HomeMy WebLinkAbout06 Trip Generation and Site Access Report 02.28.2019Benchmark Project No. 250009
TRIP GENERATION AND SITE ACCESS REPORT
LONGACRE EQUINE CAMPSITES
February 28, 2019
Prepared for:
LONGACRE EQUINE
2101 CR 245
New Castle, CO 81647
Prepared by:
Benchmark Civil Engineering Services, Inc.
1727 W. Jonathan Street
Allentown, PA 18104
RE&IST EREU
PROFES.TJONAL
PETER 4. TERRY
..." 't
041437.E
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. INTRODUCTION 1
II. PROJECTED TRIP GENERATION 1
III. ACCESS REQUIREMENTS 2
APPENDIX A - ITE TRIP GENERATION MANUAL 10TH ED.
APPENDIX B - VEHICLE PATH
Trip Generation and Site Access Report
Longacre Equine Campsites February 28, 2019
I. INTRODUCTION
Benchmark Civil Engineering Services, Inc., (Benchmark) has been retained by Longacre
Equine to evaluate the anticipated trip generation and access requirements for their
proposed addition of 12 campsites. The site is located at 2101 CR 245, New Castle, CO.
II. PROJECTED TRIP GENERATION
The National standard to projecting the trip generation for a proposed use is the Institute
of Transportation Engineers publication "Trip Generation" (ITE Trip Generation Manual)
which is currently in its 10th Edition. The trip generation manual includes studies of
numerous land uses including Use 416 Campground/Recreational Vehicle Park. This
land use category is appropriate for the proposed Longacre Equinel2 campsites. The
data available in the ITE Trip Generation Manual is limited to identifying the weekday
AM and PM peak periods of projected trips. The table below indicates the projected trips
for this site. Typical for many land uses, the peak hour of traffic is 15% of the total daily
traffic so the table below indicates both the weekday AM and PM peak hours as well as
the weekday average trips. The table also includes the trip generation associated with the
three existing single family residential houses and the barn/boarding operation which are
also accessed via the driveway. Any additional use of the driveway would be associated
with the adjacent agricultural operations and would not occur on a daily basis.
The table indicates that the heaviest traveled peak hour will be 10 trips and the average
daily number of trips will be 73.
* Based on peak hour being 15% of the Average Daily Traffic (ADT).
** Based on observations of facility operator
250009
Appendix A provides copies of the ITE Trip Generation Manual description and data,
1
Projected Trip Generation
AM Peak Trips
PM Peak Trips
ADT
Trips
Enter
Exit
Total
Enter
Exit
Total
2
3
5
3
2
5
34*
12 Campsites ITE Use #416
3 Ext. Single Family
Residential Units
1
1
2
1
2
3
29
ITE Use # 210
Barn/Boarding Operation**
1
1
2
1
1
2
10
TOTAL
4
5
9
5
5
10
73
* Based on peak hour being 15% of the Average Daily Traffic (ADT).
** Based on observations of facility operator
250009
Appendix A provides copies of the ITE Trip Generation Manual description and data,
1
Trip Generation and Site Access Report
Longacre Equine Campsites February 28, 2019
III. ACCESS REQUIREMENTS
The majority of the 73 projected daily trips per day will be automobile trips. The
AASHTO Green Book includes typical vehicle path requirements and roadway width
requirements for different classes of vehicles. The largest typical (widest and largest
vehicle path) vehicles will be the single unit trucks which will service the portable toilet
pump trucks. These vehicles would be classified as SU 40 trucks (single unit total length
40 feet). This vehicle is eight feet wide and has a turning path maximum width of 14.8
feet. Based on Table 7-107:Roadway Standards the site driveway would be classified as
"Semi Primitive with eight foot wide lanes and two foot wide shoulders. The roadway
should have a gravel surface.
The existing roadways within the property can accommodate the path of a single unit
truck or large passenger vehicle (van).
Appendix B includes copies of the truck turning path for the SU -40 vehicle.
The Garfield County Colorado Land Use and Development Article 7: Standards (Table
7-107 Roadway Standards) indicates that a Semi Primitive Driveway should provide eight
foot wide lanes and two foot wide shoulders and that the roadway can have a gravel
surface. The existing site driveway provides these requirements as does the existing
internal roadway system. Any additional internal roadway segments will also meet this
design standard. The design standards and proposed/existing features are included in the
table below.
