL Flisl•CfaC orFY64 4359 331 COUNTY RD cooed TILT CO 81652 lnleraalic 11 lnsteana with Cad of Carta inauranc cerialn F u For en oddillonol fee, andwlnl a 11r0lrar endorsement on Ma mellpicce, you may request l to following cervi AS: Rehire receipt service, :filch prandos a record o1 delivery ((rcbdog hie recipient's signature). You can roquseta hardcopy return receipt Or en elecnordo vorston. For a hardcopy Mum meet!, complete PS Form 3811, Domestic Return Receipt; attach PS Form 3811 to your mailpiece; the following benefits: for an electronic return receipt, see a retail associate for assistance. To receive a duplicate rolum receipt far no additional fee, present this OSPS05•poslmarked Certified Mail receipt to the retell associate. - Restricted delivery service, With provides delivery 1011e addressee specified hyaline, er to the addressee's au!h0r)3Ed agent. - Adult signature service, tyhich esquires Ilia skmee la be a! 6s421 years of ago (roll S & KAREN R 3erv180, WW1. !1 years 01 refile Wee specified • Uiorixed agent ' Ample; ;Ishould1rar•a-• trademark 001 X05001 your C▪ erliRRed Mall close a! a P101 anlce'" ler pestle/kap. If you don'l need a posultalk ort this Ce1l111e4 Mail receipt, dela eh the harcadail pnnfon al Oda label, affix it to 1110 mnilpl080, npply appreprlete posteoe. a nor deposit lha rcalrplece- IMPORTANT: Son Irds sou lilt for your records. PS Form 3300, April 2015 (Reverse) PSN 7530.02.0009047 1 C -V1 m iT m r9 I1 m —o ru r9 O r -R 0 O 11 -u I: pC_IT[FIED MAIL RECEIPT ,,boxn. §,tvc mail Only. Certified Moil Fee P•JJ s $2.75 Extre.Sarvi1oes$ Pees (crrccrravr, add kof mecxcyerey ❑Return Receipt (hardcopy) $ d94r-',,.•,.."--' ❑Return Receipt (electronic) S._SIr yi-: DtI `" ❑ Coddled Mail Restricted Delivery 6' .....0. 'J �+lY ['Adult Signature Required S ____C1— 0Adun&gnalm ResIrlcled Delivery S Postage S $11.49 Total Po imago and;eg' 59 Sant To Reeve an tirKgate, 2!Ara.3; Postmark Hera O7i'121 /2017 'P5;'F,•pr(D36[Ipu'� .1d: � iii�tre: ; U.S. Postal' Servic?h` CERTIFIED MA1L1 RECEIPT Do)Plestic Only - joridr 11141•yfirtfi tor" tilRtl4,00:3t o1{r: uiitv,li,':n1;ivv.'ry urpr.gonhi'_ • LTA a t t� i Certified h0l=oa S $3.35 =xlr2 ry ces sea fcoaca bar, add ltd Noy ❑Rosin Receipt (he8capy) S ❑ Return Receipt (electronic) 8_1(4_00_ ❑ Cerr10,9 iloOReshlcted Delivery • S 00_ ▪ Slgnalure Required 6 ❑Adult Signature ResIrlcled Delivery Sfir+ e-00-7 Poslage $0.49 Tole! Postage and Fees s 9x.59 Nr9 Sent o Nirvar and W. info., or)r G}Ty, Sra)a. ,1.4 C 0 V FA i I )11 0543 U2 Postmark Here U.S. Postal Servicer' CERTIFIED MAIL' RECEIPT Dornesloc idlaif.Only . Fax rlolivory rritarrtta1Iiir i 11 t C811t11odMall Fee $3.35 S e7wi Extra Services Fees (sImeS oat add 1pesirptitNo1 ❑ Return Receipt (hardcopy) 9 ❑Return Receipt (electronic) S $0.8° ❑ Cerlieed Mali Restricted Delivery 6 $0.00 ['Adult Signature Required 6 $0.00D Adult Slgnalure Restricted Delivery $ Postage $0.49 Thielfi. 9 8 Soni To Street 10011i°F Ci6;;O7ai-a,- ifr+de r I 05143 Postmark • Here 02 '37/21/2017 x Mid 117052M4. eeUrEl1Etna 0011011�C:fF010i0 F.;rE)UI(bes Tgla Wilowi 19 Variants: ra A receipt (tills portion of the Certified Mall label). e A unique Identifier for your meilpiece. D Electronic verification of delivery or attempted delivery. a A record of delivery (OMAN the recipient's signature) Mat Is retained by Ulu RASA Sal vice'" for a specified period. Irportwif Rurailidare; You may peggelicr. iswnlind Mall soNrce tv1Ut arrPlor��MaIII�1NRiGHT, JFFFREY$ '70i OWENS DR Ccrdf{eo Mdk asr latematfenai mast LT, CO 81652 e IIrivromi ewer with Certified M' of CetWfied Mail insurance cover certain Priority a For an etldillo iaian. �t,�..,__. endorsementUre mailplet.o, you may request the following =delta: - Relum receipt seavice, which provides emceed' of delivery (Including the recipient's signature). You can request a hardcopy return receipt or an electronic version. For a hardcopy return receipt, complete PS Form 9811, Domestic Return Ifeoofphaitach PS Form 351110 your malipiecc; for an electronic return receipt, see a Marl associate for assistance.To receive a duplicate return receipt for no additional fee, meant Ihi9 USPSO-postmarked Miffed Mall receipt to the retail