HomeMy WebLinkAboutExhibit50_PettetExhii
r Date
i
DISTRICT COURT, GARFIELD COUNTY,
COLORADO
109 8th Street, Suite 104
Glenwood Springs, CO 81601
(970) 928-3065
Plaintiff:
ST. FINNBAR HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, a
Colorado nonprofit corporation,
V.
Defendant:
RANCH AT ROARING FORK HOMEOWNERS
ASSOCIATION, INC., a Colorado nonprofit
corporation.
Atlorneys for Defendant:
James F. Fosnaught, Esq. #31820
Jeffrey J. Conklin, Esq. #40194
KARP NEU HANLON, P.C.
201 14th St. Suite 200
P.O. Drawer 2030
Glenwood Springs, CO 81602
Tel.: (970) 945-2261
Fax: (970) 945-7336
j ff2mountainlawfirm.com
ID: B3CBEA3559F43
NUMBER: 2022CV30052
♦COURT USE ONLY
Case Number: 2022CV30052
Div.: Ctrm.:
DEFENDANTS' ANSWER, AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES AND COUNTERCLAIMS
Defendant, Ranch at Roaring Fork Homeowners Association, Inc., by and through their
undersigned counsel of record, Karp Neu Hanlon, P.C., submit the following Answer, Affirmative
Defenses, and Counterclaims to Plaintiffs' Complaint.
I. PARTIES, JURISDICTION, AND VENUE
1. Admit.
2. Admit.
o
s
s
s a
CL
�:s
=
CD
aD
CD
v CL
CIL 0�
cD
iD
m
m
cv
= CD
O n
(D
�,
�•S
�•S
077
0�
CD
(D
c
�'
S
S
O y
CD
S
O
O
O
rD
cn
40
(D
CL
�
CL
CL
CL
O� (D CD
o
a
as
CD
oo
ut�
�, r- o
o
0
O
O
O
O
y
S
O
,
(D
w
CD
(D
Ln
CD
ocD
CD
rD
-
D
o•
o•
o
o
CD
CD
`
o
0
0
P.
n
N
1
(D
O•
(SD
S
FD
CD
-�
--
CD
--
CD
CD
(D (D
(D
O
Q.
Cl.
Cl.
c0D
_
<
CD
S
S
0c
S
c0�
W cn
O
O
(D
�
(D
!D
•�—c
(D
(D
N
S
cn
(D
CAD
(CD
((DD
r�r
(D
`.e-
S
�
ig
r.
V)
CD 0
ram-.
CD
CD
CD
EnEn
� w
-�
CD
o 0ono
S
CD
S
f D
°
°
CD
S
a �D
S
v CD
S
`�
S
`D
c
uo
-,
cro
ao
na
O
O
n
UD
O
n
A
O
O S
N
Ci
cn S
in S
cn
...
�
. [v'D
cn S
cn • S
to S
n
,•-•
in S
in • S
CD
w
CD
v,
CD cn
CD L7
� L7
CD
CD _ •
O
: i
FL
O
O
cn
..
O
O
O
ry 0
CD
O
p
rD
rD
oil
CL
O.
CD
`%�
p..
O..
O..
�'
D
rD
UO
CD
(TQ
CD
p
CD
d
Cp
UO
0
UQ
CD
QO
CD
—
(Jp
CD
rD CD O
-z
O
O
CD
rr
O
O
O
p
O w
0
Cr
O
O
CD
m C17
O
O
O
CD
o
C
to
V'
p
Do
CSD
w
w
w
w
wcr
CD
m
�,
CSD
CSD^
w
CD
C D
CD
D
w
O
CL
CD
—
CD
-
CD
0-
CD
CD
w
w
w
CD
w
..
S CD
n
a
O.
a
fl.
C
a
CAD
S
SCD
CD
Ul
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
C^D
CD
fD
(D
0
CDw
CD
�' lD
O x
O
O
N
O
O
O
O
[D
N
CAD
0
N
N
(D
n
Oh a
CD
CD
CD
CD
CD
fD
O
(D
CD UO
4�.