250009 2
Trip Generation and Site Access Report
Longacre Equine Campsites
February 28, 2019
Table 7-107: Roadway Standards
Design Standards
Simi Primitive
Existing
Design Capacity (ADT)
21-100
21-100
Minimum ROW Width (Feet)
40
40
Lane Width (Feet)
8
8
Shoulder Width (Feet)
2
2
Ditch Width (Feet)
4
4
Cross Slope
2% Chip/Seal
3% Gravel
3% Gravel
Shoulder Slope
5%
5%
Design Speed
N/A
N/A
Minimum Radius (Feet)
50
50
Maximum % Grade
12
12
Surface
Gravel
Gravel
250009 3
APPENDIX A - ITE TRIP GENERATION MANUAL 10TH ED.
Trip Generation and Site Access Report
Longacre Equine Campsites February 28, 2019
Land Use: 416
Campground/Recreational Vehicle Park
Description
A campground and recreational vehicle park is a recreational site that accommodates campers,
trailers, tents, and recreational vehicles on a transient basis. They are found in a variety of locations
and provide a variety of facilities, often including restrooms with showers and recreational facilities,
such as a swimming pool, convenience store, and Laundromat.
Additional Data
The sites were surveyed in the 1990s, the 2000s, and the 2010s in Rhode Island, Vermont, and
Washington.
Source Numbers
401, 559, 728
24 Trip Generation Manual 10th Edition • Volume 2: Data • Recreational (Land Uses 400-499)
250009
Appendix A A - 1
IM'illr
X
5 X
1/7/2019 https://itetripgen.org/PrintGraph.htm?code=416&ivlabel=PESCP&timeperiod=TAGEN&x=12&edition=385&IocationCode=General Urban/S...
Trip Generation and Site Access Report
Longacre Equine Campsites February 28, 2019
Campground/Recreational Vehicle Park
(416)
Vehicle Trip Ends vs: Occupied Campsites
On a: Weekday,
AM Peak Hour of Generator
Setting/Location: General Urban/Suburban
Number of Studies: 6
Avg. Num. of Occupied Campsites: 95
Directional Distribution: 36% entering, 64% exiting
Vehicle Trip Generation per Occupied Camp Site
Average Rate Range of Rates
Standard Deviation
0.25 0.19 - 0.42 0.09
Data Plot and Equation
T = Trip Ends
60
50
40
30
20
10
00 50 100 150 200 250 300
X = Number of Occupied Campsites
Fitted Curve Average Rate
3
12
X
X
X
X
X Study Site
!!11 pp Fitted Curve Equation: Ln(T) = 0.81 Ln(X) - 0.50 R2= 0.92
https://itetrip5.�d�W��11:tintGraph.htm?code=416&ivlabel=PESCP&timeperiod=TAGEN&x=12&edition=385&IocationCode=General%20Urban/Suburban... 1/2
Appendix A A - 2
1/7/2019 https://itetripgen.org/PrintGraph.htm?code=416&ivlabel=PESCP&timeperiod=TPGEN&x=12&edition=385&IocationCode=General Urban/S...
Trip Generation and Site Access Report
Longacre Equine Campsites February 28, 2019
Campground/Recreational Vehicle Park
(416)
Vehicle Trip Ends vs: Occupied Campsites
On a: Weekday,
PM Peak Hour of Generator
Setting/Location: General Urban/Suburban
Number of Studies: 3
Avg. Num. of Occupied Campsites: 60
Directional Distribution: 62% entering, 38% exiting
Vehicle Trip Generation per Occupied Camp Site
Average Rate Range of Rates
Standard Deviation
0.41 0.38 - 0.57 0.07
Data Plot and Equation
Caution — Small Sample S
T = Trip Ends
60
50
40
30
20
10
00 50 100 150 200
X = Number of Occupied Campsites
X Study Site Average Rate
5
12
X
X
X
��11
Fitted Curve Equation: Not Given R2= ****
https://itetrip5.Q�W���11pp tintGraph.htm?code=416&ivlabel=PESCP&timeperiod=TPGEN&x=12&edition=385&IocationCode=General%20Urban/Suburban... 1/2
Appendix A A - 3
Trip Generation and Site Access Report
Longacre Equine Campsites February 28, 2019
Land Use: 210
Single -Family Detached Housing
Description
Single-family detached housing includes all single-family detached homes on individual lots. A typical
site surveyed is a suburban subdivision.