associate. - Rostriclelnellieryseroirrr,whlnhprnvldAn delivery .ip,th4addroria9peciliad by pame, or to the addressee's authorized agent. • Adult signature oervlca, which requires me $Iyneo to be at least 21 years doge (not 5r 10tailf- &.HIEIDi 1. warm. Imo poslmmkldg. If you deaf rod a postwar k oft this Certified Mall receipt, dela& the barcoded portion of this label, aux it to the mallpiece, apply appropriate postage, and deposit 111e mailplece. which Q1 age Wed quit ) hear a irk on four IMPORTANT: Save (ids recerpl for your records. PS Farm 3800, April 2015 (Reverse) PSN 7530-02.000-9047 Certified Mail service provides A receipt plc portion or the Cartlned Mall rebel), vl Aunique idenllforfor your mrdlpleoo. r Electronic verillcaUon of delivery or attempted delivery. a A record of delivery (Including the recipient's signa{ure) that Isrotalned by llie Postal Service' fore specified perled- the following benefits; tar an electronic return receipt, sue a retell oseocUrte for aaaloiance-Ta tecateae duplicate ratum receipt for no addluonal fee, present -Ude USPS01.poslmeikeel Cerlfflcd Mall recefplla the retail associate. - Restricted deliverysenrlce, which pty 11ea dol€very•ip U(sgtldreseeb spaulffed byname, or to the addressee's authorized agent IRiporiani Ronfhiders: - Adult eignelureserlrlce,wteela requires the u You may purchase Certified Mod ssrvleowllli simmer to be al leest2f years 4f age (col Ri3!•IXOSS r'""� c..r rv...- 0,0,,,..4 orPrteifti( FERGUSON!, GEORGE W & JUDY L� e cellirradM 4066 331 COUNTY RD fntemation ®InsSrencel SILT, CO 81652 with Certlll of CerUlled insolence I certain Pdi e For an add. endefeemnnr onion malrp10000. yea meyro lIIool the folio -who survlcea: - Return receiptSONIes, willed provides a record of delivery !Including Uie recipient's signature). Von can requests hardcopy Mum receipt or an electronic version, For a hardcopy return receipt, complete P5 Form 3011, Domestic Reim Receipt; attach PS Form 3011 to your mailpiece; IrrfPORTAin1t Savo tills receipt for your records. PS Form 3600, April 2015 (Reverse) PSN 7530.02.000.9047 ervlce, which years of ego ca speeiflo d :plied owl let lo Ihould bear a simads on brdyour I • vanilla! Mall Item eta fest Oitice-" 10r posUrlaridng. i1 you eu'l need rr pasrmarlt on this Certified Mail receipt detach the bar coded portion of UIIs!abol, affix It to the nrallpleoe, apply approprlale postage, owl deposit the maliplece. r• Fr'ir i+ritry:infislpjailb7i; JidISriltir vi FiSISe;rd Yvi;f+',usps. gr?i+ :.'; • L .. iiiiiilaillIMI adra'Cas: eesOwke:dem rffaspy dro) ❑ Return Receipt (hardcopy) S [(Return Receipt(eleclronlc) S-74-ualu— ❑ Cerliaed Mall Restricted Delivery $ . g( -I a 1.11 ❑Ad5n Signature Required $--U11i J OAdott.-galweReardotedOetiesry S .11 $ Q Total POStaueand Eep: 59 nslaga lti r9 sartr To Fa Slraedpvii! pf.- a.,ei� Lot); SfelO, Xlar'r I 0 .A ,nJ 0 ri 0 0 0 .11 0 N rR 0 .01V ekre-6" 05 02 POOviniadr • Hero 07/21/2017 0.s "14:041-'- caddied },(04f Certiied Mali Fee $3.35 1..ry75 ra servfaes& 405 (chock ber,ndrlle�Flfi 0 Return Receipt (Hardcopy) $ ['Return Receipt (electronic) 5 LI Corned Mall Restricted Delivery S $0. 00 ❑ Adult Signature Required S El Adult Signature Roctdnled Delivery $ Postage $1:1.49 Total Postage and Fens 59 0543 02 If ri511p ollr if H ire "lilt 07/21/2017 &orf To &rev.arrrllpr: FIe 67 1,3' Cil eters, 20•041' 1,47- • gems PUBLIC NOTICE TAKE NOTICE that Jarad Elder has applied to the Community Development Department Director, Garfield County, State of Colorado, to request an Administrative Review for a Minor Subdivision, in the County of Garfield, State of Colorado; to -wit: Leal Description: Section: 34 Township: 6 Range: 92 TR IN W1/2NE Practical Description: Description of Request: The property is located at 4280 County Road 331, Silt, CO 81652, approximately 3.3 miles south of the Town of Silt. The parcel is located in Section 34, T6S, R92W of the 6th p.m. and known by Assessor Parcel Number 2179-341-00-404. The Applicant is requesting a Land Use Change Permit for a Minor Subdivision on an approximately 5 acre parcel. Both parcels will be served by a shared existing well and separate Onsite Wastewater Treatment Systems. Access is provided off of County Roads 331 