.�-
-P6
-P�
4�6
--
0
a.
a
a.
CL
a
Un
N
O
o
p
S
W
=
A
CD
w
3
A
O 3
h
LA
LIP)
roOil
C
(D
�7
r
�
a
A
A
w
�
ro
�
O
O
V)
CD
CD
O
O
CD
CD
W
O
W W
00 -]
W
W
W
W
W
>
�U AV
�U
-s
cD CD
— N
0
lD
Q.
CD
a.
Ay
CD
a �, •
o
fD
(D
v
_
S
fD
fD
h
O
�
O
A
CD
rA
CD
CD
A
p�
CD
0.
L.
CCD
CD
O
-S
fD
O
�
(D
O
CD
fD
r eo1
w
N
0-0
CD O CD
C.
a.
rn " ti
LnCD
o
"
CD
ro
n O CC4
CD
Q
n
n C:r
C
0
w
CCD
�
s
D S
V
�- E
E
CD
CD
CD
�.
- s
�
CD
=r
CD
CD
w
C)
o
r
o
c.
CD
¢i
CD
� s
(4 CD
o
Ln Ln C
B Q.
CD
cn
�n
cn
t n
to
to
v,
41.
�
A
�O
Oo
�]
�
�_
fl.
O..
p
C.
Q
!�
G�
CD
fl
fl.
Q
Q.
O..
A:
P7
=
n
n
fnin
s
s
CD
(D
CD
CD
CD
rD*
0-
"�
oilA—
Oil
0
cr
Q
1
w
CD
0
CD
CD
a�
�
C�
aro
vo
4
CD N
C CD
�
a
�,
�
•� w
r�
�.
o
a
z
CD
z
rO
,�
�
C7
c. -�
2
� �
o•
o.
CD
a
--
�
C�7
a °'
-�
ro
rD
0
CD
L-1
Cr
rD
9T
A a
CD
CD
CD
S
CL
e
-n
BCD
CDrp
n-1
0
C'
CD
s
rD
O CD
.O
•O• O -�
I'D
00
v
C�
t•n
y
�
O
° -t P�
cN7
cS9
S
S :1
>=
R
�
�
'•�
c
�
lD
.-y
�. (JQ
�
yr
to
A S
l2 Sr
(D
_O
p
i. n
fD to
CD
(D
w-�
UQ (D
�
°" g
O
v
0
CD
to O
UQ
a,
(D
CD
I
;
�'.m .�
CD
a
n
yLA �
o
CL
CD
r'CL
a
�,
CDCD
°
>v
< C:
°
O °
W
�.� °
'a
-ti
ao
D �.
m
CD
❑-
(D
O cn
<
s
(DCA
`< cn
to
(D p
(D
..,
0
S
= �
� A
cv'n
O
(D O
CD
c
C
A�
�
�
O
177 to
Cl.
.�.
0 O
p :
UQ C)
(D
rA
CD
�<73
CD
CL
m
CD
CD
N 'T?
CD
s
`° aQ
c
CD
`°
El
n)
^t
00 r.
(D
cr (D
CD
0
CD
a.
o
.9
o
u ¢
�'
CD
2
Z,
'�
vo
C
n
O A
n
(D cr
`Z7
V�i •
UOQ
= D
�'
O.. CD
n
r
...� / 'o � •'o w m o 'a f� s
N0J00:' CD
CD • 3 p CD � C O AD S
.O-' � � n •,.1� �." 'fo[ti+e'ii•• •l.•1 . _ � • Y3_• .-. AY � �' � (D ("*D CD S
C/l CO)S n .� 0. 0. t D
00
n pOj Ali k A7 O S d n
n r+
do . y < CP CD
(D
CD
CD
_ CD
P� O OZ'£CZ N OO.O�.gFJN . -., O CD �• Cu
Y _ 44 7R ,, CD
w o
oo CAD , %; �� : •+ : : : : : : Q-• CD S n LA ° w
CD
rL
uOV1 W CD CD
CD C) CD
CD
CL
CL
a cD
! O77
CL
40
CD rD
all t,/ Do O
UQ �A 'D c07
It
•' ' +% •a' i �•' iTi. .Lii%tN�7c %\ - �'�i O = '� CD G • cr
Q.•,,1'o\` 4 ` O dp p r% ,�•..