Additional Data
The number of vehicles and residents had a high correlation with average weekday vehicle trip ends.
The use of these variables was limited, however, because the number of vehicles and residents
was often difficult to obtain or predict. The number of dwelling units was generally used as the
independent variable of choice because it was usually readily available, easy to project, and had a
high correlation with average weekday vehicle trip ends.
This land use included data from a wide variety of units with different sizes, price ranges, locations,
and ages. Consequently, there was a wide variation in trips generated within this category. Other
factors, such as geographic location and type of adjacent and nearby development, may also have
had an effect on the site trip generation.
Single-family detached units had the highest trip generation rate per dwelling unit of all residential
uses because they were the largest units in size and had more residents and more vehicles per unit
than other residential land uses; they were generally located farther away from shopping centers,
employment areas, and other trip attractors than other residential land uses; and they generally had
fewer alternative modes of transportation available because they were typically not as concentrated
as other residential land uses.
Time -of -day distribution data for this land use are presented in Appendix A. For the six general
urban/suburban sites with data, the overall highest vehicle volumes during the AM and PM on a
weekday were counted between 7:15 and 8:15 a.m. and 4:00 and 5:00 p.m., respectively. For the
two sites with Saturday data, the overall highest vehicle volume was counted between 3:00 and 4:00
p.m. For the one site with Sunday data, the overall highest vehicle volume was counted between
10:15 and 11:15 a.m.
The sites were surveyed in the 1980s, the 1990s, the 2000s, and the 2010s in California,
Connecticut, Delaware, Illinois, Indiana, Maryland, Minnesota, Montana, New Jersey, North Carolina,
Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Vermont, and Virginia.
Source Numbers
100, 105, 114, 126, 157, 167, 177, 197, 207, 211, 217, 267, 275, 293, 300, 319, 320, 356, 357, 367,
384, 387, 407, 435, 522, 550, 552, 579, 598, 601, 603, 614, 637, 711, 716, 720, 728, 735, 868, 903,
925, 936
Its
250009
Appendix A
Trip Generation Manual 10th Edition • Volume 2: Data • Residential (Land Uses 200-299) 1
A-4
2/28/2019 https://itetripgen.org/PrintGraph.htm?code=210&ivlabel=UNITS210&timeperiod=AWDVTE&x=3&edition=385&IocationCode=General Urb...
Trip Generation and Site Access Report
Longacre Equine Campsites February 28, 2019
Single -Family Detached Housing
(210)
Vehicle Trip Ends vs: Dwelling Units
On a: Weekday
Setting/Location:
Number of Studies:
Avg. Num. of Dwelling Units:
Directional Distribution:
General Urban/Suburban
159
264
50% entering, 50% exiting
Vehicle Trip Generation per Dwelling Unit
Average Rate Range of Rates
9.44
Standard Deviation
4.81 - 19.39
2.10
Data Plot and Equation
20,000
10,000
5,000
X Study Site
xx
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
500 1,000 1,500
X = Number of Dwelling Units
Fitted Curve
2,000
2,500
Average Rate
x
3,000
�1p
Fitted Curve Equation: Ln(T) = 0.92 Ln(X) + 2.71 R2= 0.95
https://itetripc 5.�1 'O0AntGraph.htm?code=210&ivlabel=UNITS210&timeperiod=AWDVTE&x=3&edition=385&IocationCode=General%20Urban/Subur... 1/2
Appendix A A - 5
2/28/2019 https://itetripgen.org/PrintGraph.htm?code=210&ivlabel=UNITS210&timeperiod=TASIDE&x=3&edition=385&IocationCode=General Urba...
Trip Generation and Site Access Report
Longacre Equine Campsites February 28, 2019
Single -Family Detached Housing
(210)
Vehicle Trip Ends vs: Dwelling Units
On a: Weekday,
Peak Hour of Adjacent Street Traffic,
One Hour Between 7 and 9 a.m.