and 326. The parcel is zoned Rural. The File Number is MISA-05-17- 8535. Vicinity Map: Please see attached Vicinity Map. All persons affected by the proposed Minor Subdivision are invited to comment regarding the application. You may state your views by letter, email (pwaller@garfleld-county.corn) or you may call the Community Development Department at (970) 945-8212 regarding the application. The Director will give consideration to the comments of surrounding property owners, and others affected, in deciding whether to approve, approve with conditions or deny the request. The application may be reviewed at the office of the Community Development Department located at 108 8th Street, Suite 401, Garfield County Plaza Building, Glenwood Springs, Colorado between the hours of 8:30 a.m. and 5:00 p.m., Monday through Friday. Alternatively, the application can be viewed at http://records.garfield- county.com/WebLink/CustomSearch.aspx7SearchNameBuildingDocumentSearch (Search for File MISA-05-17-8535). The Director will make a determination on this application on Wednesday, August 9, 2017. Any comments to be considered must be received prior to that date. Vicinity Map: Community Development Department Garfield County July 28, 2017 Mr. Patrick Waller Garfield County Planning 108 8th Street, Suite 401 Glenwood Springs, CO 81601 MOUNTAIN CROSS ENGINEERING, INC. Civil and Environmental Consulting and Design RE: Review of the Elder Minor Subdivision: MISA-05-17-8535 Dear Patrick: This office has performed a review of the documents provided for the Elder Minor Subdivision Application. The submittal was found to be thorough and well organized. The review generated the following comments: 1. The Applicant states that drainage requirements are not applicable since the structures are constructed and existing. However, the Applicant should verify that there is positive drainage away from the structures, that there are no areas of shallow ponding, and that existing drainage patterns are not causing erosion or sedimentation problems. 2. The Applicant provides pump tests results from the well from over 15 years ago. Adjacent land uses, additional wells, drought, or other impacts can affect the production of a well over time. The Applicant should provide results of a recent pump test. 3. The Applicant provided water quality testing results that appear to show that E. Coli was detected. The Applicant should verify the results and provide proposed method of treatment or test results showing the absence of E. Coli. Feel free to call if you have any questions or comments. Sincerely, Mountain Cross Engineer ng, h3F. iris Hale, PE 8261/2 Grand Avenue, Glenwood Springs, CO 81601 P: 970.945.5544 F: 970.945.5558 www.mountaincross-eng.com Patrick Waller From: Dan Goin Sent: Tuesday, July 18, 2017 4:11 PM To: Patrick Waller Cc: Dale Stephens Subject: Elder Sub EXHIBIT 1L4 Patrick we have review the application for the Elder Subdivision both of the driveways have aprons and are up to code. Dan Goin District 3 Foreman Garfield County Road and Bridge 0298 CR 333A, Rifle CO 81650 970-625-8601 1 Patrick Waller From: Atwater - DNR, Levi <Ievi.atwater@state.co.us> Sent: Monday, July 10, 2017 7:36 PM To: Patrick Waller Subject: Elder Minor Subdivision Patrick, Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the proposed Minor Subdivision (Elder Minor Subdi , ,sion) located at 4280 County Road 331, Silt, CO 81652. The Garfield County parcel number is 217934100404. The File Number is MISA-05-17-8535. After reviewing this proposal I find no significant wildlife concerns regarding this subdivision. I appreciate Garfield County's willingness to consider wildlife impacts. Levi Atwater DWM - Rifle Sotrith/GMU 42 C 970.985.5882 1 F 970.255.6111 711 Independent Ave., Grand Junction, CO., 81505 tevi.atwater@state.co.us 1 www.cpw.state.co.us Turn in a Poacher 1.877.COLO.OGT 1 COLORADO GEOLOGICAL SURVEY 1801 19th Street Golden, Colorado 80401 August 1, 2017 Patrick Waller, Senior Planner Garfield County Community Development 108 8th Street, Suite 401 Glenwood Springs, CO 81601 EXHIBIT i Location: NW SE Section 34, T6S, R92W, 6th P.M. 39.4889, -107.6508 Karen Berry State Geologist Subject: Elder Minor