CL
tA � CD p'Oj •� to
0 R€ •� ��S age 35� �'� ./K ry � CD a CD w CDEs
0
C
Cr1
r
a
rAOWNI 1
u
W
O
C
CL
z
00
cD
0o
v
41.
w
-v cn
a
I Ayr-
w
m o
y;"
"
0
o
CD
o
O C
a p
A) .+
CD
:. O p) -,
a .0..o
CD 20
'
BCD
A�S7
0
> CD O.
`o o
•
.�-�
n
s'.
�..i
N
N s1
n
S N
.¢
—
'W.. �. CD
A
w
`�
A 00 CD UQ
2 : c S
�.. O
C>
t'j
CL
CD
En
CD
s- s
'^i '"y')
C)
CD
rD
00 CD
k ^•t w
s n ° :
w
C/1
CD
CD
p
N o a
CL 'a
a'
r+
CD
M a
`co s
^ems
�t
-3 CD Ln'
� ,
�,
CD
0000
<
CD Cl. o,
' Y
o `cs
S iD
CL
m
o
O
H
r.
O
z
n
v W
<
CD O �•
o Z)
r)>
�<
n
n
tD
rD CD �
.
O
S
CD
a O =
n
E CD
(Do
tom n
fn <•
0.o
R O SID
-O
= `l7 N
En
0.
O
E a
EL
O
P?
N
�,'
O
00
..
,�CD
cD
rA
O
A7
CD
w
s
't7
a.
O O
O
rD
CD
cD
(A
o
a
00
m
W
O
00
:
p
CD _
� J
O Cr
O
SID J
O.
W
N
O .O
v
v�i 0. CSD CSD
f<D
CD
QO :1
o o a
— y `• O
A= o�
� o J
� O
<' z
CD N
Q O
O' N
n
� � C
N
6
� � N
o
� O
CD
0
0
4
0
= O s (D p UR fTQ CD C CD
O n CD Ln
O N n O cn
_ En
O S " rA
CD CD (n20 0 CSD • CD (�9 S
Ln
cr
<D' CD ^h SCD $13
�• CD (D Vi OCD Co CD 0
• S
QCD CD CD CD
0 CD
a O
' O BCD FD ' n CD (D _ 0
(D CD v w fD ' W poc
c
d S i S
N O CAD ap � S - A
CN P fD p w < O
CD O L7 .- CD Q
� CSD � v�i O � ` � • � p: .�
n SrD
Ln LA
CD
'TI CD
Cl.rD
W n
(D N
CD Q CR. CD C' CD .0 +; CD CD b
p1 (SD CD bQ O "1
w O S ¢� CD 15' Al ti w a
C) CD O fDu y 1 CD .O.
CD .Cn+ CD
��
< CD
CD o' � -n 'a n
o0. o Ln
G v^t CD CD (p CDCD
O_
Ln
CD O N CD � h
� O Q w
r I }
N
O
oh w
00 v'
n rD
w
CD
d
w
a
A
O
C
A
CD
CL
w
n.
w
w
A
S
CD
a
S
G
�D o0
-j
S rD
� CD o
-o in w
rD
CD ' . A
o fD
� � w
Q
� w
fD A n
O S S
CAD �G CD
O a w
(D
� 0 �
� � w
CD r<D
Y �
S �
�) CD w
CAD [D A
a
cr
p� S
?Om1
o
S
N
�< n
CD s
n �
C
CD
O �
...n O
U4 c,
O
0 �
`TJ V7
Q4 `�
m �
C7
CD
C..
z
0
D
r elo1
Irl
W
W
tJ
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
O
�O
OO
00
O
O_
w
..
.