Setting/Location: General Urban/Suburban
Number of Studies: 173
Avg. Num. of Dwelling Units: 219
Directional Distribution: 25% entering, 75% exiting
Vehicle Trip Generation per Dwelling Unit
Average Rate Range of Rates
Standard Deviation
0.74 0.33 - 2.27 0.27
Data Plot and Equation
T = Trip Ends
2,000
1,500 X
1,000
X V500 �yy
X' X,
X JC`X
' X*
X Study Site
X
X
X
500 1,000 1,500
X = Number of Dwelling Units
2,000
X
2,500 3,000
Fitted Curve Average Rate
!1 p Fitted Curve Equation: T = 0.71(X) + 4.80 R2= 0.89
https://itetrip5.�d�W�1:tintGraph. htm?code=210&ivlabel=U N ITS210&timeperiod=TAS I D E&x=3&edition=385&IocationCode=General%20U rban/Suburb... 1/2
Appendix A A - 6
2/28/2019 https://itetripgen.org/PrintGraph.htm?code=210&ivlabel=UNITS210&timeperiod=TPSIDE&x=3&edition=385&IocationCode=General Urba...
Trip Generation and Site Access Report
Longacre Equine Campsites February 28, 2019
Single -Family Detached Housing
(210)
Vehicle Trip Ends vs: Dwelling Units
On a: Weekday,
Peak Hour of Adjacent Street Traffic,
One Hour Between 4 and 6 p.m.
Setting/Location: General Urban/Suburban
Number of Studies: 190
Avg. Num. of Dwelling Units: 242
Directional Distribution: 63% entering, 37% exiting
Vehicle Trip Generation per Dwelling Unit
Average Rate Range of Rates
Standard Deviation
0.99 0.44 - 2.98 0.31
Data Plot and Equation
T = Trip Ends
2,500
2,000
1,500
1,000
500
X
00
X Study Site
X
x
X
X
500 1,000 1,500
X = Number of Dwelling Units
2,000
x
2,500 3,000
Fitted Curve Average Rate
�1p Fitted Curve Equation: Ln(T) = 0.96 Ln(X) + 0.20 R2= 0.92
https://itetrip5.�1 'Oi�W�tintGraph.htm?code=210&ivlabel=UN ITS210&timeperiod=TPSIDE&x=3&edition=385&IocationCode=General%20Urban/Suburb... 1/2
Appendix A A - 7
APPENDIX B - VEHICLE PATH
Trip Generation and Site Ace s Repo
LqneNtd Spline Campsites Feburary 28; 2019
AASH
0
A Policy on
Geometric Design of
Highways and Streets
Trip Generation and Site Access Report
Longacre Equine Campsites
2-66
A Policy on Geometric Design of Highways and Streets
Path of left
front wheel
[3.20 m]
[7.62 m]
39.5 ft
[1.22 m]
[12.04 m]
0 5ft 10ft
0 t m 2.5 m
Seale
5 f 1011
0 1m 2.5m
Scale
18.0 ft I
[2.44 m]
Path of right
rear wheel
o Max. steering angle is 31.8°
o CTR = Centerline turning
radius at front axle
February 28, 2019
Path of front
overhang
Figure 2-12. Minimum Turning Path for Single -Unit Truck (SU -40 [SU -12]) Design Vehicle
250009
Appendix B
B-2
Generation and Site Access Report
gacre Equine Campsites
50009
pendia B
February 28, 2019
Design Controls and Criteria
2.3 ft
[0.69 m]
o -o
27.0 ft
4.0 ft
[1.22 m]
[8.23 m]
12.0 ft
17.7 ft
5,0 ft 11.0 ft
[3,66 m
[5.39 m]
48.7 ft
[1.52 m] [3.35 m]
19.0 ft
[5.79 m]
3.0 ft
Path of [eft
front wheel
[14.84 m]
5 f 10 ft
III NI II
m 2,5 m
Scale
El
8.0ff
[2.44 m]
I�
0 1 m 2.5 m
Scale
Path of right
rear wheel
® Max. steering angle is 21.5°
• CTR = Centerline turning
radius at front axle
• AAI = 47.2°
[0.91 m]
Path of front
overhang
Figure 2-30. Minimum Turning Path for Passenger Car and Camper Trailer (P/T) Design
Vehicle
B-3
2-83