Subdivision File Number MISA-05-17-8535; Garfield County, CO; CGS Vniuue No. GA -18.0001 Dear Mr. Waller: Colorado Geological Survey has reviewed the Elder minor subdivision referral. I understand the applicant proposes to subdivide a five -acre parcel located at 4280 County Road 331, Silt, creating two parcels. Proposed Parcel B, approximately two acres, contains an existing accessory dwelling unit which will become the primary residence on this parcel. No new construction or improvements are currently proposed. We visited the site on August 1, 2017. We did not observe any surface conditions that would preclude the existing and proposed residential use and density. CGS therefore has no objection to approval of the two -lot subdivision as proposed. However, we have several comments: Rockfall. The existing ADU on proposed Parcel B is located below a small slope containing detached blocks of Wasatch Formation (claystone, siltstone, sandstone, and minor conglomerate). The blocks appear to be stable under current conditions. Future improvements should be located and constructed such that any grading, driveway, foundation, or other cuts do not undercut the slope or otherwise remove any existing material supporting these blocks. Erosion setback from unnamed drainage channel. An unnamed, intermittent drainage channel crosses the site from east to west. No flood hazard zone has been mapped for this drainage. CGS recommends an erosion setback for any future improvements on both proposed lots, to reduce hazards associated not just with rising floodwaters but also erosion and scour. The setback should be determined based on site-specific analysis of topography and soil erosion properties. Thank you for the opportunity to review and comment on this project. If you have questions or need further review, please call me at (303) 384-2643, or email carlson@mines.edu. Sincerely, Jill'Carlson, C.E.G. Engineering Geologist GA -18-0001_1 Elder Minor Subdivision 3:06 PM, 08/01/2017 Colorado River Fire Rescue EXHIBIT 1 7 Patrick Waller 108 8th Street, Suite 201 Glenwood Springs, CO 81601 RE: Elder Minor Subdivision July 31, 2017 Patrick: This letter is to advise you that I have reviewed File Number: MISA-05-17- 8535, Elder Minor Subdivision, located at 4280 CR 331 and 066 CR 326 in Silt. I have no requirements or concerns with this lot split on the existing property including buildings and residences. This lot split will not add any additional impacts to CRFR or our response to that area. Thank you for allowing me to review this referral and please feel free to contact me with any questions or concerns. . Thank You, Orrin D. Moon, Prevention Division Chief/Fire Marshal CRFR COLORADO Division of Water Resources Department of Natural Resources July 31, 2017 Patrick Waller Garfield County Building and Planning Department 108 8th Street, Suite 401 Glenwood Springs, CO 84601 Re: Elder Minor Subdivision, MISA-05-17-8535 Section 34, T6S, R92W, 6th PM Water Division 5, Water District 45 Dear Mr. Waller: EXHIBIT John W. Hickenlooper Governor Robert Randall Executive Director Kevin Rein, P.E. Director/State Engineer We have reviewed the above referenced proposal to subdivide a parcel of approximately five acres into two lots of approximately three acres and two acres. There are currently two residences on the five acres, a primary residence and an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU). Under this proposal, the primary residence will be located on the three acre lot and the ADU will be located on the two acre lot. Water for both residences is currently and will continue to be provided by a shared well and each lot will be served by individual onsite -wastewater treatment systems (OWTS). According to our records, an existing well, Permit No. 55921-F, is located on the five acre parcel. This permit was issued on June 19, 2001 pursuant to CRS 37-90-137(2) for the expansion of use of an existing well. Under this permit, the use of ground water from this well is limited to ordinary household purposes inside two (2) single family dwellings, the irrigation of not more than 2,000 square feet of home gardens and lawns, and the watering of two (2) head of livestock. The average