..
p CD
3
CD
rD CD
CD
n CD
CD
`�
'77
`t7
CD
CD
S
S
S
7
co
(f4 B
S
S
S
�
y
p _»
°
`n
w
w
�' �'
CD
CD
°
o
CD
CL
CD
CIL
--
=
CL �
o
CD
p
v
CD
n-
N CD Q
Con
CD
" 3
E
�?
Y
�
x
�
o-
Q.
o
�
0�0
°—'
C�D
�
C°
CD
a
r0
o
CD
CD —
o
-:
°
V"
CLCD
--1
°
c
w
w
cr
o
cn
�' s "~'
=
�
o
tea.
.o
"'
� �
w
o
r. �•
C.
'Tl
lA-9 O
CD
CD
C
s
fD
n
D
CD
C9
w
o
w
n
CD
O
=
Uq'
N
CD
—
DD
Q.
'*
CD
c
s
ro
CD
C:
C
o
wJ
n
x c
CD
s
`a
rrDD
ArD
C
n
UO
w
rD
C -e
o°
f°
y
o
w
3
0
°
cro'
x
�►
s
e
-,�
own
ID v
w
C
CroCD
c°
w
w
A.
>—
°
Lh
Y
CD
rn
�
S C>
CD
^ h
�
O
<
n
w
CD
A�
••�
�
CL
-�
I
bo
S
w
cD
t�
CD
fD Cu
CD
a
y
CD
ry
^
CD
VCDi
CD
-O
�i
C
rDrDD
�
r /0�
=
0
CD o
O
O A
N
S
A ry
= w
CL
w •a
a.
rD
o
-�
m
-�
o
��
o-
--3
CD
rD
¢ ON =
CL
CD
rww
�
CD
[ADD
.0
A
N i w
UO
CD
O
O
O
N
'►
wCD
A�
..
v
Q. w
CND
Z
CD
rD
r�
A
K
h
A
rD
CDD
.+
A
D
rD
CD
S (D O
O
S
G
m
�_
O
�
O
CD
°7
w
�
a
y
rD
rD
�'
o
w
(D �' -
w
<
0.
CDaq
q
-�i
�'
d
O
(D
p-
C
rD
CD
CD
O
A
CD
CD
•,
w
w
s
A7 w
�a
--.
'-.
C/�
-z
vwi
CD
A�
A
CD
0
CD
un
-*�
rD c�'D
S
S
CD
-�
�:r
to
A
A
S
rD
''
UQ
O
A
.�
�'
UQ
w
•rDD
rD
s
rD
¢'•
rD o
Q. C4
<
CD
S
w
rD
�,
0
O
w
SrD
CL
rD
CD
A
rD
�N.
lD
A
<
CD
CD
A
'
7
O
v,
N w
CD
N¢
'
°
OQ
N
S
x
O
Qq
w
k
O
�.
S CD
�
-b
CSD
-1
A�
rD
y
0
-+
w
-a rD
w
cD
`0CL
0
-:
C
cD
�'
rD
m
o
°
Ora
m
o
0a
CD
o
<
cr
C0.D
D
w
O
O
O
S
w
ti
O vCD
N
CD
CA7
•a
S
p:
7
z
n
CD
a O
w
_
°
OrD
-T7
AD
j
cAD
r
d
CD
as
rD
o
w
D
o
'a
°
ELcn
0
CD
w
CD
CD �_
CD
-z
w
N
CD'
n
O
�
N
H
T.
cn-
E3
Es
w
0.
O
S
Q
A
O
S
0
(SD
--1
rD
v�
n
A
o•
m
S
v
A
(D
i
i
CD
R
r 'ON,
I3��"����o�D�
�
.a,
A
A'•� �
'� O
U7nz� w �
O O�� a 'T7
c?
rn p
te•
z
m
y �.n
00 o— n
O . cD
a ril na
AGE
�a��.
CD
n N
CD
o N�
C7�,��
>
b
r CD
R
rb CD
M
m
Dv
P
w
CAD
00 O
CD
00
N S
fD
CD
r
co y
O
O'
�CD
a �
A
o�
a
cD • .y
C �
yA
oil
s
X
CD
CD
A
G
ct
a
V)
O
N
CD
t.N
O
N
N