annual amount of ground water to be appropriated shall not exceed 0.934 acre-feet. According to the unsigned Declaration of Water Well Use and Maintenance Obligations agreement included in the referral materials, irrigation uses shall be limited to not more than 750 square feet of lawn and garden irrigation on Lot 2 and 1250 square feet of lawn and garden irrigation on Lot 1. The agreement does not address the use of watering two head of livestock allowed under the well permit. Section 37-92-602(3)(b)(III), C.R.S., requires that the cumulative effect of all wells in a subdivision be considered when evaluating material injury to decreed water rights. The source of the proposed water supply would be from, or tributary to, the Colorado River. This area of the Colorado River is over -appropriated; therefore, an augmentation plan is required to offset depletions caused by the pumping of any wells. The existing well permit, Permit No. 55921-F, was issued on the condition in part, that the well is operated in accordance with the Debra Kay Engelhardt Augmentation Plan approved by the Division 5 Water Court in case no. 2000CW10. Pursuant to Permit 55921-F, the maximum pumping rate of the well shall not exceed 15 gpm. The well was constructed on September 23, 1981 and the permit is valid. According to the Well Completion and Pump Installation Report received on December 10, 1981, after the well was completed an eight hour air lift test was conducted and the well yielded 15 gallons per minute. Office of the State Engineer 1313 Sherman Street, Room 821, Denver, CO 80203 P 303.866.3581 www.water.state.co. us o,: • Patrick Waller, Garfield County Building and Planning Department Elder Minor Subdivision July 31, 2017 Page 2 of 2 However, this office does not have information on the installation of the permanent pump and the sustained yield of the well with the permanent pump. Based on the above, it is our opinion, pursuant to CRS 30-28-136(1)(h)(I), that the proposed water supply will not cause material injury to decreed water rights, so long as the applicant maintains a valid well permit and the augmentation plan is operational. Provided the well continues to have a sustained yield similar to the rate reported in 1981, the water supply should be physically adequate for domestic purposes. Please note that the long term adequacy of any ground water source may be subject to fluctuation due to hydrological and climatic trends. If you or the applicant has any questions concerning this matter, please contact me for assistance MAS: Elder Minor Subdlvlslon CDWRComments.docx cc: Alan Martellaro, Division Engineer Water Commissioner, District 45 Sincerely, Mein Sullivan, P.E. Water Resource Engineer Office of the State Engineer 1313 Sherman Street, Room 821, Denver, CO 80203 P 303.866.3581 www. water. state. co. us Garfield County 195 W. 14th Street Rifle, CO 81650 (970) 625-5200 Garfield County Community Development 108 8th Street Glenwood Springs, CO 81601 Attn: Patrick Waller August 1, 2017 Hello Patrick, Public Health 2014 Blake Avenue Glenwood Springs, CO 81601 (970) 945-6614 I have reviewed the application for the Elder Subdivision and have the following comments: 1. Drinking water: the shared private well that services the two properties has not been tested for water quality since 2003. Water quality tests are recommended every year for private drinking water wells, with more comprehensive tests every five years. Public Heath suggests that the applicant should do a test on the well that is at least as robust as the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment Laboratory Services Division's Deluxe Colorado Package. A water treatment system should be used as necessary to assure safe drinking water for residents. 2. Onsite Wastewater Treatment System: If the owner has not had the septic systems serviced and maintained since 2001, we recommend an inspection and tank pumping if necessary. The status and location of both systems should be known to be in good working order to protect groundwater supplies, including the residents' own drinking water well. Thank you, 1(f2. Morgan Hill Environmental Health Specialist III Garfield County Public Health 195 W. 14th Street Rifle, CO 81650 (970) 665-6383 Garfield County Public Health Department — working to promote health and prevent disease Garfield County Vegetation Management July 31, 2017 Patrick Waller Garfield County Community Development Department RE: MISA-05-17-8535 Elder Minor Subdivision Dear Patrick, Thank you for the opportunity to comment on this permit. Noxious weed inventory and treatments The county listed noxious weeds whitetop, Russian knapweed, and Russian olive are located on the property. It is too late this season to treat whitetop; however Russian knapweed and Russian olive may be treated this fall. Staff requests that the applicant treat the Russian knapweed this fall. Russian olive may be treated by using the cut stump method. Russian olive may be treated effectively in September and October. The County partners with the Conservation Districts on a noxious weed cost -share program that provides for partial financial assistance for noxious weed treatments. The applicant may contact the Vegetation Management Department for information on this program. Please provide this office with treatment records by October 31, 2017 (if any noxious weeds are located). A multi-year treatment program may be necessary. The current list is attached. Sincerely, Steve Anthony Garfield County Vegetation Manager 195 W. 14th Street, Bldg. D, Suite 310 Rifle, CO 81650 Phone: 970-945-1377 x 4305 Mobile Phone: 970-379-4456 Garfield County SURVEYOR SCOTT AIBNER, P.L.S To: George Bauer — George Bauer PLS From: Scott Aibner — Garfield County Surveyor Subject: Plat Review — Re -plat of Lot 4, Block 5, Cordillera Filing 34 Date: 07/31/17 George, Upon review of the Re -plat of Lot 4, Block 5, Cordillera Filing 34 Plat, I have prepared a list of comments or corrections to be made prior to approval for survey content and form as Follows: 1.) Please refer to section 5-402 (F) Final Plat of the Garfield County Land Use Code. Once the plat is complete and correct please re -submit for review. Once these comments have been addressed and all final comments from the Community Development have been completed, the Mylar may be prepared for recording. The Mylar shall be delivered to the Community Development office with all private party signatures no later than Monday the week prior to the next commissioner meeting day in order to make that meeting. Sincerely, Scott Aibner Garfield County Surveyor cc Patrick Waller — Community Development Department 109 8 th Street ,Suite 10B1 • Glenwood Springs, C081601 • (970)945-1377 • Fax: (970)384-3460 • e-mail:saibner@garfeld-countycom Patrick Waller From: Kelly Cave Sent: Thursday, July 27, 2017 10:29 AM To: Patrick Waller Subject: RE: Elder Subdivision MISA 05-17-8535 Hi Patrick—I reviewed the 3rd supplement. EXHIBIT The title commitment was updated. There is a lender so the plat will need a lienholder certificate and signature. The plat should include a plat note that all easements and encumbrances in this updated commitment are referenced on the plat. The new title commitment number should be referenced. Mineral right owners—no additional information was provided. Applicant will need to give us more information on how mineral owners were researched. ILC—it looks ok. I had an issue with the northern access, but you pulled the subdivision exemption legal description for the property and it provided a legal to the southern portion of the road so access should not be a problem. Please let me know if you need anything further from me. Thanks, Kelly Cave Assistant Garfield County Attorney Telephone: (970) 945-9150, ext. 1735 Email: kcave@garfield county.com From: Kelly Cave Sent: Friday, July 07, 2017 1:51 PM To: Patrick Waller <pwaller@garfield-county.com> Subject: RE: Elder Subdivision MISA 05-17-8535 Hi Patrick—I reviewed the 2nd supplement. I have the following outstanding issues: Title commitment—applicant needs to provide an updated title commitment showing current encumbrances on the property. The title insurance policy is from 2005. We need it updated. This will provide us with all current easements or encumbrances and all lenders who have deeds of trusts on the property. Also, the plat should reference the updated commitment to state that all easements of record are shown. Mineral rights—the title work from 2005 shows several reservations of mineral interests. Applicant claimed that he owned all the interests. It looks like the prior owner, Debra Engelhart only owned a 1/8 interest (from the lease under exception 20 of Schedule B). Further research into the mineral interests is needed to make sure all owners are notified. Exception 21 states that potential adverse matters are disclosed on the ILC. I would like a copy of that ILC. The applicant will need to contact Bookcliff Surveying with this ILC reference number. The title work shows 2 lenders so just a note to you that the plat should have lienholder's consent. Thanks, Kelly Cave Assistant Garfield County Attorney Telephone: (970) 945-9150, ext. 1735 Email: kcave u@gaxf eld-county.com From: Kelly Cave Sent: Wednesday, June 28, 2017 10:47 AM To: Patrick Waller <pwaller@garfield-county.com> Subject: RE: Elder Subdivision MISA 05-17-8535 Hi Patrick -I reviewed the supplemental information. Ownership—complete. Title commitment -incomplete. Title commitment provided is for a different property. Mineral research—incomplete. Applicant still needs to explain how mineral interests were researched in accordance with the Section 4-101(E)(1)(b)(4). Please let me know if you need anything further from me. Thanks, Kelly Cave Assistant Garfield County Attorney Telephone: (970) 945-9150, ext. 1735 Email: kcaveagarfteld-county.com From: Kelly Cave Sent: Thursday, May 11, 2017 9:16 AM To: Patrick Waller <pwaller@garfield-county.com> Subject: Elder Subdivision MISA 05-17-8535 Hi Patrick, I reviewed the above referenced file for the following: Ownership—incomplete. No deed or title commitment provided. I recommend asking the applicant for a title commitment to show recorded easements on the property. Also, there is a life estate on a portion of the property. 2 One-half of the couple (Vera Grant) quitclaimed her interest back (I researched the deeds), but I do not know if Kenneth Grant still has an interest. If he has passed away, the death certificate needs to be recorded. Authority—complete. The owner authorized Misty to act on his behalf. Access—looks complete. Just questioned if they have driveway permits with the County Road and Bridge department. 200 foot notice—complete. Mineral notice—incomplete. Applicant needs to explain how mineral interests were researched. Other—as we discussed, I do not know how this 5 acre parcel was created. Was it properly subdivided or was it created prior to subdivision regulations? The applicant should detail how the parcel was created. I have asked Casey to look into this as well. Water—the pump test is old (1981). Applicant should provide a recent pump test. He will probably not want to do this and argue that the houses have adequate water. That will be up to Sheryl to decide if it is adequate. Also, the water sharing agreement needs work to better describe the newly created lots. The agreement should state lot 1 of the subdivision and lot 2 of the subdivision with a reception number of the plat rather than street addresses. I recommend a condition of approval that the water sharing agreement be reviewed and approved by the County Attorney's office prior to final approval. Also, there is a pond that intersects the two lots. If this were a structure, it would need to be moved on to one lot or the other. I am questioning the pond. Are there mutual rights to use it? Let's discuss. Thanks, Kelly Cave Assistant Garfield County Attorney 108 8th Street, Suite 219 Glenwood Springs, CO 81601 Telephone: (970) 945-9150, ext. 1735 Fax: (970) 384-5005 I✓mail: kcave@garfield-county.com 3 :-t : Patrick Waller From: Lois <cotrout1942@comcast.net> Sent: Wednesday, July 26, 2017 2:41 PM To: Patrick Waller Subject: Jared Elder request EXHIBIT 1� My name is Lois Martinez, and I received , registered mail a notice that Jarad Elder has applied to change the zoning for a subdivision. I am assuming this is the area. Where me and my family owns mineral rights. For gas wells . I have no problem with the rezoning as long as he understands, He can not interfere with anything that affect the income of my family from the gas wells . Lois Martinez 1